New on the site: Michi-bot. An intelligent assistant based on the writings of Rabbi Michael Avraham.

A student of the Tashbar on the sanctity of the seventh in a foreign crop

שו”תCategory: HalachaA student of the Tashbar on the sanctity of the seventh in a foreign crop
מיכי Staff asked 4 years ago

I accidentally deleted the question. I’m reposting it here:
I grew up in Bnei Brak and studied in the Talmud Torah in the Beit Chazo\”a [Tishber] when it was the year of Shemitah. Some of the students practiced Kedushat Shevi’it with leftover fruit and vegetables even though they came from non-Jewish crops. Some did not. When I inquired, I was taught that Kedushat Shevi’it does not practice non-Jewish crops except for the Chazonishniks who practice it [a few percent of the population] and a few Ba’al Teshuvah [whose tendency to be strict is understandable…] Similarly, in my parents’ house and the neighbors did not practice this strictness. Now I saw a book by a respected Rabbi Srog who writes that indeed there is no need to practice the practice of the seventh-day holy harvest of Gentiles except in Bnei Brak, where the custom of the prophet “A” was accepted to practice the practice of the seventh-day holy harvest. Therefore, and accordingly, in Bnei Brak, this is how it should be practiced. That rabbi is mistaken in reality. Yemenite Sephardim and Hasidim of course do not practice this way in Bnei Brak [and they are the majority]. The Lithuanians in reality on the ground, only a minority of them actually practice this way. Is therefore the halakha different from what that rabbi wrote? [He is mistaken in reality]
 
 

Leave a Reply

0 Answers
מיכי Staff answered 4 years ago

This is an ancient dispute that did not begin with the Chazo’a. The Me’bit disagrees with the Be’i.
In any case, some see the Chazva as a Mera Da’atra of Bnei Brak (just as Rabbi Ovadia claims that Israel is a Damran Da’atra). But there is no real basis for this. Therefore, even if you are Lithuanian, I do not see a need to act this way. Beyond that, if you have your own halakhic position, then the custom should not be relevant to you at all.
I have a good friend who was a rabbi in Tshabbar. Did you study with Shefsel Roth? 🙂

R’ Shaspel Roth was saved from being the starving in the class I studied in…
I studied in the same class as his son Yoel.
Indeed a charming man and full of joy.

Leave a Reply

Back to top button