New on the site: Michi-bot. An intelligent assistant based on the writings of Rabbi Michael Avraham.

The Haredim were right.

שו”תCategory: generalThe Haredim were right.
asked 9 months ago

Following the recent deal and the realization that many soldiers apparently died in vain (obviously there were other goals besides destroying Hamas, such as restoring deterrence and negating enemy capabilities. But the bottom line is that the main mission of destroying Hamas was not achieved due to pressure from the Deep State and the Kaplanist left), does it make sense to say that the Haredim were right in their refusal not to die in vain?


Discover more from הרב מיכאל אברהם

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

Leave a Reply

0 Answers
מיכי Staff answered 9 months ago
Are you really asking? It’s insulting to answer this nonsense.

Discover more from הרב מיכאל אברהם

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

לוחם replied 9 months ago

For many years I have thought that it is possible that it is forbidden to enlist.
When I was in the army as a soldier on the first day, they explained to us that if there is an order with a black flag flying over it, it is forbidden to obey it and they emphasized this with examples and explanations.
Nowadays, over 90% of the army orders have a black flag flying just because Bibi is the ”supreme commander” any person with sense and a little deep/psychological insight knows that he is a narcissist whose *only* thing he is interested in is to rule, and that interests him even more than the lives of soldiers (unfortunately) and the victory of the State of Israel or any other value.
I was in Gaza on various operations and saw with my own eyes that soldiers were being put at risk for unacceptable things that even the officers did not understand what was going on and were confused.
A simple soldier is not supposed to understand everything, but there is some basic logic that even the simplest warrior can understand (like for example if there is an order to enter an uncleaned street that can easily be cleansed before (even without killing people but by evacuating in other ways) but they don't want to because there are “uninvolved” and because of this desire *certainly* soldiers will die and be injured, or to put soldiers right next to “uninvolved” when it is possible with a not small probability that the ”uninvolved” are actually surprisingly involved. Or for example they put us in assembly areas for days and weeks without any minimal protection from missiles and soldiers died because of it over and over and over again. And I can make a whole list of things that kill and injure soldiers and make no sense in them and the only ”logic” is that Bibi is in a lot of illusions / ”perceptions World” (which of course are not true and valuable worldviews but only internal mental perceptions about how to continue to rule) that dangle down to orders that kill and injure soldiers.
And as I wrote at the beginning, even without thinking independently but even if you are fixed and follow exactly according to the army's orders – they order from the first day that it is forbidden to obey an order that has a black flag flying above it. And going on operations where soldiers next to you are dying and injured because of illogical things is an order that has countless huge black flags flying above it.

דוד replied 9 months ago

Fighter

You are right in everything you say, of course, except that it has to do with Bibi. Anyone else to the left of Bibi (Gantz, Eisenkot, etc.) would have done the same thing and even worse. For them, it is even ideological to risk the lives of soldiers in order to ensure the lives of the ”uninvolved” Gazans. Even one of the current generals or lieutenant generals in the IDF said that if they had not spared their lives, they would have closed a story out of thin air

mimkl1 replied 9 months ago

An example from today – soldiers are placed less than 10 meters from ”uninvolved” and at any moment they can kill the soldiers. This is an example of a clearly illegal order of the plot
https://t.me/MyGPLANET/25967

Leave a Reply

Back to top button