Recent comments
- יצחק on תשובה לאברהם ושרה – חומר וצורה: “In his opinion, the Bible in this context is not a myth but historical, and only the aggadah about Rabbi Benaiah who saw them in the cave symbolizes them there as material…" Aug 18, 16:42
- on תשובה להסוד שהתגלה: “No. I don't think there are any contradictions or inconsistencies. Just quibbles." Aug 18, 16:31
- on תשובה להסוד שהתגלה: “Could the Rabbi give examples of contradictions between science and Kabbalah?" Aug 18, 16:25
- on תשובה להסוד שהתגלה: “Oh, I see there's a discussion in column 659 that I didn't read, I'll read it and get back." Aug 18, 13:08
- on תשובה להסוד שהתגלה: “No. For that. The Rabbi does not disagree with him but rather explains the Gemara's conclusion differently." Aug 18, 11:57
- on תשובה לעידוד תושבים חילונים בירושלים: “It is not permissible to desecrate Shabbat. There is room outside of halakhic law for policy considerations, especially regarding the question of how far to intervene in desecrations of Shabbat. No one…" Aug 18, 11:55
- on תשובה לצהריים טובים: “So on what basis does the Rabbi believe in the Torah from heaven?" Aug 18, 11:15
- on תשובה להאם דור המדבר הניח תפילין?: “I won't say that many commandments seem like the interpretation of the holy sages, but we must remember that if there are sages in any totalitarian country like Morocco, and they will offer suggestions..." Aug 18, 10:19
- on תשובה לעידוד תושבים חילונים בירושלים: “I'm running through other considerations. I think Jerusalem as an ultra-Orthodox city is something that needs to be prevented and could have serious consequences. But…" Aug 18, 10:17
- on תשובה להסוד שהתגלה: “2. According to the Gemara there, that is, from the words of the Amora, Rav Bibi bar Abaye, it seems impossible, and our Rabbi Hananel there disagrees with him. Or…" Aug 18, 10:11
- on תשובה לעידוד תושבים חילונים בירושלים: “In response to the question I was asked, I wrote that there is a halakhic prohibition against violating Shabbat. I did not write what to do in practice. This is not a halakhic question. If it is forbidden to initiate…" Aug 18, 09:29
- on תשובה לעידוד תושבים חילונים בירושלים: “And allow open places on Shabbat? What's happening on the border? Is a religious mayor supposed to see Jerusalem become an ultra-Orthodox city and not do…" Aug 18, 09:24
- on תשובה לפונדמנטליזם אנטי חרדי: “As individuals, some of them are. They are brainwashed. That's why I emphasized that this is an evil society." Aug 18, 07:59
- on חרדיות בין הגדרה מהותית להגדרה סוציולוגית-מוסדית (טור 731): “This is of course based on the assumption – not Haredi – that there are countless problems that need to be solved. According to the Haredi view, most…" Aug 18, 03:40
- on תשובה להאם לפי כל השיטות לימוד התורה מגן על החיילים ?: “I am Haredi and this familiar argument doesn't sit well with reality for me. After all, in 1948 and 1967 there were few Torah students and the IDF was very successful..." Aug 18, 02:47
- on תשובה לפונדמנטליזם אנטי חרדי: “Why do you think they are evil and not wrong? Don't they truly and sincerely believe that this is what is best for the people of Israel?" Aug 18, 02:35
- on הצדקה הלכתית לשימוש בכינוי בספר "אלוהים משחק בקוביות": “I would not refer to the prohibition against a blind man in the prohibition against men, but to the problematic objective reality of a name that is profane." Aug 17, 23:14
- on תשובה להשקעה בחברה המחללת שבת: “I don't understand this enough to answer. Ask someone who knows more." Aug 17, 22:51
- on תשובה לשאלה על דייבט בין הרב לאביב: “It has nothing to do with Kant. Logic is not related to phenomena and is not subjective. Regarding causality, Kant does think that it is a transcendental matter (i.e. a condition…" Aug 17, 22:50
- on תשובה לפונדמנטליזם אנטי חרדי: “I explained. If you don't understand this simple logic, nothing will probably help." Aug 17, 22:27
- on תשובה לפונדמנטליזם אנטי חרדי: “Even if they are wrong in not enlisting because of the "minor" halachic difficulties we call them. In a Jewish state, people are supposed to have the…" Aug 17, 21:50
- on תשובה לשאלה על דייבט בין הרב לאביב: “Kant claimed: All our knowledge is subjective in a certain sense — we do not see the "thing in itself" (noumenon), but only the..." Aug 17, 21:30
- on תשובה להשקעה בחברה המחללת שבת: “Thanks for the previous response. Now I would like to clarify the first two questions with a few additional points: Earlier I asked from the direction of the desecration of the Sabbath now…" Aug 17, 21:09
- on תשובה להשקעה בחברה המחללת שבת: “Thanks to the rabbi for the answer. Does this also apply if most of the employees and owners are Jewish? What if the Jewish company pays interest but…" Aug 17, 19:45
- on תשובה לפונדמנטליזם אנטי חרדי: “In my opinion, walking towards them is completely excessive. In the Hasmonaeans, you get punished for being late for the seder or prayer. In other words, the army is obligated to have them come out…" Aug 17, 19:37
- on תשובה לפרופורציה בנוגע לחטופים ופיגועים: “Beyond emotion, the success of an attack is a moral victory for the enemy and also motivation to carry out more attacks. Therefore, the difference can also be understood…" Aug 17, 19:31
- on תשובה לפרופורציה בנוגע לחטופים ופיגועים: “Brief clarification: In my previous question, I talked about both kidnappings and terrorist attacks versus deaths from infections. Now I'm clarifying and bringing up the topic..." Aug 17, 19:28
- on תשובה לבהקשר לדיון על מושגים ריקים: “It depends on who is making the claim. It can be interpreted either way." Aug 17, 17:57
- on תשובה לשאלה על דייבט בין הרב לאביב: “Maybe you know all sorts of things, I don't. Logic is not subjective. And causality is not related to logic, even though both are a priori." Aug 17, 17:55
- on תשובה לעבודה לשמה: “I understand. Thank you. I just want to point out that in his opinion the additional floors are not only worthless, but also detract from the quality of the mitzvah by interfering with intentions…" Aug 17, 14:17
- on תשובה לבהקשר לדיון על מושגים ריקים: “Hello, does the argument "to be is to be perceived" claim that everything that is not perceived (or perceived) is an empty concept, or does it only deny existence..." Aug 17, 10:40
- on תשובה ללמה פחות מ 30%?: “Hamas is under pressure if Netanyahu falls, who will finance them? Who will agree to receive salmon from Qatar? There is no choice, we need to strengthen…" Aug 17, 09:54
- on תשובה למיון משחקי קופסה בשבת: “It is worth noting that the rabbi appears to have retracted this rejoinder. See this link: https://mikyab.net//---1TP3 T9C-%9 9--/" Aug 17, 09:34
- on תשובה לשאלה על דייבט בין הרב לאביב: “I didn't understand what the problem was with the Hebrew. Did I use the same Hebrew as in the debate? (There, by the way, the Hebrew was much more incomprehensible in some parts)..." Aug 17, 09:20
- on תשובה ללמה פחות מ 30%?: “This morning I thought that some of the people there might even be aware that they are serving Hamas and preventing the release of hostages. But toppling the government from their perspective…" Aug 17, 08:27
- on תשובה לשילוב משחק נוסף למניעת בעיית בורר במונופול: “As I wrote here, I think it can be made easier." Aug 17, 06:56
- on תשובה לשילוב משחק נוסף למניעת בעיית בורר במונופול: “So in fact, is it permissible to arrange games on Shabbat after playing them and the arrangement includes some sort of sorting?" Aug 17, 01:08
- on תשובה למיהו חרדי: “Ner, it seems to me that you attach too much importance to "what Miki thinks of me" than what really matters to you. The elections..." Aug 16, 23:56
- on תשובה לשילוב משחק נוסף למניעת בעיית בורר במונופול: “True, that's why I wrote that it doesn't really work out. It's a borderline case and my inclinations about it were different." Aug 16, 23:29
- on תשובה לשילוב משחק נוסף למניעת בעיית בורר במונופול: “But the considerations that made you lenient in this case all belong to the case where you made it stricter: "There is no waste and food here because you are interested in all the parts..." Aug 16, 23:12
- on תשובה לשילוב משחק נוסף למניעת בעיית בורר במונופול: “It doesn't really work out. There's a case here that's really hard to make a categorical decision about. There I tended to be strict and here I tended to be lenient. It's a tendency..." Aug 16, 21:51
- on תשובה לשילוב משחק נוסף למניעת בעיית בורר במונופול: “How does your answer to this question align with what you wrote here: https://mikyab.net//---/ There you wrote about the question: Is it permissible to arrange the Game components…" Aug 16, 20:47
- on תשובה לצהריים טובים: “Absolutely. But the Bible is subject to different interpretations and it is difficult to reach a clear conclusion. That is why I am not interested in it." Aug 15, 17:26
- on תשובה לצהריים טובים: “I fail to fully understand, if we find prophecies that were not fulfilled in the words of the prophets, doesn't this detract from the truth of the Torah?" Aug 15, 17:11
- on תשובה לתפילה על נס נסתר?: “Because it means stopping requests in prayer, including in obligatory prayers. This is a far-reaching step. This is also abrogation of a binding halakhic provision. So…" Aug 15, 16:39
- on תשובה לתפילה על נס נסתר?: “But I can raise such doubts about many normative instructions of the Sages and still it doesn't seem like people are canceling instructions of the Sages..." Aug 15, 16:16
- on תשובה לתפילה על נס נסתר?: “Because in my opinion, if the Sages had known that there was no possibility of intervention within the framework of nature, they would undoubtedly have forbidden asking for a miracle (because that is..." Aug 15, 16:11
- on תשובה לתפילה על נס נסתר?: “I didn't understand what the point of rejecting the normative instruction is? I don't mean a prayer that is obligatory. But rather requests beyond the obligatory prayers." Aug 15, 16:02
- on תשובה ל?: “I don't know what to do with this collection of statements. I wrote my opinion. What a person doesn't understand is considered a sin. Now..." Aug 15, 15:53
- on תשובה לעשיית מצוות בציווי האל נגד רציונליות מעשית?: “There's nothing to understand here. When you ask for an explanation, you're actually expecting reasoning based on results, but the whole argument is that these actions don't..." Aug 15, 15:51
- on תשובה לתפילה על נס נסתר?: “I explained there that there is a factual assumption (that there are gaps in nature) and a normative determination (that one should not pray for a miracle, but only for gaps in nature).…" Aug 15, 15:49
- on תשובה לעסקת חטופים: “I remember that you once wanted to be sent a piece by Avi Sagi about the kidnapping deal, so here I found one in which he says..." Aug 15, 10:50
- on תשובה ל?: “The rule that mitzvot require faith is very logical. It is just not certain that this is the starting point of the Torah and Halacha." Aug 15, 10:41
- on תשובה ל?: “And the question is also whether a reasonable person would come to the conclusion that there is a commitment to Torah and Halacha. Not whether this is necessarily true!" Aug 15, 10:38
- on תשובה ל?: “Does the Torah also require what every reasonable person should do, and not just the commandments? After all, these reasonable things are what everyone…" Aug 15, 10:35
- on תשובה ל?: “And is there any logic at all that says ignorance of the law is no solution. Or is it simply a description of the law's situation?" Aug 15, 10:28
- on תשובה ל?: “Is he considered a rapist? Also, according to the Torah, "You shall not murder, you shall not steal, etc."?" Aug 15, 10:22
- on תשובה לעשיית מצוות בציווי האל נגד רציונליות מעשית?: “Thank you. I understand, but I would appreciate it if you could explain why I would act on my duty. I understand why seeking practical benefit – it would just do…" Aug 15, 09:36
- on תשובה לתפילה על נס נסתר?: “Regarding praying for a miracle, if it is based on an error, isn't it invalid?" Aug 15, 09:11
- on תשובה להשד של לפלס: “I would love a response from the team to the previous girl. It really seems like Wikipedia says it's not possible. I also heard that in a lecture by what I think is Professor Amnon Shashua." Aug 14, 22:45
- on תשובה לדרגות שונות של הזכות לחיים: “Absolutely. At the moment of birth, he becomes a complete person." Aug 14, 21:37
- on תשובה לדרגות שונות של הזכות לחיים: “I mean, the same solution to the stacking paradox? There is some moment from which, from then on, we simply understand that the fetus is a person with rights…" Aug 14, 21:26
- on תשובה לברכות על תקנות דרבנן: “She did so, without exception. The concept of reference is not as it is usually interpreted. See column 443 on this." Aug 14, 18:36
- on תשובה למכניקת הקוונטים: “Parallel universes is just a slogan and does not concern the logical plane. There is no possibility of logical contradiction in any relation of any discourse, scientific…" Aug 14, 18:34
- on תשובה למכניקת הקוונטים: “*If we ask what the thing really is, then yes, there is one truth to it." Aug 14, 18:31
- on חרדיות בין הגדרה מהותית להגדרה סוציולוגית-מוסדית (טור 731): “I would define the Haredim this way, not out of hatred, but out of cold analysis: the sector, in which the amount of excuses invented in retrospect about..." Aug 14, 18:17
- on תשובה לברכות על תקנות דרבנן: “Hello. How does this answer work? The wording is still not precise, the "and commanded" refers to the act of taking, which was not commanded by God." Aug 14, 18:17
- on תשובה למכניקת הקוונטים: “And also in a situation of different angles of view. Maybe your example is suitable here. With the chocolate which is both delicious and fattening. If you like…" Aug 14, 18:06
- on תשובה למכניקת הקוונטים: “I forgot to mention in a situation of parallel universes of course." Aug 14, 17:53
- on תשובה למיהו חרדי: “I don't understand where this discussion is going. If you are Haredi then you are Haredi and if not then you are not. If you are not Haredi…" Aug 14, 17:41
- on תשובה לדרגות שונות של הזכות לחיים: “I am definitely talking about the ontological rather than the epistemic level. And I still don't see why it should be a sharp boundary. Even the concept of consciousness..." Aug 14, 17:40
- on תשובה לבת של גרוסע' צדיקים: “I finally came to my senses, and I understood why legislative steps intended – primarily – to prevent selective enforcement and distortion of justice are called a “coup d’état”…" Aug 14, 13:51
- on תשובה למיהו חרדי: “I don't claim to be a coercive person. I try to improve myself even though I am Haredi, which is why I serve and study in academia. I don't think it's..." Aug 14, 13:14
- on תשובה לדרגות שונות של הזכות לחיים: “I'll read it, thank you! (And I'll blackmail you for your memory of all the columns you've written). There's an issue here that's not entirely clear to me yet, and it may be..." Aug 14, 13:13
- on תשובה למיהו חרדי: “Everything has been explained. I don't understand what you are asking. 1. I am not exaggerating anything. My description is completely accurate in relation to the public. The language is also..." Aug 14, 12:44
- on תשובה למיהו חרדי: “1. It is true that at the beginning of my remarks I was referring more to columns 720 and 722 and more. I agree with a significant part of your claims, except that the language you…" Aug 14, 12:16
- on חרדיות בין הגדרה מהותית להגדרה סוציולוגית-מוסדית (טור 731): “Hello Rabbi. It seems to me (I've already thought about correcting the Rabbi several times and then I learned new words..) "You can look at it in the eye..." Aug 14, 11:15
- on תשובה לפקק בשבת: “I answered everything. Saying something to a non-Jew is a rabbinical prohibition. Simply put, there is no difference between saying something and implying something. There is a difference between saying something to a non-Jew and doing something…" Aug 14, 10:28
- on תשובה לפקק בשבת: “Thank you to the rabbi for the response. I would also like to hear the rabbi's opinion on the situation that occurred and on my previous question. My question: If by chance..." Aug 14, 10:12
- on תשובה לההורים אשמים: “"There's nothing to be done with it because they weren't holy enough when they created it"...? This delusional sentence betrays so many principles..." Aug 14, 09:55
- on תשובה להשד של לפלס: “In https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Laplaces_demon?utm_source=chatgpt.com, which is the Wikipedia entry on the subject, the arguments are that it is not possible (even according to classical calculation) and of course also impossible..." Aug 13, 23:17
- on חרדיות בין הגדרה מהותית להגדרה סוציולוגית-מוסדית (טור 731): “The difference between Haredim and other sectors is identified by the standard deviation of the differences in clothing between members of the community for that given point in time. Best regards," Aug 13, 22:13
- on תשובה לשני צעיערים חרדים סיימו במקום ראשון ושני בארץ ללימודי חשבונאות: “Easy fix: We learned Hadvah, but at a completely basic level." Aug 13, 22:03
- on תשובה לשני צעיערים חרדים סיימו במקום ראשון ושני בארץ ללימודי חשבונאות: “I happen to be an accountant, and I happen to be good friends with the two guys I studied with 🙂 I don't know how much of a connection there is..." Aug 13, 22:01
- on תשובה לצבים כל הדרך מטה: “I made a slight correction in the bot and sent the rabbi's prompt again: Brief clarification: The answers are provided by a model that uses sources from…" Aug 13, 21:04
- on תשובה לשני צעיערים חרדים סיימו במקום ראשון ושני בארץ ללימודי חשבונאות: “In any case, there is no obligation to study economics together with accounting, so even if some study it doesn't mean..." Aug 13, 20:52
- on תשובה לשני צעיערים חרדים סיימו במקום ראשון ושני בארץ ללימודי חשבונאות: “Miki, as I wrote, my basic assumption is that almost all those who pass the bar exam have previously taken courses in..." Aug 13, 20:34
- on תשובה לשאלה סמכות השולחן ערוך ותקנות: “The Shulchan Aruch follows the Torah that follows Rabbeinu Yonah." Aug 13, 20:15
- on תשובה למה גורם למסקנות הזו ?: “A combination of distrust in the press and the legal system, which leads to the conclusion that there is no corruption. Everything is sewn up. With a willingness to pay the price of corruption for…" Aug 13, 18:05
- on תשובה למה גורם למסקנות הזו ?: “* In the title, what causes this misery? * Aren't we disgusted by corruption? * Or are we simply attracted to stupid and evil people, etc." Aug 13, 17:58
- on תשובה לשני צעיערים חרדים סיימו במקום ראשון ושני בארץ ללימודי חשבונאות: “I don't know exactly what they test on the bar exams, but I have almost no doubt that the math required there is about high school level. I..." Aug 13, 17:41
- on תשובה לשני צעיערים חרדים סיימו במקום ראשון ושני בארץ ללימודי חשבונאות: “My father, CPA is a title for a profession. The discussion here was about the certification exams, and in any case, almost everyone who takes the certification exams passes before this…" Aug 13, 17:25
- on תשובה לספרות: “Many times, laws have been ruled from there by the various poskim (I'm not talking about a situation of contradiction between them and the Talmud), why even…" Aug 13, 16:18
- on תשובה לדרגות שונות של הזכות לחיים: “In principle, no, but there is room to talk about predation, for example, or someone who is brain dead (see my article on organ harvesting for transplantation)." Aug 13, 14:18
- on תשובה לשלא עשני אישה, פסול נשים לעדות ולדון: “I really don't see the problem in principle. I understand that you're not ready to accept it now, which is why I talked about change. But..." Aug 13, 14:17
- on תשובה ללבוש בתפילה: “You are as expert as I am on questions of norms. Certainly regarding your own place. I have no objective and general standard." Aug 13, 14:12
- on תשובה לדרגות שונות של הזכות לחיים: “I understand. I think the more accurate question is, are there other types of human populations that have a tenuous right to life…" Aug 13, 13:31
- on תשובה לשלא עשני אישה, פסול נשים לעדות ולדון: “I don't care if it has changed or not. At some point in the past, God created a being whose purpose is to serve man.…" Aug 13, 12:47
- on תשובה ללבוש בתפילה: “True, but even by today's standards, shorts are not something to be respected, and when a person is respected even if he plays sports, he is..." Aug 13, 12:25
- on תשובה לסמכות סנהדרין רק בקידוש החודש: “I saw that you once wrote that it doesn't matter whether the Sanhedrin is right or wrong because they are the authority. And a rabbi is just an expert in Halacha and with him you..." Aug 13, 10:49
- on תשובה לסמכות סנהדרין רק בקידוש החודש: “I understand that she has formal authority. And even the Sanhedrin of 23 has the authority to gouge out someone's eyes. Even if they're not sitting..." Aug 13, 10:38
- on תשובה לסמכות סנהדרין רק בקידוש החודש: “Is it a fact that if the Sanhedrin ruled on an erroneous law, their ruling has no validity? After it has been proven, of course. It's not like the sanctification of the month, which has a written decree." Aug 13, 10:22
- on תשובה להתרת נדרים על לבישת מכנסיים: “So maybe it's worth doing. I'm still not sure it's necessary since she didn't really take a vow/swear and in fact she wore a skirt and not pants..." Aug 13, 10:06
- on תשובה להתרת נדרים על לבישת מכנסיים: “Her motivation is a combination of the fact that she thinks pants are modest and that she wants to make it easier for herself. Does this fall under the definition of…" Aug 13, 07:35
- on תשובה לשלא עשני אישה, פסול נשים לעדות ולדון: “Perhaps the goal was for men to lead until the world becomes more educated and women also enter the circle. There are quite a few things that change throughout history,…" Aug 13, 06:32
- on תשובה לברכת המזון: “There is an abbreviated version by Rabbi Yitzhak Abadi. https://beta.hebrewbooks.org/reader/reader.aspx?sfid=1525#p=63&fitMode=fitwidth&hlts=&ocr=" Aug 13, 02:45
- on תשובה לברכת המזון: “There is an abbreviated version by Rabbi Yitzhak Abadi. https://beta.hebrewbooks.org/reader/reader.aspx?sfid=1525#p=63&fitMode=fitwidth&hlts=&ocr=" Aug 13, 02:42
- on תשובה לשני צעיערים חרדים סיימו במקום ראשון ושני בארץ ללימודי חשבונאות: “My friend took career counseling tests. They told him he was good at arithmetic and average at math. Go study accounting. Study accounting…" Aug 13, 00:35
- on תשובה לשלא עשני אישה, פסול נשים לעדות ולדון: “I understand, thank you. Regarding 3: If this is God's intention in creation, it's hard to see how it could change, isn't it? That's what God..." Aug 13, 00:06
- on תשובה להתרת נדרים על לבישת מכנסיים: “Yes, it is desirable that they have some knowledge of the laws of vows." Aug 12, 23:54
- on תשובה להתרת נדרים על לבישת מכנסיים: “She did not make a vow revocation on the eve of the Lord's Day. So that doesn't apply. Besides, it's not a clarification of an error but a desire to make things easier..." Aug 12, 23:42
- on חרדיות בין הגדרה מהותית להגדרה סוציולוגית-מוסדית (טור 731): “This is not an essay that encompasses the phenomenon. This is a review of a book. Modern Haredim are on the fringes of Harediism. See the discussion on definitions…" Aug 12, 23:25
- on תשובה לשני צעיערים חרדים סיימו במקום ראשון ושני בארץ ללימודי חשבונאות: “Ruach, I was responding solely to the words "Woe to the CPA who does not understand Hedva (basically)." That is simply not true – there is no connection..." Aug 12, 22:48
- on חרדיות בין הגדרה מהותית להגדרה סוציולוגית-מוסדית (טור 731): “I don't see any reference in the article to the phenomenon of "modern Haredim," but only to "modern religiosity." Is this an overlapping concept, or is it contradictory?" Aug 12, 22:40
- on תשובה להנאה ממוזיקה בשבת: “Indeed. And supposedly according to the Hayyim method, a person who only desires is forbidden, one should say that a burning lamp is a desire, or that fire is a desire (even though the light…" Aug 12, 22:20
- on תשובה להנאה ממוזיקה בשבת: “Now I thought that light is also something that doesn't really exist, and still no one says that there is a side to enjoying the candlelight that someone..." Aug 12, 21:24
- on חרדיות בין הגדרה מהותית להגדרה סוציולוגית-מוסדית (טור 731): “The rabbi is right, as usual, but I'm not sure that in reality the rabbi's words are better, and I'll explain. In analyzing things, this is modern religiosity, but..." Aug 12, 21:21
- on תשובה לשני צעיערים חרדים סיימו במקום ראשון ושני בארץ ללימודי חשבונאות: “Father, I wrote about basic level mathematics. I didn't write that you need to complete an information technology course at the Technion. A CPA knows mathematics at a higher level than…" Aug 12, 21:08
- on תשובה להנאה ממוזיקה בשבת: “There is no real sound in the sound. This is also what Maimonides writes in his book, Ha-Ha'aretz, about the shofar being one of the prohibitions of pleasure. However, here we are talking about a sound created by the use of…" Aug 12, 21:03
- on תשובה להנאה ממוזיקה בשבת: “I don't understand. When they say there is no object here, do they mean that the sound is something that doesn't really exist? Or something else?" Aug 12, 21:00
- on חרדיות בין הגדרה מהותית להגדרה סוציולוגית-מוסדית (טור 731): “If I understand Rabbi Navet's suggestion correctly, he means that what distinguishes Haredi society is a perspective that does not grant..." Aug 12, 20:42
- on תשובה להנאה ממוזיקה בשבת: “No. This is a disagreement among the poskim, but they include it as a branch. I personally am not sure that there is no hefza here, because in my opinion it is a device that works…" Aug 12, 20:37
- on תשובה להנאה ממוזיקה בשבת: “Does the fact that there is no object here excuse me in any case?" Aug 12, 20:25
- on תשובה לעסקת חטופים: “Okay, so if future considerations are important, what do you see that has changed between the time the order was written and now, from that perspective? Does…" Aug 12, 20:24
- on תשובה לשני צעיערים חרדים סיימו במקום ראשון ושני בארץ ללימודי חשבונאות: “This doesn't diminish the difficulty of the study, accounting is one of the most difficult degrees in my opinion outside of the exact sciences. But the difficulty is in places..." Aug 12, 20:13
- on תשובה לשני צעיערים חרדים סיימו במקום ראשון ושני בארץ ללימודי חשבונאות: “I'm kidding. CPAs do take a course in economics, but it's mainly to understand certain models in economics (marginal products, etc.). In accounting work..." Aug 12, 20:11
- on תשובה להנאה ממוזיקה בשבת: “A Sabbath act is a different issue. There is no intention here and it depends on whether it was done for me, accidentally or not, etc." Aug 12, 20:09
- on תשובה להנאה ממוזיקה בשבת: “Isn't there any pleasure in a Shabbat act? I mean the way the person who turned on the music turned on the speaker on Shabbat or plays the guitar on Shabbat.…" Aug 12, 20:07
- on תשובה לחיוב מספר חדר בשבת: “Without the registration, he wouldn't be known to you. Your explanation doesn't sound reasonable to me. If he has the option without registering it..." Aug 12, 19:53
- on תשובה לשני צעיערים חרדים סיימו במקום ראשון ושני בארץ ללימודי חשבונאות: “Yes, at the high school level." Aug 12, 19:50
- on תשובה לחיוב מספר חדר בשבת: “Regarding the registration problem. Does it matter if it's Jewish or Gentile? In many hotels, employees have the option to save this data..." Aug 12, 19:42
- on תשובה לשני צעיערים חרדים סיימו במקום ראשון ושני בארץ ללימודי חשבונאות: “Woe to the CPA who doesn't understand the law, completely. All the chamber's opinions are filled with boundary calculations." Aug 12, 19:20
- on תשובה לחיוב מספר חדר בשבת: “And what about drinks in the paid minibar? At the beginning of the vacation, the hotel owner fills the small refrigerator in the room with drinks, and at the end…" Aug 12, 18:55
- on תשובה לעסקת חטופים: “I did not write there and I never thought that future considerations should be ignored. On the contrary, the main considerations here deal with the future. My argument there was that dangers…" Aug 12, 18:45
- on תשובה לדעת הרס״ג בבחירה וידיעה: “It is possible that your choice not to answer the question is in accordance with the method of Rabbi Saadia Gaon." Aug 12, 17:29
- on תשובה לעסקת חטופים: “Of course, I'm just asking your opinion based on the developments that have occurred. After all, in column 607 you said that future considerations should be ignored, and I wonder if..." Aug 12, 17:20
- on תשובה לפקק בשבת: “This is a rabbinical prohibition. This is a statement about a Torah prohibition (in my opinion), and therefore one should not be lenient except in cases of great necessity. In stating a rabbinical prohibition, they permitted…" Aug 12, 16:48
- on תשובה לפקק בשבת: “Actually, I had a disagreement with a friend of mine about something that happened to us. We originally went out on the street to look for someone who had a Shabbat plate,…" Aug 12, 16:40
- on תשובה לשני צעיערים חרדים סיימו במקום ראשון ושני בארץ ללימודי חשבונאות: “It is not true that "there is not the slightest connection between accounting and mathematics." CPAs do indeed deal almost exclusively with calculations (and laws), but..." Aug 12, 16:18
- on תשובה לעסקת חטופים: “If you choose to ignore these considerations, you can of course make any decision you want." Aug 12, 13:59
- on תשובה לעסקת חטופים: “Why not actually accept a surrender deal in exchange for all the hostages (if that's possible, which of course isn't true)? Assuming we ignore..." Aug 12, 13:57
- on תשובה ללמה שניצל הוא כשר?: “But if you want a rant about the relationship between schnitzel and chicken, accept what my grandson (three and a half years old) said a few days ago: Mom,…" Aug 12, 13:43
- on תשובה לשני צעיערים חרדים סיימו במקום ראשון ושני בארץ ללימודי חשבונאות: “That's it. You can continue writing in a loyal tone." Aug 12, 12:52
- on תשובה לתפיסת האלוהים: “Why does this claim require the assumption of infinite degrees?" Aug 12, 11:33
- on תשובה לשני צעיערים חרדים סיימו במקום ראשון ושני בארץ ללימודי חשבונאות: “And we haven't even talked about the scholarships and related academic assistance that are usually not given to non-Haredi students." Aug 12, 10:41
- on תשובה לציטוט בשם הרב: “What is the point of these questions? Obviously, if good arguments are presented, I should accept them. What I said is that I am not impressed by human authority. This…" Aug 12, 10:39
- on תשובה לשני צעיערים חרדים סיימו במקום ראשון ושני בארץ ללימודי חשבונאות: “Point 4 is an appearance of the first of Michi's laws, when comparing companies you have to compare top to top and bottom to bottom. That's how I saw it once..." Aug 12, 10:15
- on תשובה לציטוט בשם הרב: “Even if they convince you? Or do you claim that your positions are so entrenched that you can't be moved from them? And when you get to a discussion or a confrontation,…" Aug 12, 10:00
- on תשובה לאיך יכל משה רבנו לא לאכול ולשתות ארבעים יום: “The light of life is seen in the entire verse that explains that he ate fruits and vegetables, but did not eat "bread" and did not drink "water."" Aug 12, 09:52
- on תשובה לציטוט בשם הרב: “You wrote: Even if I don't have another interpretation in the Rambam, I will not back down from my clear position. Are you speaking only in this context or..." Aug 12, 09:32
- on תשובה לסמכות חכמים והקשר לאבותיי: “The Knesset does not obligate me or you, it simply says that if I break the law, it will be possible to arrest me. If…" Aug 12, 09:30
- on תשובה לשני צעיערים חרדים סיימו במקום ראשון ושני בארץ ללימודי חשבונאות: “And I have a relative who, in the yeshiva, is considered the best in terms of his ability in "learning," and because of the cliff of times and a dash of sanity, it was easy to retire for the rest of his life..." Aug 12, 09:02
- on הנתיב השלישי: על להט"ב, לייטיות וביקורת מזיקה (טור 728): “Regarding sexual orientation, I do think it's more of an innate tendency, I'm not convinced that it's completely reversible. In my opinion, the claim that it's..." Aug 12, 02:58
- on תשובה לפארק מים: “And someone who is famous for being gay? Apparently he has no thoughts (I assume so, I haven't researched it) according to what you divided between famous..." Aug 12, 01:51
- on על אפלייה נגד נשים ומהותה של הרבנות הראשית (טור 725): “The question is about the boundaries of the Getz, which each time bites more and more into the decisions of the rabbinate and interferes in religious matters." Aug 12, 01:49
- on תשובה לפארק מים: “There is a difference between a person who is famous for his piety and an ordinary person who has no reflections and who is not aware that there is no prohibition in this. Even though there is no…" Aug 11, 23:26
- on תשובה לפארק מים: “And if they all bleed on me like pale pee, is that permissible? Or even if I'm right, my opinion is invalid and I can't give it to everyone..." Aug 11, 23:23
- on אינדוקציה – המשך: על מובהקות מקרית (טור 730): “There is a much more logical solution to this: please inform all people whose ears may be ringing and to be careful." Aug 11, 23:12
- on אינדוקציה – המשך: על מובהקות מקרית (טור 730): “Why not? The logic is that a person who has been shot at three times is more aware of the chances of his shot hitting {even though there may not really be such a chance}…" Aug 11, 22:44
- on תשובה לציטוט בשם הרב: “So I'm supposed to do a self-status check for him so he can safely lower me into the pit and not fail to save me, God willing? 🙂" Aug 11, 19:26
- on תשובה לציטוט בשם הרב: “Maybe he can relate what you brought from the Gemara and Ritva to the matter before Ayur, according to his opinion, who should let others know? Someone believes that there is no foreskin in bananas…" Aug 11, 18:41
- on תשובה לציטוט בשם הרב: “Search here and you'll see. I have no idea and I don't care. Why is it even interesting? I'll add more than that, just to clarify: Also…" Aug 11, 18:30
- on תשובה לציטוט בשם הרב: “A. I didn't understand the answer. Is this a true or false quote? B. https://mikyab.net//--/" Aug 11, 18:18
- on הנתיב השלישי: על להט"ב, לייטיות וביקורת מזיקה (טור 728): “I can offer the answer of the bot: Two levels must be distinguished: Public tactics: “extreme against extremism” in order to “balance” – this is…" Aug 11, 17:21
- on תשובה לפקק בשבת: “According to most rabbinic jurists, there is no problem here with turning on electricity (except that according to Rabbi Michi, it is from the Torah). Although the plate is from the Torah, but…" Aug 11, 17:09
- on תשובה לאיסור מוסרי בגאולת דם: “The idea is to pressure the accidental murderer, so that he will run to a city of refuge and not pose a danger to the public." Aug 11, 16:59
- on הנתיב השלישי: על להט"ב, לייטיות וביקורת מזיקה (טור 728): “Congratulations on the important things. The topic came up in two lines and I would love to know your opinion on the struggle that is being waged by extremism against other extremism,…" Aug 11, 16:39
- on תשובה לאיסור מוסרי בגאולת דם: “The very attempt to convince him means that killing is immoral. That's why they're trying to dissuade him. Of course, the IDF can also prevent it by force.…" Aug 11, 14:18
- on תשובה לאיסור מוסרי בגאולת דם: “The truth is, I didn't know that there was blood redemption in cases other than an accident (now I see that it is already in the verses) and I intended to ask only about…" Aug 11, 13:25
- on תשובה לים בשבת: “It is possible. And yet such a feeling can be a motivation to seek a halakhic explanation. To permit, one must find a halakhic explanation. You could perhaps say…" Aug 11, 12:03
- on תשובה להערה קצרה על ספר "מצוי ראשון" עמ' 450 "אמונה והתגלות": “And what's the question? You're driving me crazy. Phrase the question clearly. What is my claim, and what is your question about it?" Aug 11, 12:01
- on תשובה לפקק בשבת: “If the problem was just a plate, there is room for discussion. It depends on what food is available, and what the children eat. I don't have a general answer." Aug 11, 11:59
- on האם יש עבודה זרה 'נאורה'? על היחס לגויים ועל שינויים בהלכה: “Although I agree with the analysis of HaMeiri's words, it should be added as a side note, as seen in his words regarding trade with Christians on the day..." Aug 11, 11:52
- on תשובה לים בשבת: “I thought about this matter again, and it reminded me of what you said about yeshiva leaders who have no connection with homeowners who can…" Aug 11, 11:29
- on תשובה להערה קצרה על ספר "מצוי ראשון" עמ' 450 "אמונה והתגלות": “Okay. I was talking about the concept of an internal and natural faith. It is openly present in some of us, and I think subconsciously in everyone. And all the rest are excuses to reinforce…" Aug 11, 10:44
- on תשובה לתנור מצב שבת: “Regarding soy foods, it is not similar in my opinion, since the appearance of the raw material does not resemble meat at all. Moreover, the name of the definition itself…" Aug 11, 10:25
- on תשובה לפקק בשבת: “Assuming the problem was only with the plate (say the refrigerator was connected to a different power source), would you still think so? I don't know, Rabbi…" Aug 11, 10:06
- on תשובה לתנור מצב שבת: “Regarding the signs of purity, this does not concern us at all. The signs themselves were given there and the entire application is left to us. It is not about an image…" Aug 11, 10:05
- on תשובה לתנור מצב שבת: “There is a difference between the laws of the Torah and the laws of the rabbis. In the Torah, a word is compared to a word more than in the rabbis. Therefore, if there is no reason, it is not nullified…" Aug 11, 10:04
- on תשובה לתנור מצב שבת: “But the ruling is general for all cooking methods, isn't it? Why would a new situation that falls within the limits of the prohibition not be considered part of it? After all…" Aug 11, 10:01
- on תשובה לניסיון שאין אדם יכול לעמוד בו: “🙂 I dealt with this in discussions about homosexuality. See, for example, column 728. In my opinion, R.M. Feinstein assumes this without any basis, and I leveraged…" Aug 11, 10:01
- on תשובה לניסיון שאין אדם יכול לעמוד בו: “This is likely the source: Corinthians 10:13 There hath no temptation taken hold of you but such as is common to…" Aug 11, 09:51
- on תשובה לפקק בשבת: “First of all, the refrigerator also went out. Second, these days, cooked food that isn't hot is definitely a big necessity, especially for children. In their day, they lived..." Aug 11, 09:43
- on תשובה לפקק בשבת: “Rabbi, why is eating hot food such a great necessity? People eat cold food every day. You can eat cold food and still be fine even if…" Aug 11, 09:39
- on תשובה לתנור מצב שבת: “Because this is a new decree. It urges to introduce a new situation under an existing decree. Like the argument of banning cycling lest it come…" Aug 11, 09:34
- on תשובה להערה קצרה על ספר "מצוי ראשון" עמ' 450 "אמונה והתגלות": “You appear under a lot of nicknames, so readers here don't see the amount of questions and comments I make to you. That's why I also..." Aug 11, 09:32
- on תשובה לתנור מצב שבת: “Rabbi, why is it necessary for a Sanhedrin to be established for this? After all, if using an oven is indeed considered a normal way of cooking, why isn't it included…" Aug 11, 09:32
- on תשובה להערה קצרה על ספר "מצוי ראשון" עמ' 450 "אמונה והתגלות": “Maybe you'll enlighten me, I really mean it. But honestly. And not just to insult. And I'm sure I have some good questions too..." Aug 11, 09:18