The criterion for truth
Has the rabbi read Rabbi Yosef Kellner's books "The Criterion for Truth and the Criterion for Morality",
"Like a lion rising up" and "The terrible majesty of the ice"? So what do you think of the Mishnah that is deployed there?
And in general, what is the Rabbi's opinion of the method of Rabbi Kellner, who, although he is among the "line", is undoubtedly not a typical canonist who puts the fear of thought at a premium and avoids general education studies in breadth and depth?
I haven't really read it. I've read some of his stuff and I really didn't like it. He's very strict and extreme, and I don't think he really understands the issues he writes about and therefore isn't accurate.
I have never read such a superficial answer.
One can disagree with Rabbi Kellner, but to write that he doesn't understand the topics he writes about... is a joke.
And that's without even reading the books and understanding how they say everything. Apparently, his honor doesn't understand the topics he writes about and therefore isn't accurate.
Leave a Reply
Please login or Register to submit your answer