New on the site: Michi-botA wise assistant on the writings of Rabbi Michael Avraham.

The Khazari Proof

Response › The Khazari Proof

0 Vote Up Vote Down

thoughtful asked 12 months ago

הרב מתייחס הרבה להוכחת האלוקים (הפילוסופי) בצורה לוגית. יש דרך להוכיח את האלוקים היהודים בפרט? ראיתי שיש מפקפקים בטיעון ההתגלות בסיני של הכוזרי

Leave a ReplyCancel reply

1 Answer

0 Vote Up Vote Down

Michi Staff answered 12 months ago

זה ודאי לא שייך לתחום הטיעונים הפילוסופיים. זהו טיעון היסטורי והוא נשפט כמו טיעונים היסטוריים. במצוי הראשון הסברתי שהכוזרי כשלעצמו אינו ממש משכנע, אבל בצירוף מכלול שם שביסודו האלוהים הפילוסופי, זה כן נשמע סביר.

thoughtful replied 12 months ago

'נשמע סביר' זה טענה סבירה כדי לבסס עליה את כל החיים?

Michi Staff replied 12 months ago

בהחלט. גם עקרון הסיבתיות נשמע לי סביר ואני מתבסס עליו בחיי.

Leave a ReplyCancel reply

Live classes are held on Zoom on Thursdays, 8:45-10:00 PM.
After the classes, there will be an open discussion of questions that participants may wish to discuss as they wish (even those unrelated to the class). All classes are also recorded and uploaded to the website. You can access the Zoom class at the following link:
http://zoom.us/j/8854356300
To join the WhatsApp group with updates about the classes and their dates, send an email to: orenmarg@gmail.com

New on the site: Michi-bot – A wise assistant on the writings of Rabbi Michael Avraham

“The greatest flaw in the trait of fear of Heaven, when it is not properly joined to the light of Torah, is that instead of becoming fear of sin it turns into fear of thinking. Once a person begins to be afraid to think, he proceeds to sink into the mire of ignorance, which steals the light of his soul, weakens his strength, and darkens his spirit.” — R. A. I. Kook, Shemoneh Kevatzim, I §267
—
“Therefore, out of a love of inquiry and knowledge, one should not dismiss anything that opposes one’s view… Even if the words run counter to his faith and religion, one must not say to him, ‘Do not speak; shut your mouth,’ for if so there would be no clarification of the religion. On the contrary, in such a case we say: Speak as much as you wish… For concealing the words of one who opposes the religion is nothing but the nullification and weakening of the religion… Reason dictates that there be no prevention of this at all, nor should a person’s mouth be closed regarding matters that touch upon religion; rather, the text of the law is given to all… Through this a person comes to the very substance of truth and stands upon complete truth, and there is to be no shutting of such words. For any warrior who seeks to oppose another in order to show his strength greatly desires that the one who comes against him strengthen himself with all his might; then, if he defeats that warrior who sought to overpower him, it is seen that the victor is exceedingly mighty.” — Be’er HaGolah, Seventh Well, Maharal of Prague

לאחרונה
פופולרי
תגובות

Harediism between a substantive definition and a sociological-institutional definition (column 731)
לפני 6 days
Induction – Continued: On accidental significance (column 730)
לפני 2 weeks
Scientific Generalization and the Problem of Induction in Halacha and in General (Tur 729)
לפני 2 weeks
The Third Path: On LGBTQ, “Lite” Religiosity, and Harmful Criticism (Column 728)
לפני 3 weeks
A look at the current debate on war crimes in Gaza (column 727)
לפני 3 weeks

On Criticism in Light of the Corona Crisis (Tor 290)
01/04/2020
On Labels and Discussions, or: Am I Epicurus? (Tor 74)
07/06/2017
Reflections on Bible Study (Volume 134)
11/04/2018
Reflections following the Meron disaster (column 387)
05/05/2021
The Synagogue as a Preaching Arena for a Captive Audience: Another Look at Prayer (Tur 77)
25/06/2017

Tiger's Eye
What conclusion does he explain? The principle conclusion of the Gemara that there is a perishing in...
Michi
Not really interested in biblical interpretation. You should search online or ask people...
Michi
I don't understand the point of these insistences. The things are completely simple. I don't...
Michi
True. If you are a logical and critical person, you are not Haredi. If you give in to the...
Michi
It's very difficult for me to deal with such a low level of understanding of what I'm doing...

New trilogies were printed
New copies of the Quartet books (except the second) have arrived. Those interested can contact Dafna at 052-3322444.
You can purchase the collection of recordings of previous courses (critical thinking, yeshiva scholarship, philosophical thinking, contemporary Judaism, reading philosophical texts, and the analytical and synthetic) by contacting Dafna at 052-3322444, also for 250 NIS per course.
The new edition of the trilogy has now been released in paperback, which includes many corrections, but these are mainly printing corrections and there are no substantial changes. In addition, a shipment of new books has arrived. The books are sold as a complete trilogy for 200 NIS or 75 NIS for a single book. They can be received either in Lod or Jerusalem, or by courier to your home for 42 NIS.
The book Two Carts and a Balloon and The Spirit of Justice is available for 75 NIS each.