New on the site: Michi-botA wise assistant on the writings of Rabbi Michael Avraham.

Nahma Dachisupa

ResponseCategory: FaithNahma Dachisupa
Jonathan asked 2 months ago

Do you think God created the reality of shameful bread?

Leave a Reply

1 Answer
Michi Staff answered 2 months ago

I guess so.

Jonathan replied 2 months ago

So He created the world in order to benefit His creatures. He created this reality of shameful bread. Whatever He could not do, so that we would receive a reward for our labors by merit and not by grace, don't you think that this is a foregone conclusion? It would be as if this reality of shameful bread could not have been changed by Him.

Michi Staff replied 2 months ago

I said he created the phenomenon of shameful bread. I didn't say it was his consideration for giving a commandment. This invention really doesn't seem right to me.

Jonathan replied 2 months ago

And of course it didn't matter if this was a reality that was forced upon him.

Jonathan replied 2 months ago

Okay, but not a consideration for giving a commandment, a consideration for creating the world, I mean. The commandments are just a means to good or one of several

Jonathan replied 2 months ago

I actually think he created the world because that's how he wanted it. Why he wanted it is beyond my understanding, and what's the point of asking why someone wants something? He wanted it because he wanted it, that's how.

Michi Staff replied 2 months ago

I do not share this invention either.

Jonathan replied 2 months ago

Okay, you're right, if that's how he made a sign that he wanted, no. And every reason you say why he created the world is asked why he created that reason, unless you say that he wanted it in this specific way, if he's not limited he doesn't have to do anything for something else to happen but just do the thing he wants, I hope I explained myself well.

Leave a Reply

Back to top button