New on the site: Michi-bot. An intelligent assistant based on the writings of Rabbi Michael Avraham.

A question about empowerment and truth

שו”תCategory: faithA question about empowerment and truth
asked 8 years ago

Hello Rabbi Michael, I’m getting stronger now and I read that you wrote something like this: “I’m not saying that the truth is in me, I’m saying that there is truth and we need to reach it.”
If I make such an assumption, how will I be able to strengthen my faith without doubts?


Discover more from הרב מיכאל אברהם

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

Leave a Reply

0 Answers
מיכי Staff answered 8 years ago
Hello C. Let me start by saying that the question of whether a claim is true or false is not examined through its implications, that is, its harm or benefit (whether it is beneficial or detrimental to strengthening one’s faith). A claim should be examined on its merits and content. After reaching the conclusion that it is true (or not), one can discuss its harm and benefit and how to deal with both of these. Now to your question itself. I don’t know where you read this sentence, but I definitely think that the truth is in me (although not with certainty, every person can be wrong). In addition, I also say that there is truth and a duty to strive to reach it. It is possible that where you read the words, I was dealing with the second claim and not the first. And one last thing, there is no such thing as faith without doubts. We are human beings and as such we are condemned to live with uncertainties. A person cannot reach certainty (after all, it is always possible that you were wrong in what you thought. You never have a guarantee that you are not wrong). Empowerment means acting according to your best understanding despite uncertainties and despite the fear that you may be wrong, but you as a flesh and blood person are not required to and cannot eliminate uncertainties. Postmodernism is wrong in that it identifies uncertainty with doubt and with multiple truths or with no truth. Each of us has different beliefs, and if that is what he thinks, then that is the truth for him, and he must act according to it. But you should always take into account that you may be wrong, and at the same time not let it neutralize the management of your life according to your understanding. We are condemned to live with a certain uncertainty, but this does not mean that there is no truth and that it is impossible to reach it. Contrary to the postmodern assumption, truth is not the same as certainty.

Discover more from הרב מיכאל אברהם

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

מושה replied 8 years ago

Dear G
What the Rabbi is actually telling you is:
A person should go with their faith in the direction they are more inclined to agree with, in the Rabbi's case, they are more inclined to believe.

Honorable Rabbi, if you were asked how many percent do you feel you are right? Would you answer 80% with confidence?

מיכי Staff replied 8 years ago

I don't know how to quantify it. In my opinion, it's reasonable.

יוני replied 8 years ago

To the rabbi;
If indeed there is no certainty about the righteousness of the path, then this will have an impact when the righteousness of the path conflicts with other desires. For example: in a situation where it is explicitly forbidden in the Torah but there is a very great desire, or very great considerations of profit - the absolute uncertainty about the righteousness of the path will affect the decision and will be added to the considerations of fulfilling the desire and generating profits.

מיכי Staff replied 8 years ago

Indeed, it is true. Such an effect is certainly possible. So what to do? Is that why I will deceive myself into believing that I have confidence when I do not?

אורן replied 8 years ago

By the way, when thinking rationally, there is almost no difference between 100% certainty and 90% certainty when deciding in a dilemma between a Torah value and an extra-Torah desire. When calculating the expected “profit” or the expected importance in a dilemma, an equation is obtained in which the percentage of doubt only reduces the importance of the Torah value by about 10%, that is, if, say, someone offers me a million dollars to eat a pork steak. If when I had 100% certainty in terms of faith I would value eating the pork steak at, say, a billion dollars, then when I have 90% faith, I should value it at 900 million dollars, which is still much greater than one million. The percentage of doubt is expressed more on the psychological/emotional/existential level, and less on the level of decision-making (except in extreme cases of life and death).

מיכי Staff replied 8 years ago

A bit reminiscent of Pascal's Wager. And there's a part.

Leave a Reply

Back to top button