Debate with Aviv about choice
Hello Rabbi
At the beginning you said there are three possible mechanisms: causality, randomness, and choice. You said that a voluntary mechanism is the result of discretion, but what is the reason for your discretion? Does it have a reason? And if not, is it random? thanks!
There is no reason for discretion and it is not random. It is purposeful. I talked about discretion there.
Is it logically possible for something to exist without a cause but not be random?
Are you sure you listened to the debate? Are you sure you wrote the opening message? Because the answer is written there.
Sure. I don't see an answer there, just because I said something doesn't make it true. I said on your behalf that there is a third mechanism, but I'm asking because I don't understand how it's possible.
I explained. If you want more explanation, you'll have to be more specific.
Leave a Reply
Please login or Register to submit your answer
