New on the site: Michi-bot. An intelligent assistant based on the writings of Rabbi Michael Avraham.

Faith and Torah

שו”תCategory: Torah and ScienceFaith and Torah
asked 11 months ago

1. How are we so certain of our belief in God, when every piece of evidence we bring must be based on fundamental assumptions, which are also uncertain?
2. Isn’t it likely that our story about receiving the Torah was invented over the generations?
3. What does studying the Bible advance me? I am unable to understand from either the stories or the prophecies how they advance me in the knowledge of God or morality. Apart from the simplest messages, I rarely reach any depth.
Even if we can learn a lot from special parshiot – such as Gan Eden or Nekeret HaTzur – what does the rest of the Torah teach us?
4. Maimonides writes in the Book of Mormon that there are parables in which some of the details do not have a simile, and there are parables in which all the details have a simile. How can one know which parable is before me? How can one know what the simile is? After all, there can be an infinite number of meanings for each parable.
5. What is the relationship between Peshat and Darsh? Did God mean the sermons of the Sages or the Hasids, and yet they seem so disconnected from the words of the Torah! Is everything that can be put into words called Peshat, or only the thing that fits in the most?
6. In determining a law, is it possible to rule according to my study of the Gemara, and the opinion of a few rishonim that have not been ruled upon, or am I indeed bound by the rules of law, such as the Shulchan Aruch?
7. Regarding the blue color, could it be that the Gemara, which said that blue color is produced from snails, did not mean that this was the only way, but that this is how they would have arrived at this color in their time, since the Gemara did not say that this is necessary, but only that this is how it is done? (The problem with ‘Kala Ilan’ is therefore that it is very similar to the real color, but not exactly in shade.)
According to this possibility, if we learn to produce the color blue by industrial means, we will be able to wear it.
Is this explanation acceptable?

Thank you very much!
.


Discover more from הרב מיכאל אברהם

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

Leave a Reply

0 Answers
מיכי Staff answered 11 months ago
You’ve presented here a collection of questions that each require a book. It’s not serious. You don’t even bother to explain what exactly the question is and what the parties are in dispute about. This is sloppy writing. 1. I don’t know what “we are sure” means. Each to their own. Beyond that, I’m at least not sure of anything. Why do you assume anyone is sure of anything? 2. I don’t think so. 3. In my opinion, it does not advance us in anything. You can search here for Bible study and legend studies. 4. There is no blanket rule for all cases. There is common sense and it should be applied. 5. I don’t know if he intended it, but the qualities of the sermon were handed down to us from Sinai and their use yields a result that is the interpretation of the verse in terms of the sermon. The interpretation in terms of the sermon does not have to meet the test of the simple interpretation and can contradict the simple. This is a different level of explanation, and one should not be examined in terms of the other. 6. If you are a barrister then not only can you but you should rule for yourself. See my article on authority and autonomy. 7. Possible. Such a side was raised in discussions about Tekhelet, but it is generally believed that it is not true. I have no clear evidence one way or the other.

Discover more from הרב מיכאל אברהם

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

Leave a Reply

Back to top button