New on the site: Michi-bot. An intelligent assistant based on the writings of Rabbi Michael Avraham.

How did the great men of Israel write books on how to conduct life when they differed quite fundamentally from 99% of people?

שו”תCategory: generalHow did the great men of Israel write books on how to conduct life when they differed quite fundamentally from 99% of people?
asked 5 years ago

peace,
I think everyone would agree that the great men of Israel, such as the Ari, the Ramchal, Rav Kook, and the like, were people with the highest levels of intelligence, with the highest creative abilities, and so on regarding the other qualities and attributes.
So how could they write books with instructions, ways of acting, ways of living, and so on, when perhaps not even for one second of their lives did they experience the ways of thinking/abilities/behavior of a normal/average human being?
It’s like saying, for example, about people who haven’t experienced a serious mental problem like “real” depression or severe anxiety that they won’t be able to truly understand people who do experience such things.
Or for example, if the son of a billionaire who has been a billionaire his entire life were to write various books on how to act and live for people, people wouldn’t take it seriously because they would say – how can he even understand the life of an ordinary person? Let alone a poor person who has lived in poverty his entire life. Or they would read it to “gain insights” but would constantly feel that something here is not true / accurate / correct.


Discover more from הרב מיכאל אברהם

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

Leave a Reply

0 Answers
מיכי Staff answered 5 years ago
I think that anyone who treats their words as a set of behavioral guidelines is missing the point. They write what is right and what is proper, not how to implement it and how to behave. Everyone decides that for themselves. (By the way, in my opinion, everyone should also formulate for themselves what is right and proper.)

Discover more from הרב מיכאל אברהם

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

שאלה replied 5 years ago

Hello,
I didn't quite understand the answer.
For example, the Ramachal in the Yesharim line writes instructions carefully on how to fumble, etc., and quickly on how to be quick, etc.
For example, Rabbi Kook in the Orots Teshuva writes all kinds of practical instructions.

מיכי replied 5 years ago

They write suggestions, not instructions. At least that's how it should be viewed.

נור replied 5 years ago

How foolish to think that the great Torah scholars did not experience trials, that the ranks of the righteous are only due to the difficulties they went through, even if in fact they were not the same trials, but they experienced the same problems.

And our sages have already said that everyone who is greater than his fellow has a greater desire than him. Someone who has greater desires and is also wiser does not prevent him from being useful to someone who is going through lesser experiences than him.

נור replied 5 years ago

Of course they never intended to tell us instructions, that this was only given to us at Mount Sinai…

Leave a Reply

Back to top button