Is persuasion to faith through logical tools possible?

Hello Rabbi,
 
I recently heard a claim from a Jewish intellectual from the United States named David Wolfe in which he claims that he has never been able to convince anyone to believe in God from purely logical arguments. Do you agree?
Let me explain a little: In your experience, have you seen an atheist become convinced of the existence of God from the physico-theological or cosmological proof or only from the proof from morality or as opposed to any emotional arguments?