moral

I meant according to morality.

Rabbi, I remember you once said that it was completely unnecessary, precisely because if someone is already dead, it's just revenge.

I did mean reward and not punishment. Regarding punishment, it is necessary to discuss it, since if it is given in the world, then it does not achieve its purpose (deterrence in the world). Therefore, it is more reasonable to threaten and not to carry out. But then what is your point? There is no room for your question, since you assume that there is a point in punishing otherwise his wrongdoings are not rewarded. In other words, you assume that the justification for punishment is not deterrence but revenge.

What is the meaning of the division between reward and punishment? If we do not assume a reward goal for reward and punishment but only deterrence/incitement, then God should also pamper those who behaved badly with a large jacuzzi in the next world, since this is no longer known.

Regarding wages, there is a stronger intuition that it is not given just to spur me on, but because I deserve it. A kind of fulfillment of a contract. In contrast, with punishment, there is no meaning in fulfilling the contract because I probably won't want to be punished, and God has no interest in it either. Therefore, it makes more sense to see it as a deterrent.

I once wrote a similar distinction regarding the difference between a Baal Teshuvah and one who is in question. One can be forgiven for transgressions committed before the law, because this is a remaining obligation. But for one who is in question, God Almighty cannot erase his remaining right before the law. This is only with His consent.

Even the salary has no meaning in fulfilling the contract. I will not want potions (I will want a salary much greater than I deserve) and God has no interest in it either (what does he care about pampering me more?!)

By the way, there is a kind of paradox here. God is unable to punish in the afterlife, otherwise it contradicts his being moral. Maybe it is an inability of the kind to create a square triangle and therefore it is not really a limitation on him

In both posts here, we've already entered the realm of chatter. There's nothing immoral about it. It's just not necessary. And as for salary, I want it but I don't deserve it.