New on the site: Michi-bot. An intelligent assistant based on the writings of Rabbi Michael Avraham.

question

שו”תCategory: Halachaquestion
asked 2 years ago

In honor of Rabbi Michael Avraham Shlita
question:
I studied in a yeshiva and transferred to a kollel. Can I take the religions for myself? And if I don’t want to take them for myself, is it permissible to give the religions to someone else? And then to whom should I give them?
Regards
A.I.A.

Leave a Reply

0 Answers
מיכי Staff answered 2 years ago

I didn’t understand.

א.י.א replied 2 years ago

Religions = Amount of money that the state funds the yeshiva with so that it can finance me as a yeshiva student.
Question:
A. Since I transferred from the yeshiva and the yeshiva no longer pays me anything, am I allowed to take the money since I continue to study?

מיכי Staff replied 2 years ago

How can you take money that comes from the state to a yeshiva? Is there an envelope in your name at the office?
If you are no longer studying at the yeshiva, it itself should report this and not accept money from you.

א.י.א replied 2 years ago

True. But if I transfer the money from the religions to the kollel, I receive kollel religions, which is actually what I do today, studying at the kollel [like a regular avrech who receives religions].

מיכי Staff replied 2 years ago

I'm sorry, but I don't understand. Do you receive a scholarship directly from the Ministry of Religious Affairs? Doesn't the yeshiva receive it and pass it on to you?

א.י.א replied 2 years ago

At first I was in a yeshiva and then I moved to a kollel [and I'm still a boy] and there is a possibility to transfer the religious money that the state gives to a yeshiva if I register for a kollel and then from the perspective of the Ministry of Religious Affairs I am a berecher who accepts religious people. Now the question is whether I am allowed to take the money because I am not exactly a berecher, because I am a boy, and on the other hand, may I hate

דוד ש. replied 2 years ago

Instead of understanding the situation exactly, I will give you the rule: (to the best of my knowledge) if it is legal, it is permitted.
Morally, ask yourself if the legislator had you and your actions in mind when he budgeted for religions

מיכי Staff replied 2 years ago

I gave up. Anyway, David S. wrote beautifully.

Leave a Reply

Back to top button