Regarding Stalin’s example and the responsibility of the Russian people for his actions
Hello Rabbi,
In the last lesson on judging evil, you mentioned the example of Stalin and the responsibility of the Russian people for his actions. You mentioned the issue of collective responsibility. On the other hand, I remember you saying in the past that not every group of people constitutes a collective. For a group of people to constitute a collective, there must be something that binds them together (such as a system of law and justice). And so, regarding Stalin’s example, there is no collective of the Russian people upon whom collective responsibility can be imposed. Isn’t that so?
Another question that occurred to me in this context is, how does this example parallel Aharon Barak’s story of the unreasonable action of the reasonable person?
Best regards,
They are definitely a collective. If this is not a collective, what is a collective?
I did not make a full comparison between the situations. My argument is that in both cases, responsibility is imposed on a person who is not really at fault. He acted reasonably (like a reasonable person) and yet he is still held responsible.
Leave a Reply
Please login or Register to submit your answer