Reincarnation? And more among Druze?…
Greetings to the Honorable Rabbi,
I would love to hear a logical explanation for the phenomenon described here; a Druze child who didn’t speak at all until the age of two and suddenly began speaking fluent English with a British accent:
https://drive.google.com/file/d/1ISkmYBDoeNDjLajXFwhLMgCxzZ0fcd2L/view
[I came to this by referring to this website – https://rationalbelief.org.il/%D7%90%D7%99%D7%95%D7%9D-%D7%95%D7%A9%D7%9E%D7%95-%D7%92%D7%9C%D7%92%D7%95%D7%9C-%D7%A0%D7%A9%D7%9E%D7%95%D7%AA/%5D
Yes, I heard about this case, and I have no explanation. A similar case in some respects is discussed in the books on the science of freedom (about a girl with a split personality who, in one of her performances, knows how to play the piano even though she never learned it).
As I wrote about the girl, it seems that at least we can conclude from this that there is a soul beyond the body and brain, but not necessarily that there are reincarnations, etc. (this is not necessary for the purpose of the study). If we only had a brain and not a soul and mind, the chance that a brain with a neuronal system containing all the information that allows us to speak English (which happens after we learn to speak) would be created by chance is zero. It’s hard to believe that such a thing happens by chance. Maybe there is a mechanism that transmits brain information through heredity? Sounds pretty fantastic.
There was a well-known case of an old Gentile woman on her deathbed who began quoting entire sections of the Book of Zohar in its own language (she knew neither Aramaic nor Hebrew).
In this case, they were not too lazy to trace her life story, and it turns out that in her youth she worked for a certain period of time as a servant in a Jewish house, where the owner of the house sat at the table and chopped Zohar, and it turns out that somehow her brain absorbed the things, and during her illness, during twilight and hallucinations, the things floated.
I would bet that in the present case too, a good investigation will find the source.
There is a big difference between an old woman and a two-year-old child who sometimes doesn't even speak his mother tongue fluently.
There is a difference, and yet, a good investigation would probably have found the source.
People here are probably not up to date, but the Rabbi? They already found the explanation for this:
https://www.mako.co.il/tvbee-articles/Article-173dbb809b6a361006.htm
First, I'm not sure they found the explanation. The explanation also needs to be examined. But, why is it that I'm not up to date? I heard and responded to the facts I heard. If there is an explanation - excellent.
My filter is blocking me from this link. Could the scientific updater kindly copy what is written there for me?
Thanks!
“But one hypothesis caught our eye more than others. One of the comments said that the child “watched too much Peppa Pig, they'll put him in the confused Yuval and he'll start speaking Hebrew”. A conspiracy theory involving children's TV shows? Let's just say “a case where it says tvbee” and that's it. Indeed, listening carefully to ’George’ from the original British version of “Pepa the Pig” revealed what is called an eerie similarity to the child's accent, as well as to his vocabulary.
Did you notice the similarity in the pronunciation of the word “Dinosaur”? Because we heard it and we haven't been calm since.”
Very interesting! It does indeed sound the same accent.
Does this really solve all the problems, including the scales and the key and so on?
Moshe, there are Peppa Pig videos for children that deal with using scales and keys. Whether that's relevant or not - you decide.
It reminded me that a few years ago I heard about a friend of a friend, here in Israel, whose child had a speech delay and then suddenly started speaking in Spanish even though they only spoke Hebrew at home, and the number of Spanish words they knew could be counted on the fingers of one hand.
But since his parents are rational Jews, for whom the theory of reincarnation is not the first thing they think of, they did some research and it turned out that the caregivers at the child's daycare spoke Spanish.
If he had been born in Magd El Shams, they would probably have made a TV show about him.
Leave a Reply
Please login or Register to submit your answer
