New on the site: Michi-bot. An intelligent assistant based on the writings of Rabbi Michael Avraham.

Sabbath

שו”תSabbath
asked 7 months ago

Hello Michi,
Last Shabbat I went down at 6 am to take out the trash and saw a Hasidic with a beard and sideburns and a long black coat sitting on a bench smoking for his own enjoyment. When he noticed me, he smiled and called out to me, “Git Sha’abs!” I asked him if he knew that there was a prohibition on lighting a fire on Shabbat, and he claimed that nowadays it was irrelevant because fire is a much less “creative” action due to technological advances, and that, on the other hand, actions that are truly “creative” should be made stricter. What do you think of his statement? If he is right, do you have any ideas about which “creative” actions that are currently considered productive on Shabbat should become prohibited?
 
thanks,
 
Joseph

Leave a Reply

0 Answers
מיכי Staff answered 7 months ago

Nonsense. I don’t see why it is less creative today, and even if it were, that is no reason to allow it. The Mishnah’s determination has the same authority as the Sanhedrin, and it takes the Sanhedrin to change it.

Leave a Reply

Back to top button