The direction of sleep in modern research and among the sages
Hello Rabbi,
I recently came across a video in which someone claims that there is a modern study that recommends placing the bed in the north-south direction rather than east-west. The name of the study is: “Bedroom Design Orientation and Sleep Electroencephalography Signals.” The study concludes by writing:
The present study findings provide evidence that bed orientation influences sleep EEG signals and sleeping towards the EMF (NS) can have some positive effects on the sleep EEG.
This immediately reminded me of the Gemara in Berakot Ha-Ha 2:
Tanya, Abba Binyamin says: I have been sorry for two things all my life – for my prayer to be in front of my bed, and for my bed to be placed between north and south. For my prayer to be in front of my bed – is it in front of my bed? Or is it literally in front of my bed – and Rav Yehuda said, Rav and Itima Rabbi Yehoshua ben Levi said: How can a person who prays not have something between him and the wall – as it is said: And Hezekiah turned his face to the wall and prayed. Not in front of my bed, but in front of my bed. For my bed to be placed between north and south – as Rabbi Hama the son of Rabbi Hanina said, Rabbi Yitzchak said: Whoever places his bed between north and south will have male children, as it is said: And your belly will be filled with sons, they will be satisfied with sons. Rav Nachman bar Yitzchak said: Nor does his wife miscarry; it is written here: And your belly will be filled with sons, and it is written that the barren and her days to give birth are fulfilled, and behold, the barren are in her womb.
I wanted to ask you about this: Is this a coincidence? Or maybe the sages had special understandings about human nature?
Best regards,
Discover more from הרב מיכאל אברהם
Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.
Discover more from הרב מיכאל אברהם
Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.
This is a study with 21 participants. There are serious reporting issues, including an almost complete lack of demographic data on the participants. Nothing is said about randomization of the participants to the two treatment conditions (sleeping “with” or “against” the direction of the Earth's magnetic field). The methodology of data analysis seems almost arbitrary. The journal in which this was published is not listed in any academic journal database that I know of, was founded in 2014, and operates on a pay-to-play model that does not add to its reputation.
In short, I am with the Rav++. I am completely skeptical of this study in particular.
What Rabbi understands at all about anatomy and life itself, most of them are completely ignorant and uneducated, period!
According to Feng Shui, it is mandatory to sleep with the head facing north, that's how it is, and the Chinese are an ancient and wise people no less than the people of Israel and it has been for centuries, so research by anyone who is in the thick of Feng Shui is not serious at all!
Leave a Reply
Please login or Register to submit your answer