New on the site: Michi-bot. An intelligent assistant based on the writings of Rabbi Michael Avraham.

The next mitzvah in transgression and something else

שו”תCategory: generalThe next mitzvah in transgression and something else
asked 8 years ago

Hey Miki
Before I bring up the subject itself, I feel the need to share something fresh, fresh with you: Since the teeth in my mouth are ruined, I went to our dentist and he explained to me that he was prevented from treating my teeth except for temporary treatment due to the surgery. [I knew there was a problem – any infection in the jaw could spread to the heart!]
This morning, I’m sorry – I googled and found that the doctor who operated on me has a website with answers. I said to myself: “What could it be?” – I’ll ask today, he’ll answer when he’s free [if at all…], and I asked the question about dental care after the surgery. And here’s a surprise – within a few minutes he answered me – no problem!
Thus his desecration of Shabbat increased my Shabbat pleasure… I will punish you – the next mitzvah in transgression!
Now I want to share with you a very interesting story I experienced today:
Today we celebrated a birthday for one of my daughters in the Ilanot forest. After the feast, X [my eldest daughter], Y and I walked along the “forest” paths. As we wandered, Y told X how, among other things, the angels guide him and his wife to study a chapter from the Bible, based on a random selection. This week, the lot fell on 1 Kings, chapter 22, the event in which Ahab fell.
And the question is asked, what was the point of the angels summoning Y and his wife to this particular event? I tell you this because I don’t remember whether your book, The Sciences of Freedom, addresses this complex and delicate issue – to what extent man is sovereign and responsible for his words and actions. I have the impression that this is an extreme expression of the saying of Chazal: Everything is in the hands of Heaven – except for the fear of Heaven!
The funny thing is that X is a very rational person, but she accepts the matter of Y’s connection with the angels as fact.
Tomorrow or in the next few days I will send you another thought – and again regarding Reform Judaism.
So all the best to you and have a good week.

Leave a Reply

0 Answers
מיכי Staff answered 8 years ago

Hello A.
As you know, I don’t really understand things about angels. That’s why it’s hard for me to answer you why they did or didn’t do something. But if Y is knowledgeable, it’s likely that he inquired correctly.
So what do we do with the teeth in the end?
All the best.

ע' replied 8 years ago

Safra Taba Lekh Mikhi
The honor of the angels is in their place, but they are nothing more than “media agents” . The poignant question is indeed the degree of sovereignty of man over his words and actions. That is why I usually pray to God, and ask Him to guide me what to do. Because I am aware that although my intentions may be good and worthy, I may make wrong decisions - and not only in personal matters. That is why I have adopted the belief in private providence, without which I would be lost altogether!
Have a nice day

מיכי Staff replied 8 years ago

Personally, I do not adopt factual claims because they are useful, but only if I conclude that they are true.

Leave a Reply

Back to top button