The obligation of the first blessing from the rabbinate
In the blessings for her, the Gemara seeks a source for the first blessing.
Rabbi Akiva learned this from a verse dealing with Neta Reba:
“‘[And in the fourth year all its fruit shall be] holy to the Lord ‘ – teaches that a blessing is recited before and after them, hence Rabbi Akiva said: It is forbidden for a person to taste anything before reciting the blessing.”
The issue continues and brings up two more sources for reciting a blessing before eating:
I said it lightly: When he is full – he blesses; when he is hungry – not even more so?!
… It is understood: It is forbidden for a person to enjoy this world without a blessing.”
Here we found three sources that serve as a Torah law: a sermon, a qu’on, and a sabbarah. And yet, according to all the Rishonim, the first blessing is the rabbinan…
- A sermon can be said to be a reference and not a binding source. But why say so, and how do we know the difference between a sermon and a reference?
- What are the ‘flaws’ in the KJV and the Sabra that do not make them Torah?
- Since the law is truly rabbinical, why does the Talmud look for a ‘source’ for rabbinical law? Many regulations were established by the Sages without a source, but according to what seemed necessary to them. What is the point of finding a (fictitious?) source for such a law?
Discover more from הרב מיכאל אברהם
Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.
Discover more from הרב מיכאל אברהם
Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.
Leave a Reply
Please login or Register to submit your answer