They did not make it to Zion and were destroyed in Auschwitz. The Rebbe told them not to make it.

שו”ת › Category: faith › They did not make it to Zion and were destroyed in Auschwitz. The Rebbe told them not to make it.

0 Vote Up Vote Down

asked 4 years ago

My family was content to return to Zion. (Due to the hatred of the surrounding Gentiles, they were extremely wealthy and lacked nothing.)
The priests told them to stay in exile and promised that it would be fine.
Those who believed in the Redemptorists did not return to Zion and were buried in Auschwitz, and the blood of their offspring was also from the Redemptorists who promised and because of their promise they were destroyed.

But in Jeremiah 29, the opposite is true: the false prophets encourage the return of Zion, and Jeremiah, in the name of God, says no.
Only 70 more years
And now the trend is reversed, in Babylon they will surely live, build houses and carry off women. And the people of Jerusalem will be slaughtered and starved.

So what is true?
To return to Zion or, conversely, to settle in exile?

Discover more from הרב מיכאל אברהם

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

Leave a ReplyCancel reply

0 Answers

0 Vote Up Vote Down

מיכי Staff answered 4 years ago

This is a disgusting mess. Everything for its own sake. A Rebbe who expressed his opinion not to go to Aliyah for his own reasons said something completely legitimate. The fact that it ended badly in the end does not bind him to the outcome. No one’s blood is on his hands. If he made promises irresponsibly, then perhaps even more so. As for prophets, they speak prophetic information, so that’s a completely different discussion. If they promise something, it’s in the name of God. As a general rule, the answer to the question of whether to go to the land is not always the same. Sometimes it is right to go and sometimes not. Although there is a commandment to settle the land, a prophet removes something from the Torah in a moment or for a moment.

Discover more from הרב מיכאל אברהם

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.