New on the site: Michi-bot. An intelligent assistant based on the writings of Rabbi Michael Avraham.

Torah is Magna and Mitzvah

שו”תCategory: faithTorah is Magna and Mitzvah
asked 2 months ago

Hello Rabbi Michi, there are sources in the Talmud that Torah study provides protection and protection from sin, torment, or existential protection for an individual, a community, or the entire world (“If it were not for Torah, heaven and earth would not exist,” “Torah protects and protects,” “Rabbanan is not without purity”; I did not do a comprehensive search).
1. My question is whether, according to your knowledge and understanding, the sources (according to the plain meaning of the Gemara or whether there is a necessity from the words of the Rishonim) must necessarily be interpreted as a kind of “automatic mystical” protection. Or is it possible that it works in the usual providential way, if one does the will of a place – and among other things, studies Torah – then we receive a reward, namely protection and sustenance (according to this, the purpose of the sayings is to enhance the importance of studying Torah and not to innovate on some mystical mechanism).
2. If the answer is no, can you give me the necessary sources for mystical understanding? (As ancient as possible; the most ancient I know is the Chofetz Chaim, actually maybe even the Maharal B’Teferet?)
3. Where is it explicitly stated that it works quantitatively, say a fixed amount of “protection” depending on the time and quality of some study, meaning that there is a “price list” (I hope the question is clear)?
As a background to my question, I will mention the Haredi claim (one of them) that they do not enlist because studying Torah protects no less than IDF soldiers (quantitative understanding?). This is a clear mystical understanding because if it is a reward for doing the will of the place of discussion, there must be another – what is his will? Maybe we should also make an effort and enlist?
That’s it. Sorry for the length, maybe this is a topic that deserves an article and a review of sources (have you written about it?) and not a question here, but that’s what it is, I’d be happy for you to enlighten me.
Thank you very much.


Discover more from הרב מיכאל אברהם

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

Leave a Reply

0 Answers
מיכי Staff answered 2 months ago
  1. I don’t think so. In any case, there are no binding sources here because this is not a halakha. There are also conflicting sources so you won’t get anywhere from here. I didn’t exactly understand the difference between the normal providential path and the mystical approach. Isn’t providential mysticism?
  2. I have no interest in such sources.
  3. Who said it works quantitatively? Do you really think the Haredi claim is a quantitative claim? Do you really think they rely on Torah Magna and Matzala? Nonsense. They demand that those who do not study also be exempted. These are empty slogans.
Therefore, it does not seem worth an article at all. I addressed this briefly in the ruling I wrote on military conscription. Column 649.

Discover more from הרב מיכאל אברהם

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

Leave a Reply

Back to top button