New on the site: Michi-bot. An intelligent assistant based on the writings of Rabbi Michael Avraham.

Voting for G and the belief in “great men”

שו”תCategory: philosophyVoting for G and the belief in “great men”
asked 6 years ago

*** Deleted ****


Discover more from הרב מיכאל אברהם

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

Leave a Reply

0 Answers
מיכי Staff answered 6 years ago
Benjamin, I erase and erase, and you are on your own. I ask you to stop this trolling. We’re all fed up with it.

Discover more from הרב מיכאל אברהם

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

מהיציע replied 6 years ago

In the Gemara Shabbat, page 1, the tease asked why the heads of Babylonians are oval, and repeated the question why the eyes of Thermodyans are slanted, and repeated the question why the feet of Africans are wide. And here we must examine the tease's opinion as to why he switched from Babylonians to Thermodyans and did not continue to ask about Babylonians why they eat Nehemah in Nehemah and why they stay in a dark place. However, he also understood that if one constantly teases about the same exact subject, then the rebuke will be in order (and therefore he will not win the bet).

To the ’from the gallery’ – Hello,

It seems that the questioner Mahalel moved to the Thermoidians’ because the Thermoidians’ have a dream, and thus he could have asked: ‘Why do the Thermoidians have eyes…’ 🙂

With blessings, Shimshovin Leitz

מהיציע replied 6 years ago

You made me laugh, that's funny 🙂

רציונלי(יחסית) replied 6 years ago

It doesn't seem to me that Benjamin sees this entirely as trolling. I believe that in some of the questions he asks completely in good faith (whether to pray for the death of those who violate the Corona regulations, for example, is it clear that this is a question that came to provoke?)

בנימין גורלין replied 6 years ago

Rational (relatively)…
“In the days of Rabban Gamliel, the species in Israel multiplied, and they would bring trouble to Israel and turn them away from the Lord. And since he saw that this was greater than all human needs, he stood with his court, and established one blessing that would contain a request from the Lord to destroy the species, and he established it in the prayer, so that it would be recited by all. The blessings in the prayer are found, nineteen blessings”

— Mishneh Torah, Sefer Ahava, Hilchot Tefila, Chapter 2’, Halacha 1’

רציונלי(יחסית) replied 6 years ago

I didn't know that the definitions of "minut" include violating Corona regulations (which, in my humble opinion, even if we define everyone who violates the sages' rule as a secular government, it does not have the validity of the sages' rule from a halakhic perspective)
But maybe your knowledge is greater than mine, it would be good to learn something more

On the 2nd of Nisan 5779

To Razza, Shalom Rav,

Benyamin's explanation was to learn from the harsh attitude towards species that pose a spiritual danger to the people of Israel, that such should be the attitude towards those who are not careful and may cause others to be infected with the Corona virus, which poses a high risk to the elderly and those with medical problems.

And perhaps Bruria's solution is better: to pray that those who behave inappropriately will repent, and that they will become sinners and not sinners. And we will pray for those who err, that they will be granted the right path out of submission and a broken heart, who look to humility and joy.

With blessings, Sh.

רציונלי(יחסית) replied 6 years ago

There are several other possibilities:
1 His opinion is that anyone who mocks the sages and belittles their personalities is considered a member of the sages. We have been warned in several places about the law of the kingdom of the kingdom, and he believes that a secular government is in this category, just like all the kingdoms of the nations, and therefore violating government regulations is in the category of violating the command of the sages and in turn belittling their value - therefore those who violate the order are literally members of the species and should be wished for their death.
2 He is referring to the violators of the Corona regulations, the Haredim, who in his opinion desecrate the name of God and thus the damage they do is no worse than the damage that the Torah disbelievers do because they desecrate the name of God and thus incite the people of Israel against God, the Holy One, and therefore should be wished for their death.
3 He believes that the halakhic law of persecutor applies to those who violate the Corona regulations because they knowingly cause the death of another person.
Therefore, one should say with a clear mind that they should be killed and not just wished for their death! And because of the fear of censorship, he uses a more softened example that is only a prayer for the death of the sinner.
4 Perhaps Benjamin Gorlin is a devout Zionist and believes that the State of Israel is the foundation of the throne of God in the world, and hence the government of Israel is not just a government but a real monarchy, and to the honor of Benjamin Netanyahu, there is a king's law and his regulations are binding.
And hence he believes that violators of the regulations are rebels in the kingdom and therefore they deserve death and are generally considered heretics and heretics (and it must be made difficult whether they are heretics and heretics or whether babies who were captured if they grew up among the Haredim are considered babies who were captured because they are not aware that the government of Israel is the law of the kingdom of Israel, and the same applies if they grew up as secularists).

Leave a Reply

Back to top button