Why is a question being deleted?
I am a sinner.
I asked a question about the rabbi who served in the Mossad in Tehran.
H
I’m serious…
Why was the question deleted?
I’m very surprised to hear that you’re serious. It would have clearly looked like a troll. Phrase the question precisely without going into all the ridiculous descriptions you gave there. In particular, I would recommend not asking questions about what someone who holds positions that are bizarre in their own way is supposed to say. It’s unnecessary chatter. And finally, even if someone thinks that being a TA is a disadvantage, there’s no reason to conclude from this that saying to someone in their face that they are a TA is slander. The same goes for any virtue or neutral trait that someone thinks is a disadvantage.
The question is definitely a question. And I meant it seriously according to your known values.
Years ago, when I was using R”M in some yeshiva, there was a discipline and excursion manager who mocked some famous rabbi [whom some consider one of the greatest in the country] that there were rumors that he served in the Israeli institution [in my opinion, this is great praise, in the opinion of the aforementioned guide, this is a reason for ridicule and contempt] When I heard that, I told him, and is it just rumors? This is Wikipedia explicitly… he is an IDF that has managed to mock.
He went to the R”I place, and decided that Wikipedia is not trustworthy, and that the hands of the wicked control it. And the evidence is that it is written there about some other famous rabbi [Z”L] lowly and lesser facts of life. [And that R”I greatly appreciates that late Rabbi and assumes that these are lies] Therefore: Conclusion: Wikipedia is unreliable in describing facts about rabbis…
On Shabbat after the prayer on the street I went up to the deserted synagogue, and saw a new book. [From the author Baruch Kashrut, every few weeks a unique Torah book in its style] I looked through it, and of course there was also a daily topic. Corona laws.
I saw that he asked about reading the Megillah via radio and telephone [I hesitated to zoom in more..] and first brought up R’ Moshe Feinstein and Tzitz Eliezer and other poskim who tended to be lenient, and then the opinions of the stricter ones…
And he tells the story of his rabbi [who is the aforementioned rabbi whose story began the discussion] that when he was a spy for the Mossad in Tehran [born in France, immigrated to Israel, possibly holding two passports?] he once entered the Great Synagogue in Tehran [?] on Shabbat and saw that people were praying there through a loudspeaker. He asked, and they told him that it was a battery-powered loudspeaker, turned on on Shabbat evening {or a Shabbat clock?] and if they don't do so they won't listen. And if they don't listen they won't come. And if they don't come their Judaism will be lost/sinked. And anyway this is the hour of need…
Regarding our matter, that rabbi, in his old age, does not hide from his students his service in the Mossad in Tehran [and does not see it as wrong]
After Shabbat I checked with the author, and he confirmed the facts.
Of course I couldn't resist, and I sent it to a staff member… he saw that he had indeed served in the Mossad.
Now I wonder if I have not sinned again with the sins of the tongue.
To me, this is great praise. To that staff member [and part of his community, people with a type of logic that I do not quite understand], this is great reproach…
And here I have reinforced the reproach with him [according to his feeble mind] Did I sin with my tongue?
And in any case, this is published in a famous book, these are things known to all…
Do I need to repeat this in the repentance?
Or do we not discuss what is considered reproach according to the feeble mind?
Does the rabbi know how to answer me?
Delusional. I'm sorry, but it really seems like trolling. What does this have to do with slander? It's known in the noses of thousands of women, and it's not a negative thing at all (or even a positive thing). So what's the point of this rant? Isn't the answer obvious? And I answered it before.
Yes, may God bless you.
As I suspected.
By the way, a T”S fell in my name. Of course, I mention my sins. And not my sins that dry.
And he is merciful…
https://he.wikipedia.org/wiki/%D7%A9%D7%9C%D7%9E%D7%94_%D7%90%D7%91%D7%99%D7%A0%D7%A8#%D7%91%D7%99%D7%95%D7%92%D7%A8%D7%A4%D7%99%D7%94
On the 7th of Adar, 5771
Rabbi Aviner told one of his lessons that, while he was a student in a yeshiva, he was approached with an offer to go on a “national scientific-security mission.” When he asked his rabbi, Rabbi Kook, the late Rabbi, the rabbi replied: “I also have a national scientific-security mission for you: be diligent in studying Torah.”
And for this reason, only after he had fulfilled his role as a rabbi and adjudicator and had grown in Torah study did Rabbi Aviner agree to go on a “national security mission,” as King Solomon said: “P. For every time and a season for every purpose under the sun.
With regards, Menashe Fishel Halevi Zuchmir
Leave a Reply
Please login or Register to submit your answer
