Kusimuka nekudonha kwaBennett uye Zvazvinoreva (Koramu 486)

BSD

Mangwanani ano (Chishanu) ndakaverenga Tora naRabhi Daniel Sagron (Ndinofunga kuti aiwanzoita zvekutamba uye akanditsamwira zvikuru mukuyananisa) pamutengo wemweya iyo sangano renyika-yechitendero rinofanirwa kuita mushure mekudonha kwaBennett uye kuparara kwebato rakarurama. Muchidimbu, gakava rake nderokuti mudzi wedambudziko mubatanidzwa wechitendero nerudzi. Anotsanangura kuti (chitendero) nyika haina mukana kunze kwekunge ichivimba nechitendero (pane kungosungirirwa pairi muhuni), nenzira yaRabbi Kook. Ndakafunga kuti iyi yakanga iri nharo inofadza, uye inondipa mukana wekukurukura iyi nyaya inokosha.

Ndatove pano ndinofanira kujekesa kuti kushandisa kwandinoita hyphen kwakapesana nekwayo. Kwandiri hyphen inoratidza kubatana kwakakosha pakati pemativi maviri, chaizvo izvo Daniel Sagron anomuparidzira. Ini ndinopokana kuti iyo hyphen inofanirwa kubviswa chaizvo nekuti zvakakosha kubvisa kutsamira pakati peZionism (nemamwe maitiro) uye chinamato. Musiyano wemazwi echokwadi hauna kukosha, asi gakava riri shure kwayo, uye nezve iyo muchikamu chino.

Pakati pechitendero-nyika uye Orthodox-mazuva ano

Munhevedzano yemakoramu emazuva ano Orthodoxy (475 - 480, Skipping 479. Uye zvino chikamu ichi chinobatanawo) Ndakaedza kutsanangura pfungwa iyi, uye kuisiyanisa kubva kune zvechitendero-nyika kana Zionist-chinamato (kwandiri pano aya mazwi akafanana, uye anofanira kunge "anofanana" mune dzimwe pfungwa se zvakanaka). Ndakaita nharo ipapo kuti pasi pemusoro wekuti 'Haredi' pane zvirevo zviviri zvakazvimiririra: 1. Kupikiswa kweZionism. 2. Kupikisa zvemazuva ano. Chero zvazvingava, kusiyana kunofanira kuitwa pakati pemapoka maviri mukati mechitendero chisiri cheHaredi: 1. Avo vanotsigira Zionism (chii zvakadaro?) Asi hazvifaniri kutora mazuva ano. Mwoyo weboka iri ndewemasitadhi, kana izvo zvinodaidzwa kuti munyika-yechitendero quarantine. Izvi zvinotsigira zvechitendero uye halakhic conservatism, asi vanotsigira Zionism. 2. Avo vanotsigira chimanjemanje asi kwete hazvo chiZion. Ndakadana aya maOrthodoxy emazuva ano (izvo zvinogona kunge zviri Zionist, uye zvinowanzoita).

Ini ndakatsanangura yemazuva ano Orthodoxy ipapo kuburikidza nehunhu hwehalakhic nharo dzavanosimudza (inochengetedza midrash yakavakirwa pahunhu, uye kwete chokwadi). Ndakatsanangura kuti hwaro hwekubata kwake hunhu hwemazuva ano uye hunhu hwemazuva ano. Vanoda kubatanidza mune yavo halakhic uye yechitendero hunhu hunobva kunze vasina kukumbira ruregerero uye vasingataure mazwi akaremara anotitsanangurira kuti hunhu uhwu hunobva (sedemocracy, kutevera ruzhinji, kuenzana, kodzero dzevanhu, nezvimwe zvakadaro MuTora. Zvinoratidzika kuti kunyange maererano nemapoka aya zvinokwanisika kusiyanisa pakati pemazuva ano-Orthodox nedash, iyo yemazuva ano ine kukosha kwechitendero, uye dzidziso yemazuva ano isina dash, iyo inobatanidza maitiro maviri asi haioni mazuva ano sechitendero. value.

Zvakakosha kuti ndijekese kuti mukuona kwangu hakuna nzvimbo yekuchengeta chero tsika dzisingabvi mukuda kwaMwari. Izvi hazvisi zvehuzivi (ona chikamu 456) Uye zvakare halakhic zvisiri pamutemo uye zvebhaibheri (iri rudzi rwebasa rekunze rakabatana). Uye zvakadaro muOrthodoxy yemazuva ano mavambo ehutsika uhwu haasi muTorah zvinyorwa (Bhaibheri kana vachenjeri) asi muhana yemunhu anofurirwa nemamiriro ekunze kwenyika yake. Anofunga kuti ndiko kuda kwaMwari kubva kwaari, asi haazvitore kubva kuzvinyorwa zvatakapiwa kubva kumusoro. Naizvozvo panogara paine dashi kumashure, asi rinobatana nekuda kwaMwari uye kwete kuTorah kana chinamato neimwe pfungwa. Ani naani anochengeta chero hunhu ane chitendero. Kunyange ichi chiri chinamato chepasi rose chinotenda muna Mwari wehuzivi uye kwete hazvo theism mupfungwa yayo yakazara.[1] Saka kwandiri hapana hyphen apa. Ndakazvipira kumirairo maererano nezvakanyorwa muTorah uye ndakazvipira kukuda kwaMwari nekuti izvo zvinoratidzika kwandiri kuti ndizvo zvaanoda. Iko hakuna kubatana kwakananga pakati pezviviri izvi, uye iyi ndiyo hyphen isipo.

Kuwanda kwemazuva ano munzanga yechitendero

Ndakamira ipapo muchidimbu (uye kumwewo mune zvakadzama) zvakare nezve kukanganiswa kwezvematongerwo enyika kuripo munharaunda yechitendero, iyo yakakamurwa kweinenge zana pakati pechitendero cheZionists uye Ultra-Orthodox. Sangano rechitendero rinoona kunyura kwezvematongerwo enyika kumativi eZionist axis, sekunge hurumende yakanga isati yasimbiswa makore 75 apfuura, uye sekunge hurukuro iri kuitika pamusoro pekuisimbisa uye kana kubatanidzwa nayo. Gakava iri riri kupisa uye rinopisa kusvika nhasi sekunge tiri pamavambo ehurongwa uhu, uye ndiye anosiyanisa mapato ezvematongerwo enyika akasiyana-siyana anomirira veruzhinji. Cherechedza kuti chokwadi hapana mutsauko maererano nehurumende pakati pezviviri. Kazhinji, aya maonero akasiyana. Asi nokuda kwechimwe chikonzero ikoku kunoratidzika kumunhu ari wose kuva nzvimbo yakafanira umo gakava riri muvoruzhinji rorudzidziso rinofanira kuregwa, uye panofanira kuumbwa zvitendero zvakasiyana-siyana.

Asi mvura chaiyo inoyambuka nzanga yechitendero nhasi chaizvoizvo mutsara wechipiri: chizvinozvino. Iyo nharo chaiyo haisi pakati peZionist uye anti-Zionists asi pakati pemazuva ano uye anti-mazuva ano, kana pakati pekusununguka uye kuzarurirwa kune vasiri maZionists. Asi nokuda kwechimwe chikonzero muIsrael pfungwa yeOrthodoxy yemazuva ano inotadza kunyura, ndosaka tichiramba tichikandwa muhurukuro pamusoro pechitendero chenyika kana chechitendero-Zionism kupesana ne-ultra-Orthodox. Izvi zvinoitika zvakare uye zvakare musarudzo dzeMukuru Rabhi (ona zvandinotaura pane izvi Here), Kuti kunyange maererano navo pane kunyara kukuru uye mhute. Vanhu vanotaura sekunge kurwisana ndekwekuti kuchava neZionist kana ultra-Orthodox mukuru rabhi, nepo kurwisana kunofanira kunge kune zita remazuva ano kana rinopesana nemazuva ano. Rabhi akavhurika uye akasununguka kana rabhi anochengetedza. Izvo zvakakosha kuti unzwisise kuti axis iyi haina kunyatso kuenderana neiyo Zionist axis. Kusiyana neizvi, vazhinji vevaRabhi vechitendero cheZionist avo vanomirira chinzvimbo chemukuru wevaRabhi ndivo vanochengetedza maOrthodox pazvinhu zvese (kunze kwechikomborero chimwe uye mapisarema mashoma pazuva rimwe pagore). Maonero avo kune vakadzi uye chimiro chemunhu, uye mune dzidziso mune zvakajairika, akafanana chaizvo nemafungiro evaRabhi ve-ultra-Orthodox. Sekufunga kwangu, zviri chaizvo pakati pevarabhi veOrthodox nemadayanim kuti uchawana mafungiro akasununguka, asi izvi zvinoda kuongororwa. Uyezve, vamiriri vezvitendero zveOrthodox zvechinzvimbo charabhi mukuru (zvichida avo vari kushanda iye zvino, vaRabhi David Lau naYitzhak Yosef) vanoita maererano nemvumo yokutengesa sezvakaita rabhi wechitendero cheZionist uye vose vanototi rumbidzo paZuva Rokuzvitonga (I. funga kwete chete panguva yavo sevakuru veRabhi). Saka chii chakaipa kuti vasarudzwe? Ko sei vachemi vakachema mushure mekunge zvabuda musarudzo zvazivikanwa? Nekuti ivo vane hunhu hwekuchengetedza halakhah, asi mune ino mamiriro akafanana neakawanda evamwe vavhoti, kusanganisira maZionists echitendero. Kurwisana ikoko kwakanga kusiri pakati pevaOrthodox neZionists asi pakati pevanochengetedza uye vakasununguka. Hazvina maturo kutaura, maConservatives akakunda, sekugara nesu.

Zvimwe chetezvo ndezvechokwadi nezvezvamatongerwe enyika. Iro zita rekupokana kwepfungwa kunoitikawo kutenderedza Zionist axis, asi chokwadi iyo inonyanya kukosha uye yakakosha axis ndiyo axis yemazuva ano. Funga kwekanguva, chii chakasiyana pakati pe-ultra-Orthodox ne-ultra-Orthodox? Kusvika pakutonga kwangu iwe haungawani mutsauko wakadaro kunyange mu electron microscope (kunze kwemuvara we dome uye chimwe chikomborero chakadaro). Saka sei vaine mapato akasiyana? Smutritz's Religious Zionist Party yakasiyana sei nemapato e-ultra-Orthodox? Panyaya ipi yavanovhota zvakasiyana? Panogona kunge paine chinhu chidiki chakadaro, asi ini handingaendi nacho muhondo yenyika. Hazvishamisi kuti ivowo vanogara vachienda pamwe chete mune zvematongerwo enyika (uye nekuda kwechimwe chikonzero vanonzi 'chaizvo'. Likud inotaura nezvemubatanidzwa weZionist uye anti-Zionist zvinhu mumubatanidzwa, nemubatanidzwa wayo wakavakirwa pazvinhu zvinozvitsanangura sevasiri maZionist. Of. chokwadi, tsanangudzo isina chinhu). Kunyangwe maererano nekutarisa bhajeti, kupinza vanhu basa, kutendeuka, Mutungamiriri Mukuru weRabbinate uye kuderedzwa kwemasimba ayo, zvinzvimbo zvavo zvakafanana. Saka sei kune mapato maviri akasiyana pano? Just inertia, uye zvechokwadi zvido zvesimba uye chimiro. Mativi ose ane chido chekuenderera mberi nekukanganiswa uku, nokuti pairi zvose zvakavakwa. Pasina iyo havana hupenyu.

Kupokana kwangu ndekwekuti kwemakore akawanda kwave kusina kumiririrwa kwezvematongerwo enyika kweOrthodoxy yemazuva ano muIsrael. Kunyangwe pfungwa iyi zvakare pachayo haina kudzika midzi pano, asi mukuona kwangu ingori nyaya yekuzivikanwa. Kune vanhu vazhinji vanobatirira kwachiri, asi hakuna hutungamiriri hwakarongeka uye dzidziso yechitendero inohupa pamutemo uye saka ivo pachavo havazvizivise sevakadaro. Izvo zviri pachena kwavari kuti iyo Zionist-yechitendero modhi ndiyo muenzaniso wavo, kunyangwe ivo vasingazvibatanidzire muRamach neShasa yega yega. Paunobvunza munhu akadaro kuti ndechipi chitendero chake, achapindura kuti ndewechitendero cherudzi kwete kuti ndewechitendero chemazuva ano. Aya ndiwo magadzirirwo akaitwa muunganidzwa wevanarabhi veOrthodox, vakadai saRabhi Yaakov Ariel, Rabbi Druckman naRabbis Tao, Lior naMelamed, "vakuru vevaRabhi veZionism yechitendero" uye vatungamiriri vevanhu vechitendero cheZionist, izvo zvinosanganisirawo. Orthodoxy yemazuva ano. Chaizvoizvo hocus pocus, izvo zvese nezve pfungwa yekuvhiringidzika. Muunganidzwa wevaRabhi veOrthodox avo, kazhinji ruzhinji rwevanhu (kunze kwevashoma) vasingatendi munzira yavo kana mavari uye zvakare vasingateveri nzira yavo, vanodzokororwa korona semazwi e ruzhinji rwenyika-chinamato uye chemazuva ano. Zvinogara zvichindiyeuchidza nezve "vanoremekedzwa" vemusha wechiArab kana taundi rebudiriro reMoroccan. MuTel Aviv hamuna 'vanoremekedzwa' asi veruzhinji nevamiriri vayo vakasarudzwa, asi muchitendero netsika dzechivanhu uye mumagariro echiArab mune 'vanoremekedzwa'. Kusiyana kweavo kuti havafanirwe kusarudzwa. Vane ropafadzo ine ropafadzo inobva kudenga, uye munhu wose anofanira kuvaziva saizvozvo. Icho mhedzisiro yekufungidzira kwekufungidzira, uye nekudaro zvakare zvemagariro, zvemazuva ano Orthodoxy mukati uye pasi pemusoro wenyika-yechitendero. Kuedza kubuda imomo, kwakadai seDimension movement, kana kuti Torah neLabour vakavimbika, zvakaramba zvichikundikana mune zvematongerwo enyika nemagariro. Sezvakataurwa, mukuona kwangu hakusi nekuti hakuna ruzhinji rwevanhu asi nekuti hapana chitupa chakadaro.

Iyo yeultra-Orthodox Zionist-yechitendero propaganda yakabudirira mukuita kune veruzhinji fungidziro yenhema uye isiriyo yekuti nyika yechitendero yakakamurwa pakati peZionist echitendero nevekupedzisira-Orthodox. Vamwe vese vane lite (kureva kuti havasi vechitendero chaizvo, uye havaumbe muenzaniso wechitatu). Nokudaro hapana nzvimbo yakasara yeorthodox-yemazuva ano niche, yeimwe yakazaruka uye yakasununguka, asi kwete yepamusoro, yechitendero. Mumwe anotenda mune imwe nzira yechitendero kune vaviri ava. Parizvino hapana kuratidzwa kwezvematongerwo enyika nemagariro enzira yechitatu pakati peZionism yechitendero neiyo yekupedzisira-Orthodox, uye uku ndiko kubudirira kwavo kukuru uye kutadza kukuru kwedu tese. Kukundikana uku kunobva mukusajeka kwepfungwa uye kufamba mushure memaitiro akaipa nedzidzo yatakawana. Nokudaro kupwiswa kwangu kwakadzama mukukosha kwekuongorora kwekufungidzira uye kwehungwaru kwezviitiko izvi, nekuti pasina izvo hazvina hupenyu. Vanhu vazhinji vane zvinzvimbo izvi, asi chero bedzi vasingazvitsananguri uye vakazviisa pamepu uye vachivapa pamutemo wechitendero, havazove nekutaura kwezvematongerwo enyika nemagariro, uye havazokwanisi kupesvedzera nekuchinja.

Kudzokera kuna Bennett

Ndinofunga kuti chakavanzika chebudiriro yaNaftali Bennett mumakore achangobva kupfuura chave chiri chokuti akakwanisa kuva chiratidziro chechimiro chendangariro chazvino uno chechitendero. Iye pachake angave akakodzera zita remadunhurirwa rokuti Lite (ini handimuzivi, asi ndiwo mafungiro angu), uyewo haasi nyanzvi huru yeHalacha nechiJudha, uye naizvozvo haana kuwana uye akazvitsanangura pachake pfungwa dzaanosimudzira. Ichi ndichowo chikonzero nei varabhi ve-ultra-Orthodox veruzhinji rweZionist-chinamato vane (kana kuve ne) simba rakakura pazviri. Ichowo chibereko chedzidzo yavo uye manzwiro akabatanidzwa mairi kuti ivo hutungamiri uye ndivo vakakodzera muenzaniso, kunyange kana ini pachangu (Bennett) ndisipo chaizvo. Asi zviri pachena muhurukuro yake kuti zviri pachena kuti ari kuzvitarisira, uye izvi zviri kuuya kuzadzika nekusikwa kwaBennett uye kusunungurwa kwake kubva mumaketani ebato rechitendero reZionist kupinda munzvimbo yezvematongerwo enyika kuchigaro chemutungamiri wehurumende uye mubatanidzwa wake wakafara. .

Ndinofunga kuti ndicho chakavanzika chekubudirira kwake. Vazhinji vakamutevera nokuti vakaona kuti aimiririra, kunyange kana asingazive, nzvimbo yakafara isina mumiriri mukuru kusvika nhasi. Akabatana zviri nyore nevenyika, izvo zvechinyakare zvechitendero Zionism yanga ichiedza kuita kwemakore pasina budiriro, nekuti yechinyakare yechitendero Zionism inotungamirwa neiyo yekupedzisira-Orthodox. Izvi hazvigone kugadzira hukama chaihwo nevenyika. Vangani vanhu vakaita saAyelet Shaked vachada kuvhota vachipokana nekutorwa kweva-ultra-Orthodox uye vachifarira bhajeti reyeshivas uye nekuenderera mberi kwe-ultra-Orthodox parasitism, nekuda kwekuti vamwe vanopfeka vatema vanovaraira kudaro?

Bato remazuva ano rinopikisa ultra-Orthodox uye ultra-Orthodox conservatism rinogona nyore nyore kuumba mubatanidzwa nevasiri vechitendero vanofarira tsika yakasimba asi isiri-yekupedzisira-yeOrthodox uye kuzivikanwa kwechitendero nechitendero (izvo zvinowanzoenda nekodzero yezvematongerwo enyika nezvematongerwo enyika zvakare. ) Takataurawo nezvemubatanidzwa nemaArabu anofarira kugarisana zvine musoro neNyika yeIsrael. Aya, pamwe chete neakasununguka akasara, anoisa njodzi chaiyo kune Zionist-yechitendero fungidziro inoona nyika semucherechedzo wechiJudha neTorah. Chigaro chaMwari munyika. Naizvozvo zviri pachena kuti chero munhu asingabvumiri kuumbwa kwemubatanidzwa wakadaro, kunyangwe iri bato reArab pragmatic (kutinhira, iyo Likud yaitoda kujoinha) uye kuti hapana mukana wekubatana kwechitendero chekurudyi. pasina iyo, zvinoreva kuti Smutrich uye Religious Zionist Party (iyo ine zita rakanaka. Inonyatsomiririra Zionism yechitendero, yakasiyana neOrthodoxy yemazuva ano). Kubatana kwakadaro hakugoneki kubva kuZionist-chitendero chemaonero, asi zvinokwanisika kubva pakuona kwemazuva ano (uyo Zionism haisi yechitendero, uye haioni Hurumende yeIsrael semunhu wechiJudha-halakhic-wechitendero) . Dambudziko nderekuti Bennett haazive kuzvitsanangura zvese izvi, saka iye pachake ari mumhute inomukwevera zvakare uye zvakare munzvimbo dzehurukuro yakajairika. Anoedza kuzviruramisa maererano nehurukuro yenguva dzose uye haanzwisisi kuti anofanira kubudisa imwe, imwe hurukuro.

Kurwisana naBennett nezvaanomiririra

Hazvishamisi kuti kurwisana naBennett uye pamusoro pezvaanomiririra kwakwira kusvika kumatanho ehupenzi pamatanho apo angadai akaita seanokwanisa kuumba ruzhinji rwakamupoteredza uye kubuda mukutonga kwechirabhi kwe-ultra-Orthodox kupinda munzvimbo yezvematongerwo enyika. Varabhi vepamusoro-soro veOrthodox vanotungamira Zionism yechitendero uye vatauriri vavo vezvematongerwo enyika vakaziva kuti chiitiko chaBennett chinogona kudonha pasi pasi pekubudirira kukuru kweparaganda muchiJudha chemazana maviri emakore apfuura, uye kupa kutaura kune ruzhinji rwakafara rusinganyatso mira. vari shure kwavo kunyange zvazvo vachiedza kakawanda kuzvitsanangura. Hazvishamisi kuti vakatanga kushandisa propaganda imwechete uye kukurudzira pamusoro peBennett neshamwari dzake vachipikisa Orthodoxy yemazuva ano (neo-reforms, lite, leftists, anti-Israel, nheyo itsva uye European Union, vachipa Israeri kuruboshwe uye. maArabu neMuslim Brotherhood), kuitira kuti aiburutse nechisimba Kubva pamepu. Vakataura zvese zvaimupikisa, kubva paburiro nepaimba yewaini, uye vakamuratidza semutengesi mukuru munhoroondo yevanhu, nekukanganisa kwese kwaakaitwa nevamwe vavanotsigira (uye mukuona kwangu nekuda kwezvikonzero zvakanaka zvishoma. ) Zvese zvisina maturo zvake zvakaratidzwa sekutyisidzira chiJudha neZionism uye kuparadzwa kwenyika. holocaust.

Chikonzero cheichi hysterical uye kurwisa kwemusango chiri nyore. Bennett ndiyo inonyanya kutyisidzira kune yekupedzisira-Orthodox hegemony, uye nekuenderera mberi kweiyo Zionist axis semvura inoyerera munharaunda yechitendero. Mupfungwa iyi, pane kufarira kwakajairwa pano kumapato e-ultra-Orthodox uye chitendero cheZionism, sezvo ese ari maviri achidya pakukanganiswa uku kweparaganda uye nekudaro anosimudzira pamwe chete. Kana veruzhinji vakangoerekana vanzwisisa kuti vazhinji vavo havasi neizvi kana neizvi, chii chichaitika kwavari?! Kana veruzhinji vakaziva kuti vari kukweverwa kune rimwe remativi maviri asi chokwadi riri revazhinji vakanyarara vari pakati, mativi iwawo anogona kunyangarika pamepu, uye zvirokwazvo anorasikirwa nekutonga kwavo kunopfuurira paruzhinji. Hazvishamisi kuti kuratidzira kwechisimba uye chisimba, kushungurudzwa kusingaperi uye kutyisidzirwa, kusabatanidzwa kwevanhu (kukundikana kusimudza Torah musinagogi, kukundikana kushumira girazi remvura, kukundikana kukoka Prime Minister kuRabbi's Center paJerusarema Day) nezvimwe. muriwo akatanga. Yakanga yakananga kune chero nhengo yebato raBennett uyo akashinga kugara uye kuratidza kuvimbika kwaari uye nenzira yake, asi kutanga uye zvakanyanya kupikisa Bennett pachake. Akagadzira zvichemo pamusoro pake kubva kunobva uye kubva muwaini, echokwadi uye enhema. Muite iye munhu ane makaro ane huwori vanhu vanga vari pano, uye chokwadi kumashure shamwari yavo yekare Netanyahu (uyo anove ane huwori mukuru, asi hazvivanetsi). Wakanga uri muchina wekuparadzira kubva kwaGoebbels waigona kudzidza chitsauko chikuru, chinotungamirwa neakashata uye anonyepa Bibi mukubatana kweiyo yekupedzisira-Orthodox hongu, uye zvisingaite zvevaRabhi veOrthodox nevaratidziri vanotungamira Zionism yechitendero. Muchidimbu, ultra-Orthodox naBibi vachipokana naBennett. Vanhu vorudzidziso vakavhiringidzika, avo nokuda kworutivi rukurusa vasiri vavo havana kunzwisisa ikoku. Akatsauswa mukufunga kuti Bennett akanga atsauka kubva munzira uye saka akanga achitengesa Zionist yechitendero. Izvi ndezvechokwadi, nokuti akauya neimwe nzira, asi nzira iyi ndeyechokwadi uye yakakodzera. Masimba erima chete haasi kuda kutitendera kuti tibvume izvi. Chinhu chiri mupfungwa dzavo.

Pane vezvematongerwo enyika vakashingirira kukurudzirwa uku, asi kune vakaputsika. Ndakatsamwira zvikuru Idit Silman nevamwe nhubu dzakafanana naye, kunyange zvazvo akaratidzwa ne<em>ultra-Orthodox yaSmutritz uye naBibi Kafar mubhuku rinonzi Repentance. Kupokana kwake kwenhema, demagogic uye kusinganzwisisike kwakapihwa chinzvimbo chemufungo unobwinya uye ushingi hunorumbidzwa. Zvakanaka, ndinonzwisisa kuti zvakaoma chaizvo kumira wakasimba pamberi pevadzidzisi nevadzidzisi uye zviitiko zvako zvakakosha izvo iwe pachako wakakurira. Ndivo vakakutsanangurira kuti zvakakosha sei kuva muZion wechitendero, shure kwezvose ivo zvakare vakuru vevaRabhi veZionism yechitendero avo iwewo uri wavo, uye iwe ndiwe ani, Ben-Shalulit, uchasimuka? kwavari ?! Ndiani anogona kumira nokutendeseka uye kuita mhedziso mumamiriro ezvinhu anomuratidza kuti vadzidzisi vake vakashanda paari, kuti zvitendero zvaakakurira nazvo uye zvaakarwira hazvina musoro, uye kuti vatungamiriri vake vanoremekedzwa vadheemedzi vakachipa?! Kuparadzirwa kwenhema kwenguva refu kwakabereka zvibereko (muOshim), sezvo mitezo mizhinji yeOrthodoxy yazvino uno yakanga isingakwanisi kuzvisunungura pamirangariro yokuzvidukupisa uye yokuva veZioni yorudzidziso yakanga yapinzwa mavari kubvira pamavambo ouduku hwavo. Chero ani zvake asiri muzivi kana mudzidzi akachenjera kana mufungi akadzama haangagoni kuramba mashoko anoparadzirwa asingaperi anotsanangura kwaari kuti ari kutengesa nhaka yechiJudha, achiputsa halakhah nedzidziso dzechitendero cheZionist, uye remangwana regehena. Ko munhu akaita saBennett kana kuti Silman angaite sei nemashoko anotaurwa nezita reTorah naHalacha iye ari kunyika yeDauriyta neZorba yekuDurban anogara akadzidziswa kunzwa vanarabhi ndivo vanoronga kuti Torah chii. uye Halacha anoti?! Idzi ndidzo pfungwa dzawakakurira uchiyamwisa nemukaka waamai vako. MuJudhawo zvake haangagoni kuramba izvi.

Mhedziso

Mhedziso iri pachena ndeyekuti panguva ino Bennett aifanira kunge akatora vanarabhi nevanofunga, avo vanokwanisa kufunga nekugadzira imwe nzira yezvematongerwo enyika neyechitendero. Ivava vanogona kusafadzwa neparaganda uye manyepo e "chinamato-chinamato" (kureva, ultra-Orthodox neultra-Orthodox) uye vanogona kubudirira mukuzvisunungura kubva padzidzo yakaora yavakagamuchira uye pfungwa dzakapinzwa mairi. Asi akasarudza uye akagadza varatidziri, uye ava vangangotadza kumirisana nekurwiswa kwakadaro, chero bedzi vasina pfungwa, njere, halakhic uye kutsigira kwechitendero.

Kunyangwe ini ndichifungidzira kuti kunyangwe anga ari vazivi uye varabhi, kurwiswa kwe-ultra-Orthodox-Haredi kungadai kwakavapandukira, uye kunyangwe dai kwakundikana kuvaputsa, kungadai kwakaputsa ruzhinji rwevanhu vakavavhotera. Ava vanhu vakapusa vanoda kuve vechokwadi kune hunhu hwavakakura nahwo. Naizvozvo kunyangwe vakagadzwa vanofungira propaganda vaizotyora vavhoti vavo. Saka hazvina chokwadi mumaziso angu dai izvi zvakabatsirawo.

Chidzidzo chekutanga nedzidziso uye nedzidzo yemumunda. Kugadzira hurongwa hwepfungwa hunopa imwe nzira yekuparadzira-yeOthodox pamapapiro ayo maviri (ultra-Orthodox uye yechitendero-Zionist), iyo ichapa rutsigiro rwemweya uye rwehungwaru kumoyo yeruzhinji rwakapamhama iyo parizvino isingakwanise kuwana. mhinduro. Kusiyana nezvinofungwa nevanhu vakawanda, ndinofunga kuti kune uye kune ruzhinji rwevanhu, uye rwakafara zvikuru. Chikamu chakakura chevanhu ve-ultra-Orthodox uye veruzhinji vanozvitsanangura sevenyika-yechinamato, ndevepano. Asi kusvika pave nediki uye hutungamiriri hunomumiririra, haakwanise kuronga uye kuratidzwa mune zvematongerwo enyika uye munharaunda. Hakuzovi nokuzivikanwa kworudzidziso kwakadaro. Aya ndiwo maitiro esangano rechitendero, iro kunyangwe riine maonero akafanana, chero bedzi vasina hutungamiriri netsigiro yedzidziso-yedzidziso yebhaibheri, havasimuke kumusoro uye kubata mvura. Nenzira, iyi ndiyo nyaya yebhuruu-collar munharaunda ye-ultra-Orthodox, iyo vakawanda vanotenda mairi, asi inokundikana kuronga nokuti haina kuzivikanwa kana hutungamiri hwechitendero-varabhi. Zvimwe chetezvo ndezvechokwadi nezveOrthodoxy yemazuva ano, iyo nhasi isingazivi yevoruzhinji-chitendero chenyika pasinei nekusiyana kukuru kwemaonero avo. Nokudaro pfungwa yemusha uye kuvimbika kwechisikigo kweOrthodox yemazuva ano inotendeukira kuZionism yechitendero, uye mvura inoyerera inoramba iri mutsara weZionist. Panzvimbo yekuona kuti iyi ruzhinji yakanyarara yakatarisana neiyo ultra-Orthodox pole iyo inosanganisira yechitendero Zionism uye yekupedzisira-Orthodox, isu tinoenderera mberi nezuro kurwisana pakati peZionists echitendero uye ultra-Orthodox.

Pfungwa huru apo zvakakosha kutanga ihondo ye conservatism. Conservatism ndicho chishandiso chikuru chinoshandiswa ne Ultra-Orthodox propaganda. Tave tajaira kune imwe mhando yechitendero, uye yakadzika midzi matiri zvekuti hatigone kubuda mazviri zvechokwadi. Kunyange kana tisisadaviri mazviri, hatigoni kuzvitaura pachedu nokutendeseka uye nenzwi guru. Chitendero chinenge chirevo che conservatism, uye zvakaoma zvikuru kuzvisiya. Kuti tisununguke kubva mukubatwa kunoparadza kweva-ultra-Orthodox vezvematongerwo enyika uye varabhi paZionism yechitendero, munhu anofanira kutanga uye kunyanya kubvisa kuzvipira kune zvatakadzidziswa. Hakusi pasina kuti pane chinangwa chedzidzo kutaura kuti ndiri wechitendero nokuti ndiwo madzidzisiro andakaita. Kwandiri, chirevo chakakomba uye chakamonyaniswa. Chirevo chakarurama ndeichi: Ini ndinonamata nokuti ndinotenda machiri, kunyange zvazvo ndakadzidziswa nenzira iyoyo. Conservatism inotsvenesa chitendero chechinyakare nekuti ndiwo madzidzisirwo atakaitwa ndiwo anochengetedza mhando, maonero, nehutungamiriri hwatakajaira. Anoda kutanga apfurwa.

Kudzokera kuna Daniel Sagron: Kudzima Dash

Chaive chinyorwa chaSagron chiri pamusoro chakandikurudzira kunyora iyi koramu. Pane kumwe kukundikana uye mamwe mapoinzi chaiwo mumashoko ake. Ndinobvumirana nekuongorora kwake kuti mudzi wechiitiko chaBennett ndiko kubviswa kwe hyphen (mukuona kwake: hyphen), kureva, nzvimbo yeZionism kwete pachitendero. Bennett anomiririra boka riri Zionist uye rinonamata, asi hapana hyphen pakati pezviviri. Asi inobata neaxis yeZionism. Izvi zvine chekuita sei nekutaura kwangu nezve Orthodoxy yemazuva ano? Izvo zvinondidzosa kuchikamu 477. Mune chinyorwa imomo ndakakakavadzana kuti Zionism yechitendero ine dash isiri yemazuva ano yeOrthodoxy, nepo chitendero cheZionism chisina dash chiri chiitiko chemazuva ano cheOrthodox.

Chitendero cheZionism chinoisa Zionism yayo pane intra-Torah tsika. Kukunda uye kugadziriswa kwenyika ndiyo tsika dzeTorah, uye iyi ndiyo chete hwaro hweZionism. Mupfungwa iyi hapana conservative midrash pano yakavakirwa pahunhu hwekunze asi dudziro (inonzwisisika) yeTorah uye halakhic masosi. Kune rumwe rutivi, Zionism yechitendero isina dash inotsigira Ben-Gurion's Zionism, kureva, tsika, kuzivikanwa uye zvido zvenyika, kwete chete nokuti yakanyorwa muTorah (kunyange izvi zviri zvechokwadi), asiwo nokuti vanhu vechiJudha kodzero yekubatana neChitubu cheMarudzi uye kuzvimisira nyika. Naizvozvo haana dambudziko rekugadzira mubatanidzwa neZionism yenyika, uye haazvione se'dhongi raMesiasi'. Izvi ndizvo chaizvo zviri kuitika mumatongerwo enyika yedu nhasi panyaya yemubatanidzwa.

Kwandiri, semunhu ane chigaro chakadaro, Zionism inomira pamwe chete nekutenda uye kuzvipira kwechitendero uye halakhic asi hazvibvi pazviri. Handioni munyika kuzadzika kwechiratidzo chevaporofita (nekuti handizivi kana zvakadaro), asi chiitiko chakakomborerwa pachacho, chisina chekuita nerudzikinuro nekuchengeta. Iyi haisi Aqaba Dhamasiko uye kwete kutanga kweDegula, asi ingori nyika yandinoda kugara mairi uye kuti ndine kodzero yekudaro. Naizvozvo, iniwo handitarisire zvakanyanya pamusoro pemabatiro aanoita mune zvechitendero, uye chero zvakadaro handina chero chinhu chikuru chinoodza mwoyo kubva kwaari. Ndakatsanangura ipapo kuti kubata kwakadaro ipfungwa yeOrthodoxy yemazuva ano, sezvo inotora kukosha kwekunze (nyika), kwete hazvo nekuti inotangira muTorah kana Vachenjeri asi nenyaya yekuti ndinozviratidza nayo (uye kunyangwe zvakajeka uye kupesvedzerwa pachena nemhoteredzo yandinogara). Kwandiri seOrthodox yemazuva ano izvi zvakakwana kuti ndifungisise maitiro angu anoshanda uye kunyange echitendero.

Mumakore ekumaXNUMX, kwaiva neboka revatapi venhau vaibva kunze kwenyika vakaita ongororo pakati pevakangwara pamubvunzo wekuti sei vaive maZion. Isaya Leibowitz akati kwavari: Nokuti takadyiswa navaGoyimu (tiri maZion nokuti takadyiswa navaHedheni). Rabhi wekuPonivez aive nemaonero akafanana. Aigaroti muZion saBen-Gurion, haatauriwo kurumbidza kana kukumbira pazuva rerusununguko. Kupfuura joke, sezvandinonzwisisa pane pfungwa inokosha pano: rabhi kubva kuPonivez akanga ari Zionist yenyika, asi haana kuzviona senyaya yechitendero. Maonero akadaro ari kurovera pakeke mumaziso e-ultra-Orthodox (vadzidzi vake yeshiva vakaedza kakawanda kudzikisa mureza waaishandisa padenga reIndependence Day. Izvi ndizvo zvakaitwa nemutori wenhau wekupedzisira Dov Ganchovsky, uyo akanga agere pedyo. kwaari, akandiudza) nemaZioni echitendero. Izvi neavo havasi kuda kuziva hunhu kunze kweTorah. I-ultra-Orthodox inoona Zionism sesangano rinokurudzira hunhu hwekunze uye nokudaro vanochiramba, uye veZion vechitendero vanozviona sesangano rinosimudzira tsika dzechitendero. Asi ava neavo havadi kubvuma pfungwa yemazuva ano-yechinyakare iyo inoda kusimudzira tsika kunze kweTorah. Tsika dzemazuva ano.

Nenzira, nekuda kwekukundikana uku, vanhu vashomanana muchitendero cheZionist vanhu vasina dash, avo vanonyatsoda kutaura kuti vanotsigira Orthodoxy yemazuva ano, vanotaura muhurukuro yakajairika uye vanoedza kutsanangura kuti tsika dzavo dzakatorwa kubva Torah. Iyi ndiyo nzira iyo marudzi ose evanhu 'vakavhenekerwa' kubva kune vechitendero kuruboshwe vanotitsanangurira kuti democracy kukosha kweTorah, kuenzana, kubata kweumwe, feminism, kubata kwevahedheni, rugare, zvose izvi ndizvo zvinokosha zve Tora. Zvakanaka, hazvinyatso kugutsa (zvikuru zvemaropafadzo manomwe). Zvakaoma kuti veruzhinji vabvume, uye nemazvo, kuti nekuda kwechimwe chikonzero uye mune yakanyanyisa nyaya izvo zvaunotenda mazviri ndizvo zvaunowana muTorah (kusiyana nevamwe vese vasingazviwane imomo). Zviri pachena kumunhu wese kuti hunhu uhwu hahubvi muTorah, asi hunhu hwekunze hunopirwa neboka iri. Saka nei iyi hurukuro yechienzi? Ko nyonganiso yacho inobva kupi? Wadii kuzvitaura nokutendeseka? Zvinoitika kuti ivo, zvakare, vakaisa nekusaziva mukati kufungidzira kwevanopikisa kubva kumapapiro maviri (ultra-Orthodox uye maZionists echitendero), kuti zvese zvinofanirwa kutanga uye kupera neTorah. Ndizvo zvandakataura, kana pasina kufunga uye kurongeka kwezvidzidzo zvebhaibheri uye halakhic mishnah inosimbisa nyaya, kuvhiringidzika kwemafungiro kunogadzirwa kunozopedzisira kwatungamirira kukukundikana kwezvematongerwe enyika zvakare.

Sagron anoona kudonha kwaBennett sehumbowo hwekuti haana veruzhinji. Kuti Zionism isina hwaro hwechitendero haigari uye naizvozvo haipo chaizvoizvo. Asi mashoko ake ndeeruzhinji rumwechete rusina. Veruzhinji ndivo vakaunza Bennett pachigaro uye vakaita kuti abudirire. Mukupesana, kutozosvikira Bennett yechitendero Zionism yakanga iri mukuderera kwezvematongerwe enyika kunopfuurira uye iye ndiye akamubudisa mazviri, zvishoma kwechinguvana. Saka hachisi chokwadi kuti hakuna vanhu vakadaro. Kusiyana neizvi, mhedziso ndeyekuti kune ruzhinji rwakadai, uye rwakatokura kupfuura zvaungafungidzira. Asi haabudiriri uye haakwanisi kubudirira mune zvematongerwo enyika, nokuti pasina nyaya yakarongeka haakwanisi kumirisana nekutendeseka kudzvinyirirwa kwaakaitwa kubva kumativi ose. Avo vakamudzidzisa uye vakamutungamirira uye vakamujairira kuti vanotakura shoko raMwari munyika uye kuti hapana kunze kweTorah uye kuti Torah ndivo ivo, havamubvumidzi kuona kuti iyi dzidzo inhema ine simba. iyo iri munheyo dzayo. Munhu akadaro haakwanise kumira achipikisa muchina wekuparadzira wandakatsanangura, icho chinyorwa chaDaniel Sagron chikamu (uyewo chigadzirwa chayo).

Nezvekuparadzaniswa kwakatsanangurwa naDaniel Sagron, ndinobvumirana zvachose. Kunyange zvazvo kuri kuwedzeredza zvachose kutaura kuti akanga asina kufanana naye. Kuparara kwezvematongerwo enyika kwevanhu vechitendero chenyika inzira inotyisa yave ichiitika kwenguva yakareba, uye Bennett aitove kutsauka kwechinguva kubva pazviri. Kuparara uku hakusi nekuda kwaBennett asi zvisinei naBennett. Uyo anokonzera ndiye ari munhandare kare uye shure kwaBennett, kureva, hutungamiri hweOrthodox hweZionism yechitendero (Sagron's vashandi). Ichokwadi kuti kune kurasikirwa kwenzira pano, uye mukuona kwangu uku kudzokororwa kwekutaura kwekuti hutungamiri hweZionist-hunamato hune simba rayo guru mukuparadzwa nekuparara. Anoparadza uye anoomerera pakodzero yake yekuramba achiparadza uye anorwa nemunhu wese anoedza kugadzirisa. Ndosaka hurongwa uhu hwave huchienderera mberi kwemakore akati wandei, kare Bennett asati.

Kwemakore akawanda, kumiririrwa kwechitendero cheZionism muKnesset kwave kusina kuenzana nevavhoti vayo, sezvo mhomho yevavhoti ichienda kune mamwe mapato (izvi hazvisi hazvo zvakaipa. Neniwo). Chiitiko chipi nechipi chinobudirira mukugadzira imwe nzira yekuparara iyo hutungamiri uhu pachahwo hune mhosva, ndiko kuti, huchaunganidza vamwe vevavhoti ava mumakumbo ebato rechitendero kana rechinyakare uye renyika, richaiswa muna Baba nemuchina we. kuparadza uye propaganda iyo pachayo inoshanda. Zvinoshamisa uye hazvina kuvimbika mumaziso angu kupa mhosva uyo akauya kuzogadzira kuparadza kwauri kukonzera, uye kuti iwe pachako unopfuurira muhondo yako pamusoro payo.

Mhedziso yaSagron ndeyokuti hyphen theory yemunyori inofanira kuvigwa zvakadzika. Ndinobvumirana zvachose, asi kwete mupfungwa yake. Anopa zano seimwe dzidziso umo mune chinamato chete, uye kusarudzika (nemazuva ano) ndizvo zvakanyanya kubva pazviri. Nepo ini ndichipokana kuti vaviri ava vanofanira kuramba vari padivi nepadivi, uye zvechokwadi hapafanirwe kunge paine hyphen inovabatanidza. Uyezve, mhedziso yake inondishamisa, nokuti kana achida kutaura kuti dashi rinofanira kuvigwa mune zvematongerwo enyika nokuti haana zvaanoda ruzhinji, saka pano avigwa. Asi sezvandakatsanangura zvematongerwo enyika makore achangopfuura taura kuti zvine veruzhinji. Kana aireva kuti ruzhinji urwu runofanira kusiya hyphen (kureva kusiya nyika yezvidzidzo zvebhaibheri uko kune Torah chete), ndinofunga kuti mhedziso inopesana: kune ruzhinji rwevanhu rwakadai, uye kupatsanurwa kwezvidzidzo zvebhaibheri kunofanira kugadzirwa tsigira. Zvavanoita nhasi kumuviga muguva. Kuparara kwebato rinomumiririra pasina pundutso hakurevi kuti hyphen inofanira kuvigwa (mupfungwa yaro) asi kuti inofanira kupihwa kutaura kwechokwadi uye kwakagadzikana mune zvematongerwo enyika. Kana zvakadaro, saka tinofanira kuviga muchina wekuparadzira uyo Sagron pachake anogovera.

Chimwe chinhu pamusoro pemapato ezvitendero

Ndakanyora kakawanda kuti handioni kukosha kukuru mukuvapo kwemapato ezvitendero. Kwandiri vanondikuvadza zvakanyanya kupfuura kunaka, uye rinenge rega rega revhoti yavo inopesana nemaonero angu (anowanikwa zvakanyanya kukurudzira kumanikidza). Mashoko angu pano akanyorwa nekuti nyaya dzezvematongerwo enyika dziri kufamba nemapato aya dzinoratidza maitiro akakosha kutariswa.

Kutaura kwangu pano hakuna kuitirwa kuponesa kumiririrwa kwezvematongerwe enyika kwevoruzhinji vorudzidziso namapato ezvitendero, sezvo ikoku kwose kusina ukoshi huduku mumeso angu. Matauriro angu anoitirwa kutsanangura kuti nei zvakakosha kuvaka hutungamiriri uye dzidziso yebhaibheri uye halakhic mishnah iyo ichapa hwaro hwekufungidzira pamwe nemagariro (uye pamwe nezvematongerwo enyika) kutaura kune chikamu chakakosha cheruzhinji rwechitendero nhasi icho chimumumu uye chinyararire ( pamhosva yayo pachayo). Zvakakodzera kugumisa nokunongedzera mhosva munzira yakarurama. Avo vane mhosva havasi vanarabhi. Ndinofungidzira vazhinji vavo vacheche vakabatwa mukati memaonero ekuti ivo pachavo vari kumudzidzisa nekumudzidzisa. Vanenge vachinyatsotenda muzvinhu zvavo zvisina maturo. Mhosva iri patiri. Chero bedzi tichiramba tiri mapenzi uye tichinyengerwa nemashoko anoparadzirwa atakakurira uye tichizviisa pasi pawo, isu pachedu tichava nemhosva yemichero inonyadzisa yainokura. Ngatisauye nezvichemo asi kwatiri isu.

[1] Kunyange zvazvo ichi chisiri chiDaism chaicho, sezvo ari Mwari anoda uye anorayira.

126 Pfungwa pamusoro pe "Kusimuka nekudonha kwaBennett uye Zvazvinoreva (Koramu 486)"

  1. Handina kunzwisisa. Rabbi Yoel haasi anochengetedza (kunyangwe achiuya sekunge ese maitiro ake anobva muTorah). Kupfuura izvozvo, muenzaniso pano kana pano hazvina basa kana zvasvika pamufananidzo wakazara.

  2. Haufungi here kuti koramu iyi inguva yemazuva ano? Ndiko kuti, nharo yako ndeyokuti varabhi vanoda chaizvo kuchengetedza hegemony uye simba ravo uye ndicho chikonzero ivo vakagadzira mhirizhonga yekupikisa Bennett. Pane imwe nharo yekurangana inofuratira kupomerwa kwaBennett.

    1. Postmodernism haifungi dzidziso yesimba. Ndezveneo-Marxism kana vanofambira mberi. Postmodernism iri padyo neiyo post-structuralism iyo Ramad anoda zvakanyanya. Kuti hapana nzira yekusvika pachokwadi uye kuti zvese ndizvo zvinovaka. Asi kwete kugadzira kudzora mumwe.

    2. Zvechokwadi, imwe yerabhi's hallucinatory columns. Ese kurangana kwevanarabhi, kwete zvachose chitsotsi chikuru munhoroondo yezvematongerwo enyika yeIsrael nemukaha, kuparadza pfungwa yekutanga yedemocracy uye chidimbu chenjodzi megalomaniacs. Emoji inobata musoro wako!

  3. Ndakanyora kuti pamwe vanotenda chaizvo muhupenzi hwavo. Asi simba reparaganda uye kuparadza uye upenzi hwaro uye kusapindirana zvinonyatsoratidza kurangana kwemaune uye nemaune. Uye kunyangwe dai zvaisaziva, ivo vaifanira kuzvinzwisisa nekuzvimisa.
    Kazhinji, Marxism inoturika zvese mukurangana pane kubata nemakakatanwa ekumiririra. Asi paunobata nemakakatanwa woona kuti haatombobvumirwi kuvanzwa pano, pane vavariro dzakavanzwa.

      1. Iniwo handina chido chekuita izvozvo. Iyi haisiyo nyaya yekoramu. Nenzira, izvi hazvisi zvichemo zveruzhinji-bapiro revanhu asi Bibi-Smutritz uyo nokuda kwechimwe chikonzero anoshandura kubiridzira kurudyi (kurudyi = pro Bibi) uye anopomera vamwe (zvimwe zvakakodzera) kubiridzira.
        Mumiganhu ini ndichawedzera kuti "kuora mwoyo" kukuru kwevavhoti vake verudyi kubva kwaari, izvo zvaunotora zvishoma, kune chimwe chikonzero chisingaonekwi mumavhoti. Inowanikwa zvakanyanya mukunyepedzera kwenhema kwaBibi-Smutritz, mubatanidzwa we-ultra-Orthodox-huori. Ani nani asingadi sungano isina kuchena mukombe wangu wetii.
        Kunyangwe vatsigiri vemubatanidzwa uyu vangadai vakatarisira kunzwisisa kudiki kwekuverenga. Asi sezviri pachena idzo dzakanga dziri tarisiro dzakawedzerwa.

        1. Kudzai, makarasika.

          Pashure pechiito chokubiridzira (uye noruremekedzo rwose rwakakodzera, hapana Bibi, chitsotsi kana kuti kwete, anogona kudzidzisa kunyangira uku ari ega) pakava nesarudzo dzakadzokororwa, kusanganisira idzo dzakaitwa mukati me'Yimina' (zvichida rabhi anofanirawo kuraira Bennett kuti asa ita chikanganiso chepfungwa pane iyi nhanho, kudaidza bato Yamina, kana Pamwe pachinzvimbo cheRabhi achagutsikana nemutsara wakajeka wekutasva nhema dziri pachena) izvo zvakaratidza kuti zvikamu zviviri muzvitatu zvevanhu vakamusarudza vakaodzwa mwoyo uye. vakashamiswa nehurumende yakaumbwa.

          Hazvifanirwe kuvhiringika kuti Bennett akazvipawo mamwe mabasa, zvichiratidza ruzhinji rwakaona izvi sedanho rekubatana, ruzhinji rwunosangana netsanangudzo yarabhi. Ona nhamba yezvibvumirano mumavhoti pakarepo mushure mekuumbwa kwehurumende, apo mufananidzo wemabhuraki wakaramba wakagadzikana, uchienzaniswa nesarudzo dzakaongorora mafambiro pachayo.

          Nezve kusakwanisa kubata aya ma mandate - ndinofunga unogadzirisa basa raBennett uye mhosva.

          Aive mutungamiriri wehurumende asipo, akapunzika aita zvekubira nevanopfurikidza mwero muhurumende yake, uye kazhinji aiita seshizha rinopeperetswa nemhepo kumauto akasiyana siyana, hapana dambudziko rakabatwa mumaoko ake, Corona haina kubatwa nayo. , akazviwana achiita nhaurirano pakati peRussia neUkraine apo akanga asina A real strategy, akavharirwa mukati mehurumende isingakwanisi kupfuudza mitemo inokosha yakadai semutemo wevagari vemo, zvose izvi mushure mekutaura pamusoro pehurumende '10 madhigirii kurudyi. ', isingakwanise kutonga hurumende yakadzora uye yakawiriraniswa apo gurukota rezvekudzivirirwa kwenyika rinonyatso tungamira mutsara wezvematongerwo enyika unoyambuka chengetedzo pamberi penzvimbo dzekugara, uchivarova kakawanda Musika pahudyu yako, uye maitiro ezvematongerwo enyika akabudirira ega ayo anoshongedza. Abu Mazen nemarudzi ese evamwe vanhu vane simba, uku mhirizhonga ichiita senge nyaya yakava karenda uku kutinhira kuchishanduka kuita hove dzinyerere...

          Saka ndeipi party yauri kutaura nezvayo chaizvo???

          Muchidimbu, isu tinogona kuwedzera mberi nezvakawanda, asi chii chakanyatsoitika pano ndechekuti hurumende yaBennett yakaparadza chiroto chacho pachayo, kwete chete mishandirapamwe iri pachena yerumwe rutivi (iwe unogona kufunga kuti vanopikisa vanoedza kupidigura hurumende chinhu chitsva. , mubatanidzwa une ngozi chaizvo...).

          Mune fungidziro yangu, iwe uri muchikamu cheuzivi hwemhepo dzakasiyana-siyana, uye wakakanganisa zvakanyanya pamusoro pezvakakonzera kusimuka nekudonha kwaBennett.

          Maonero angu pachangu - takakomborerwa kuti takasunungurwa kubva muchirango ichi, uye tinofanira kushuva kuti dai patomuka bato raizowira pasi petsanangudzo dzarabhi.

          1. Ndagara ndichifarira sarudzo. Asi nekuda kwechimwe chikonzero, kunyangwe nekuodzwa mwoyo kukuru, rutsigiro rwaBennett rwakangowedzera nekufamba kwenguva. Uku ndiko kungoenderera mberi kwenhema dzeBibists. Zviri nyore kupindura vhoti yandakavhotera Bennett uye ndakaodzwa mwoyo. Nokuda kwechimwe chikonzero handisati ndambosangana nevanhu vakaodzwa mwoyo naBennett, asi chokwadi ichi hachisi hacho mumiririri wemuenzaniso. Sarudzo hadzisi dzakaipa sampuli, uye ivo zvechokwadi vanotaura zvakapesana nezvaunotaura. Mushure mekunge Bennett asiya basa mamiriro akachinja hongu, asi inguva yenguva pfupi.
            Tsanangudzo yangu yezvematongerwo enyika inogona kukakavara, asi ndinofunga kuti ndeyechokwadi.

            1. Sezvineiwo, ari kukanganisa kana kusaziva zvakabuda musarudzo.

              Tarisa kumashure muakaundi ino, uchiisa pakati pemibairo munzira -
              https://twitter.com/IsraelPolls

              Rutsigiro rwaBennett zvirokwazvo haruna kuwedzera, pano neapo pakanga paine kusvetuka uye zvakare kudonha semugumisiro wemamiriro ezvinhu kumashure, asi zvachose ndakanga ndakagadzikana kumativi e6-8 mandates paavhareji (Yamina akapedza ne7 sezvakataurwa) .

              Mhedzisiro inomira, uye isarudzo yemunhu wese kuti ungayananisa sei chokwadi ichi (tichifunga kuti unobvuma sarudzo sechishandiso. Handioni kuti zvirevo pamusoro pekuwedzera kwerutsigiro, uye nhema dzebibists dzinobva pane zvakaonekwa pachivande, zvirevo zvemhando yepamusoro. kupfuura muunganidzwa wesarudzo).

              zvakare,

              1. Pamubvunzo wekuumbwa kwehurumende, musarudzo dzakaitwa zuva remutongo risati rasvika uye rapfuura, vangangosvika zvikamu zviviri muzvitatu zvevavhoti vaBennett vakati vaodzwa mwoyo nedanho iri ( pane vamwe vakatiwo vakavhota dai vaiziva)
              2. Nhamba yezvibvumirano inoramba yakagadzikana, Grosso akabvuma, uye sarudzo dzakawanda dzinobvumirana

              Unogadzirisa sei?
              Zvinogoneka kutanga kubva mukududzira kwarabhi kwenharaunda isina imwe imba, kusvika pakutsinhana kwerutsigiro kubva kune imwe nharaunda, kuburikidza nemaBentist, uye kusvika kuRabhi.

              Ini handisi kuona kuti manyepo evabists anogona kubvisa chokwadi ichi.

              Mune imwe dudziro uye mune yakanakisa nyaya kodzero (kusvikira pamudyandigere Bennett, iyo inotaura chimwe chinhu pamusoro peBentists) yakaramba ichiwedzera kana zvishoma pasimba rayo, uye mune imwe nyaya pakanga paine * yekusingaperi * kufamba pakati pemabhuroka akatanga muna 62 'yekuchinja' uye 51 'yeNetanyahu bloc' uye ikozvino (uye mamwe mazuva achataura) inomira pa55 uye makumi matanhatu zvakateerana.

              Imwe yetsanangudzo dzandinofunga kuti ndiyo inonyanya kuitika ndeyekuti vatsigiri vaBennett vakadzokera kune rimwe divi, uye akachengetedza simba rake mukufamba mukati me "shanduko" bloc. Sei? Nekuti Zionism yakakwira nekudzika munzira yese, uye ndizvo zvakaitawo Likud, saka sei uchifunga kuti ava ndivo vavhoti veNew Hope, kana Lieberman, kana Labor kana Mertz?

              Handioni kuti dudziro iyi inoshanda sei. Tine urombo, izvo zvinonzwika sekufunga kweshuviro, pane chinzvimbo chinopindirana nechokwadi.

  4. Ku RMD-
    A. Ndinofunga Ido Pechter anotaura zvakajeka sewe. Zvimwe unofanira kumukumbanira moumba bato rezvematongerwe enyika
    B. Izvi zvishoma, asi ndinofunga kana vanhu vakaita saDaniel Sagron vachiti kusarudzika kunobva muTorah, havareve kuti inoshandisa mirairo yeTorah, asi maitiro eTorah. Uye maitiro aya akanyorwa kupi? Hazvina kunyorwa asi vanofungidzira kuti kuda kwae, sekukudzwa kwake. Musiyano uripo pakati pako uri mukuziva kuti haina kunyorwa muTorah (iwe unoziva uye ishoma), uye muhunhu hwaunofunga kuti unoda (rusununguko kurwisa kumanikidza, nezvimwewo)
    Kana maiziva kubva kumazuva edzidziso dzenyu (kana makambova nemazuva akadaro) ndima semuzviedza zverumuko, nezvehutsvene hunopesana hwenyika nehwepasi rose uye nehutsvene hwakazara hunosanganisira zvose, zvakafanana. idea kune yenyu.
    chetatu. Zvinozivikanwa kuti Zionism yechitendero inoumbwa nevadzidzi vaRabbi Kook uye vadzidzi veGush nezvimwe zvakadaro, uye kuti mumiriri wezvematongerwo enyika mumakore achangopfuura akarerekera kuvadzidzi vaRabbi Kook. Asi zvinoratidzika kwandiri kuti Pedal yekare yaive yerudzi rwechizvinozvino cheTorah uye inoshanda zvakafanana.
    Cheers - Rabbi Yoel Ben-Nun haasi kunyatsochengetedza mumaziso angu

    1. A. Ndinofunga isu tine maitiro akasiyana kunyangwe akafanana. Ini handifarire kuwanikwa uye kushamwaridzana kweTorah neHalacha. Icho hachisi chinangwa changu, uye kwandiri ivavariro isina kururama. Zvisinei, ndakatora dzidziso pachangu. Zvematongerwo enyika zvichasara kune vamwe.
      B. Huat iyo yandanyora zvese mumakoramu nepano.
      chetatu. Iyo yekare NRP yaingova yeOrientalists isina dzidziso chaiyo, uye nemanzwiro mazhinji ari pasi peiyo yekupedzisira-Orthodox (uye zvechokwadi Sally hutungamiriri hwake hwechirabhi).

      1. A. Zvinoratidzika pachiso chayo kuti nzira yaRabbi Pechter (kuwedzera kune maitiro) ndeyechokwadi inopesana. Ndichitevera makoramu eOrthodoxy yemazuva ano ndakatanga kuverenga bhuku raRabhi Pechter rakataurwa ipapo (Judaism on the Sequence) uye ipapo pakupera kwesumo anonyora:
        Muchinyorwa ichi ndichaedza kuratidza kuti kudzikira kwekudzika kwekuziva kweHalacha, muzvinyorwa zvayo zvekare - yakanyorwa Torah, Mishnah neTalmud, inoratidza kuti izvo zvinoonekwa nesu nhasi sekuziva kwemazuva ano ndicho chekutanga. nheyo dzeHalacha. Naizvozvo hapana chikonzero chekuvandudza kana kugadzira chero chinhu chiri mairi kuti chiyananise nekuziva kwemazuva ano. Chinodiwa kwatiri kungosvika nekuburitsa nzira dzakakodzera kwatiri dzirimo. Nokudaro tichavakira ruzivo rwemazuva ano halakhic panheyo dze halakhah pachayo, uye chengetedza kuenderera kwayo, uye nokudaro ticharatidza kuti ruzivo rwe halakhic ikozvino rwunogamuchirwa mumatunhu akawanda eOrthodoxy haisi iyo nzira yekutanga ye halakhah asi kukanganisa kwayo. Mazuva ano haasi muvengi we halakhah asi shamwari yake yepamoyo. Nepo avo vanopokana nemazuva ano muzita re halakhah, avo vanoibvisa kubva kuhupenyu chaihwo uye nenyika yazvino, vavengi vayo vakuru. "
        Kana kubva mundima iri pamusoro apa zvichikwanisika kunzwisisa mune zvakajairika nzira yaPechter (ini handisati ndaverenga zvakakwana kuti ndinzwisise nzira yake uye kuda uye kushandisa kwake izwi remazuva ano) zvino zvinonzwisisika kuti ndicho chinhu chekutsoropodza kwekoramu mu. mubvunzo.

  5. post Scriptum. Kutsoropodza kusarudzwa kwaMukuru Rabhi kunoenderana nekuti munhu anomuona sei. Kana ukamutarisa semukuru mukuru wezvechitendero munyika, hazvisi zvekunyomba kuti maonero ake akaita sei kunyika. Asi kana ukamuona somumwe munhu anofanirwa kutungamirira Nyika yeIsrael kubva kudivi rechitendero, zvinoshamisa kugadza munhu anopikisa hurumende nokuda kwechinzvimbo chakadaro.
    Chikonzero nei iyo rabhi inodaidzwa kuti Orthodoxy yemazuva ano (iyo isiri iyo United States) isingaite sangano rezvematongerwo enyika uye repfungwa imhaka yekuti vazhinji vevanhu varabhi vanodana kuti dhinominator vakango pusa. Ndoziva uchati ingori conservative demagoguery, asi nyatso tarisa veruzhinji vauri kutaura nezvavo. Idzi ndidzo nguva zhinji vanhu vasingatarisi zviri nyore uye zvakakomba (zvechokwadi haasi munhu wese akadaro) uye mutemo hausi pamberi pepfungwa dzavo. Zvichida rabhi achawana zvaari kutsvaga muruzhinji rweOrthodox, zvingave kuti kune vanhu vakakomba uye vakasununguka ipapo (ndinotaura izvi sekufungidzira, ini handizivi zvakakwana).

  6. Kugadziriswa kwekusiiwa mukufambiswa kwemashoko aIsaya Leibowitz (uye chimwe chinhu pamusoro peBennett uye 'Dash')

    Mu S.D.

    Mwari anorambidza Leibowitz anoti 'taneta nevaHedheni', unogona kuwana 'chero chiyero chinonyadzisa' maari, asi saSnoopov akanga asina. Zvakataurwa naLeibowitz ndezvekuti, "We're Pad Up From Bying Rold Bay Gentiles," akadaro muChirungu uye akaturikira muchiHebheru: "Taneta nekutongwa nevaHedeni."

    Uye kana ari Bennett. Bennett naSmutrich idivi rimwe remari imwe chete. Misimboti miviri inotungamira vese: a. Taneta (= chitendero cheZionism) nekutungamirirwa nevenyika. Zionism yechitendero inofanira kutungamira nyika. B. Ndini mutungamiri mutungamiri akakodzera kutungamira nyika, ndini mutungamiriri achadaidza 'mushure mangu' uye kutungamira munhu wese.

    Kune rimwe divi, ini (HM) ndinofarira iyo yekare 'Mizrahnik' pfungwa, iyo yakataurwa zvinoyevedza naDr. Yosef Burg. Hatifaniri 'kumira kumusoro' uye kuva 'mutungamiriri'. Isu takakomborerwa kuve 'dash' yemunyori, isu tichasimbiswa muTorah uye isu tichabatanidzwawo mukuita uye nekudaro tichagadzira kubatana. Tichaedza kuunza nyika yeTorah pedyo nechiito cheZionist, uye isu tichaedza kuunza avo vari kure pedyo uye kusimbisa kubatana kwavo kune nhaka yavo, uye yekare 'Kima' Kimaa ichavandudzwa uye itsva ichatsveneswa.

    Ani naani anoda kuva mutungamiriri wenyika, anofanira kugara achiongorora ne‘vateveri’ vanoda hutungamiriri hwake, uye angasvika pakuora mwoyo kunorwadza paanoziva kuti ndi‘mambo asina vanhu’

    Kune rumwe rutivi, avo vanofamba nemoyo murefu - vanozviwana ivo nedenderedzwa ravo mumaonero emakumi emakore sekuwedzera uye kuwedzera simba. Zvakakwana kuona kuti akasimbisa sei muhuwandu uye hutano hwenyika yeTorah. Kunyange muvanhu venyika mune fariro inowedzera munhaka netsika. Vanhu vangani vechitendero nhasi vari munzvimbo dzakakosha mune zvekuchengetedza nezvematongerwo enyika, zvehupfumi nesainzi, mutemo nedzidzo.

    Kukundikana kwaBennett kwaive mukuedza kwake kubata kumiririrwa kwezvematongerwo enyika kweruzhinji rwechitendero chenyika iyo inoona kukosha mukusimudzira dzidzo yechitendero uye masangano eTorah uye kuzivikanwa kwechiJudha kwenyika. Iri ndiro rakasarudzika zano risina rimwe bato richatarisira. Zvingave zviri nani kwaari kuti abatane neLikud uye akwire kumusoro asina kumaka zera rake pazera re30 semukuru wenyika. Zvichida Bennett aifanira kunge akatungamira Likud uye nyika mushure meNetanyahu, 'asi akadya Pega' 🙂

    Muchidimbu: kutungamira rudzi uye kunyanya rudzi rwemaJuda ane pfungwa - zvinoda kugona kubatana neruzhinji neruzhinji kuitira kuti pave nekubvumirana kwakakura sezvinobvira. Zvichida Ayelet Shaked, uyo akazozvisunungura kubva kunzira ine simba yaBennett, achabudirira mukusimudzira zvinhu kubva pakubatana kwakafara.

    Regards, Yekutiel Shneur Zehavi

    1. Kudzoreredza 'kwekodzero' kuchabvumira dzimba mbiri dzezvematongerwo enyika kune miviri miviri yevanhu vechitendero chenyika

      Kudzoreredzwa kwe "kurudyi" kunotungamirwa naAyelet Shaked kuchabvumira kugarisana kwedzimba mbiri dzezvematongerwo enyika, mumumvuri wese weruzhinji-chinamato. Veruzhinji veTorah vachawana nzvimbo yavo muSmutritz's 'Zionism yechitendero' (pamwe ne'simba rechiJudha', 'Noam' uye Ultra-Orthodox), nepo vezvitendero, zvechinyakare uye-mapiro-bapiro echitendero vachawana nzvimbo yavo mune yakavandudzwa 'kurudyi'.

      Kana Ayelet Shaked akakunda marara ekare uye akadzosa Amichai Shikli zvakare, uye anokwezva iyo 'Jewish House' kwairi - pane mukana wakanaka wekuti mapato maviri anotevera achabudirira. Zvingadai zvakashuvira kuti bapiro rerudyi rive census uye kugadzira hutungamiriri hwakasarudzwa hunounza kugadzikana uye kuvimba neveruzhinji.

      Chokwadi, Yaknaz

      1. Kune avo vanopikisa zvakasimba kuna Benjamin Netanyahu uye / kana kune hegemony yeMukuru Rabbinate - kune nzvimbo mu "Yesh Atid", "Blue and White", "New Hope", nezvimwewo. Asi ivo vanofanirwa kufunga kuti hutongi hweBiden huchamanikidza zvakanyanya kuti vaende kunyika yePalestine. Saka vanofanira kubvunza kuti chii chiri nani? Kubviswa kwaBhibhi naMukuru Rabhi, kana kudzivirira kugadzwa kwechinotyisa mumwoyo wenyika yedu?

        Chokwadi, Yaknaz

          1. Chokwadi, mazwi aOfir Sofer naYariv Levin akaburitswa nhasi (paChannel 7 webhusaiti), vasingavimbi nekuvimbika kwekudzoka kwaAyelet Shaked kuGush Hayamim uye vanofungidzira kuti achaenderera mberi nenzira yaBennett uye kubatana nekuruboshwe uye maArabu. Zvinoita sekuti pamwe ramangwana richatijekesera kana paine zvechokwadi 'kuvhurwa kwepeji idzva' pano

            Chokwadi, Yaknaz

            Uye pamwe kana zvinhu zvisina kujeka, zviri nani kune vanhu vane mwero, yechinyakare uye yekurudyi vechitendero kuti 'vaende zvechokwadi' uye vawane imba yavo yezvematongerwo enyika muLikud.

            1. Haana kusiya sarudzo yekujoinha hurumende yeruboshwe

              Mu SD XNUMX muTammuz P.B.

              Nekudaro, tsamba yaMichael Hauser Tov, 'Shaked anotenda kuti Kara naPinto vacharamba vari kurudyi, uye vanoda kuve rurimi mumatama musarudzo' (Haaretz 2/7/22) zvinoreva kuti sarudzo yekubatana kuruboshwe. -bapiro hurumende mupenyu uye kukava, mukadzi mumwechete ane mbiri yakafanana 🙂

              Regards, Yekutiel Shneur Zehavi

              1. Uye pamwe Bennett akaenda pamudyandigere nekuti akaziva kuti aisakwanisa kumirisana nedzvinyiriro yaBiden

                Bennett anogona kunge akanzwisisa kuti pamberi pekumanikidzwa kwaBiden kufambisira mberi runyararo - haakwanise kumira.

                Zvichida anotarisirawo kuti munguva yesarudzo hapazovi nekumanikidzwa kukuru kweAmerica kune zvibvumirano, kuitira kuti tisakanganisa simba rezvematongerwe enyika rekuruboshwe, uye panguva ino tichawana mwedzi mishomanana umo kudzvinyirirwa kweAmerica kusingazoitirwi. simba rakazara.

                Ichokwadi kuti zvinofanirwa kunzwika kuti zvishoma nezvishoma uye muchivande, Lapid naGantz vachabvumirana neveAmerica pakumutsiridza "nzira yerunyararo," uye kana Knesset ikabudirira mukumisa hurumende yakagadzikana, ipapo "nzira yerunyararo" ichagamuchira. kukurumidza kuparadza, Knesset.

                Makadii, neni kutumira kuAgzam-Kimmel

              2. Inoenderera mberi nekufamba kuseri kwezviitiko

                MuS.D.H. muTammuz P.B.

                Tsamba yakabudiswa nhasi paChannel 7 inotaura kuti Ayelet Shaked anoenderera mberi achibvunzana naBennett nguva dzose, uye "Naftali Ayelet anoita chinyorwa paakanga achibvumirana naye" 🙂

                Uye muchidimbu: zvakanga zviripo ndizvo zvichavapo uye hapana chitsva pasi pezuva. Uye chinyaradzo chedu ndechekuti Prime Minister vadzoka kuzogara kuJerusarema. Iye achagara mu 'Villa Salameh', muJabotinsky kona yeBalfour, chivakwa ichi chave chaDavid Sofer. Muzukuru waRabbi Shmalka weSalish achagara mumba memuzukuru wemusaini Sofer.

                Chokwadi, Yaknaz

                1. Zvaiva nani kuti vaite sarudzo dzemukati

                  Iyi nzira - yemabiko emunhu mumwe - haina hutano. Mutongi mumwechete anopopotera vamiriri vake uye 'zvigzag' kubva kune rimwe bato kuenda kune rimwe bato' - anozopedzisira arasa kuvimba neveruzhinji, zvaive nani kuisa mari mukuvaka hwaro hwakasimba hweveruzhinji.

                  Kana nhengo dzebato nevavhoti vakaziva kuti mutungamiri pamwe naye vamiriri vebato muKnesset vanosarudzwa nenhengo dzebato, uye vari pasi pekutariswa kwemasangano akasarudzwa ebato - ipapo nhengo dzebato neruzhinji rwese vanovimbwa uye vane chokwadi chekuti. vamiririri vavo vakavimbika kune vanovatuma.

                  Makadi, neni kutumira Kimel-Langzam

                  1. Asi iyo Likud zvakare ine chimwe chinhu chekuvandudza

                    Iyo Likud iri munzvimbo iri nani. Mutauriri nenhengo dzeKnesset vanosarudzwa muma primaries nenhengo dzese dzebato, uye kunewo masangano akasarudzwa - Musangano neCentre. Asi zvaizova nani kuti sachigaro webato avewo nehutungamiriri hwezvematongerwo enyika hwaizo“takura mutoro wavanhu” maererano nechirevo chevachenjeri chinoti: “Musave mumwechete Dhani.

                    Makadii, neni kutumira kuAgzam-Kimmel

                2. Kutonga kwebhajeti raYamina kuri mumaoko aMatan Kahana

                  בכתבה ‘שקד חוששת? השליטה על כספי ימינה בידי מתן כהנא’ מסופר על מסמך רשמי שנחשף ובו נאמר שהשליטה על תקציבי ‘ימינה’ תימסר למתן כהנא.

                  הווה אומר: לא פרישה ולא נעליים. בנט ימשיך לשלוט בימינה באמצעות שליטת שלוחו הנאמן בתקציבי המפלגה. הוא יהיה ‘בעל המאה ובעל הדיעה’ ואיילת שקד – פלאקט בעלמא.

                  Regards, Yekutiel Shneur Zehavi

                  נראה שאותו תרגיל עשה בנט ל’בית היהודי’, כאשר פרש אך השאיר את נאמנו ניר אורבך כמנכ”ל המפלגה…

  7. Ndinonzwa sekunge ndanga ndakatarisa zvese izvi kubva kunze kwenguva yakati rebei. Izvo hazvindifarire zvakanyanya - kana munhu achida kuumba hutungamiriri, anoumba, kana vanhu vakada bato rinoenderana nezvavanofunga, vanoumba bato rakadaro. Kune maRabhi kana vanhu vepanyika vanotaura zvisina maturo ini ndinofarira kunzwa zvavanotaura uye varipo vakandibereka. Handioni chikonzero chipi nechipi chokuti uyu kana kuti mutungamiri andiudze zvokufunga kana kuti "kugadzira mishnah yakarongeka." Zvizhinji handina hurongwa hwakarongeka uye ini zvakanaka nazvo, nyaya imwe neimwe kumuviri wayo uye ini handioni chikonzero chekuronga maonero angu ese mumutumbi mumwe, kunyangwe zvichireva kuti maonero angu epasirese akanganisa kumucheto. Kwandiri, kuedza kuita mumwe munhu akadaro kunochengetedza uye hakubatsiri. Ini ndinoona iyo inopokana-kufunga uye hysterical hurukuro iripo kurudyi nekuruboshwe kuruboshwe uye inogadzira manzwiro ekuti handina "imba yezvematongerwo enyika" chero kupi, asi zvakare inoita kuti ndisade imba yakadaro. Dzimba dzakadaro dzinowanzoita majeri, uye majeri - kunze kwekushaikwa kwekusununguka mazviri - inzvimbo dzinofinha.

    1. Ndinosaina izwi rese. Mubvunzo ndewokuti unounza sei vamwe vazhinji vanonzwa mumhepo uye vasingazive maitiro ekuzvifungira, kuti vawane mvumo yenzira yavo uye maonero? Kare mapato maviri makuru aive mubatanidzwa werimwe nerimwe nerimwe uye risingarerekere. Ndiri kutaura nezve bato risiri remapato richafuridza gehena kubva mumapato akasiyana-siyana anotonga hupenyu hwedu. Izvi zvinoda sangano rezvematongerwe enyika uye remagariro evanhu.

      1. Ndinonzwa - chokwadi - kuti hupenyu hupfupi kwazvo kuti ndihutambise pakutsvaga kuve pamutemo. Hazvirevi kuti ini ndiri pamusoro pezvinhu izvi, ndinewo maonero andisingade kugovera nekuti ini handidi kupopotedzana kana dzimwe nguva handitombodi kupihwa chiratidzo sechimwe kana chimwe, asi zvakanyanya. hazviratidzike zvakakosha kwandiri.

          1. Ichi chimwe chinhu. Wakataura nezve kutsvaga kuve pamutemo uye kune izvo ndakapindura 🙂 Zvakadaro ini ndinowanzo kutarisira uye kufunga kuti chokwadi chine hungwaru pane kuyedza kutsanangura nekuchironga. Zvose zvinotsanangurwa zvinoratidza chokwadi chakabvaruka apo hazvibviri kugara pamwe chete uye isu tose tinoparadzwa, asi pamusoro payo, chokwadi chinoratidzika sechibvumira pakupedzisira. Zvinhu zvakakosha kwandiri rusununguko rwekufunga uye rusununguko rwekutaura, chero varipo hupenyu hunowana nzira, sechinyorwa cheJurassic Park.

      2. Mukuwedzera - zvinoratidzika kwandiri kuti chokwadi chave chataurirwa, kune masangano asina masangano akadaro: anonzi "kune ramangwana", "bhuruu nechena" uye hama dzavo dzose dzinokura usiku humwe uye dzinowanzoita. kuhwina zvigaro zvinodarika gumi musarudzo imwe neimwe - anonzi macentre parties. Vanowanzoonekwa nekuzvidzwa nekuti havana dzidziso, uye vanosanganisira vanhu vanoita sevasina chimiro chimwe chete (chenyika, chechitendero, chekuruboshwe, kurerekera kurudyi, zvichingodaro), pavanenge vachiita, dhinominati yavo huru ndeye inonzi "slime" mumutauro wevanhu. . Ndivo vanhu vanonzwisisa vanoda kurarama zvine musoro uye vanoda kurega zvibvumirano zvine musoro uye vanewo zvimwe zvinhu zvisingavakodzeri kurega asi kazhinji mumadhanzi haavaenderani zvakanaka. Ivo havasi vakaomesesa vanofunga, uye hongu - ivo havana yenguva dzose sub, zvirokwazvo kwete seboka. Hazvisi izvo zvinoorora, asi pamwe ndizvo zvese zvinotora kuti ukwanise * kumhanya * nyika ino pane kuedza kuiita chigaro chaIshe munyika kana libertarian kana socialist paradhiso yemhando imwe kana imwe. Vanhu vasina simba rekuti utopias. Mune maonero angu akazvininipisa (murombo chaizvo uye kwete sekutaura, ini handikwanise kuzviunza kuti ndifarire nyaya idzi), maitiro akadaro aivewo chikamu cheglue yakabatanidza hurumende yaBennett yainzi inoshamisa (kunze kwe "kwete Bibi." " iyo iri mumaziso angu glue yakakodzera uye inoruramiswa).

  8. Nei murabhi asina hukama naRabhi Ilai Ofran sezvo asingagutsikane nebato rechitendero (ane podcast panhau iyi) uye vese vanopikisa varabhi muZionism yechitendero chemazuva ano seTorah neAvodah akatendeka Sheikh Yitzchak uye imwe yemazuva ano yekupedzisira- Rabhi weOrthodox akaita saYehoshua Pepper anoda kudzidza
    Rabhi pachake akataura kuti kune ruzhinji ruzhinji rwemazuva ano uye ndinobvumawo kuti vakawanda saka imi vanaRabhi ndimi mune mhosva nekuti vanhu vamwechete kana vakaona kuti kune varabhi kana mishnah yemazuva ose vachada kumuvhotera kusanganisira ini mudiki anga achipopota pamusoro pekushaikwa kweimwe nzira kwenguva yakati.Anokurudzira kuna rabhi kuti agare kure neboka remapenzi Beit Midrash Anshei Chayil vanove boka revarwi, etc. Mushure mekunge ndaona vhidhiyo yavo kuti rabhi aivepo, nezvimwewo. .uye zvinhu zviri nyore

    Pachinzvimbo chehama dzangu dzese dzemazuva ano dzechiOrthodox, ndinokumbira rabhi kuti atipe imwe nzira izvozvi.

    Zvido
    Vanhu vechokwadi nekutenda

    1. Sezvandakanyora, ini handina kubatana kune chero munhu nekuti handisi muratidziri wezvematongerwo enyika. Munguva yakapfuura, ndakarambawo kujoina masangano ose echiRabhi akauya kwandiri, nokuti handibvumirani kuti vataure vakamiririra ini seboka.

  9. Kwete rabhi kwete!!

    Tichafuratira ongororo yakashata yezvematongerwo enyika mumaonero angu akazvininipisa, uye tinobata zvakanyanya, handizive kuti rabhi akadzidza zvakadii uye anoziva Rabbi Kook's beit midrash asi kudaidza iyi inochengetedza beit midrash ingori kukanganisa! Rabbi Kook zvachose chaive chitsva uye budiriro, akaona kutonhora kwenzvimbo seimwe yezvirwere zvakaipisisa zviripo. Melamed naDruckman .. pamwe unofanira kusangana navo uye unzwisise maonero avo enyika ..

    PS Comment pamusoro pezvematongerwo enyika Vanenge vanarabhi vose (Tao, Druckman, Eliyahu nevamwe) vakawira sewe mukufunga kwavo pamusoro peRAAM.Tinoziva kuti akanga akarurama uye kuti akatiponesa.

  10. Zvinonakidza kuti tsananguro yakanyangarika sei kubva mumaziso emunyori nevamwe vakapindura kuti bato rechitendero reZionist raSmutritz rakasiyana nemapato e-ultra-Orthodox mukuti ndiyo chete yakanga isingadi (kunze kwemumiriri waRabbi Tao) kugara nemaArabu. (vanova shamwari dzechisikigo dzemaArabu). Musiyano mukuru wedenga nenyika. Nekuti ichi chiZionism. Uku kuvimbika kuvanhu vechiJudha. Uye iro rakanga riri dambudziko rakaoma. Uye Smutrich aive akarurama uye akatonga kurudyi. Zvakazoitika kuti kunyangwe veruzhinji vezvitendero zvemazuva ano (izvo zvandiriwo) havana kuvimbika kuvanhu vechiJudha. Lucky ndakavhotera Smutrich musarudzo dzapfuura (ndakaona kuti Bennett aizoenda neruboshwe kuti ave prime minister. Nyangwe ndaisafunga kuti aizoendawo nemaArabu).

      1. Ndakagadzirisa kukanganisa nekukasira (zvakanditorera maminetsi mashoma kuti ndione kukanganisa uye kunyorawo kururamisa) asi chokwadi musiyano wakakosha pakati pechitendero cheZionism uye yekupedzisira-Orthodox. Smutrich anogona kutenda kuchigaro chaMwari chehushe munyika asi ndiye zvakare akadzidza nhoroondo uye ane fungidziro yenhoroondo yekuti maJuda haagone kutsamira paari uye kuvimba nemunhu asi ivo pachavo - kugovana magumo (izvi ndizvo zvandinazvo uye ndinozviisa paari). Kufamba nevatorwa kurasika kwevaJudha vagere pano. Uye ini ndiri muOrthodox yemazuva ano ndiri kutanga kukanda kusahadzika kwakakomba pachangu uye kufunga kana tsika dziri kunze kweTorah dziri tsika dzechokwadi (izvo vanhu vanobatirira pazviri vanotenda mazviri). Iwo (tsika) ndiwo mararamiro akatangira Torah (kana mumaonero akazara) asi mukati mawo haagari (kana pasina Torah hapana nzira yehupenyu. Kureva, vanhu vanozunguza mweya wavo. mireza varevi venhema).

        Zvinoita sekuti Orthodox yemazuva ano (kunyanya maAshkenazi echitendero, kusanganisira kurudyi. Zvichida kuruboshwe), havana kuvimbika kuvanhu vechiJudha. Fariro yavo ichagara iri yekutanga. Iyo inofambira mberi kuruboshwe inotungamirira kuruboshwe rworuboshwe (kune imwezve.) Kunyange zvazvo kodzero yekusununguka inonyengedza kuruboshwe rwose uye inotungamirirwa naro uye Orthodox yemazuva ano inoedza kufadza zvose izvi (kunze kwekunzwa kwenguva refu kwekuderera kubva kuNRP. legacy) uye vanotungamirwa navo. Vanhu vasiri Haredi uye vasiri Haredi Ashkenazi voruzhinji havangovimbiki kuvanhu vechiJudha (pasina kuzviziva, sezviri pachena. Nokuda kwehutungamiri hunofambira mberi hunoramba kuvimbika kune chero mutemo). Iyo ego yevanhu vanoigadzira ndiyo inovatungamira. Kwete kuti ma-ultra-Orthodox haana ego, asi Torah inoraira kwavari - kuvatungamiriri vavo - kuvimbika kuvanhu vechiJudha. Zvichida ichi ndicho chikonzero chaicho nei veUltra-Orthodox vasinganyore - vakanzwisisa kuti iyi haisi iyo chaiyo mamiriro evaJudha. Vakaziva kuti vakanga vari voga mumugumo wavo uye vamwe vose vakanga vasina kuvimbika kwavari. Kana kuti vane chitendero chakafanana nechaLubavitcher Rebbe mumutauro wose wevaJudha. Vakaona kuti vaive voga padambudziko ravo uye vamwe vese vaive vasina kuvimbika kwavari

    1. Kururamiswa kwemhosho: kuti ivo (maArabu) vadyidzani vechisikigo ve Ultra-Orthodox… uye zvakasiyana, sezvazvinonzwisisika, akaona chokwadi chekuti Smutrich akaramba kugara navo, asi kwete nekuda kwechigaro chaMwari munyika. 0 kuti mumiriri wepfungwa iyi aitoda kugara nemaArabu. Mumiriri waRabhi Tao) asi nekuti anotenda kuti Nyika yeIsrael inofanira kunge iri nyika yemaJuda. Uye kuti maArabu ndevevanhu vevavengi (uye chero zvakadaro hazvisi zvavo kugara navo uye kuva nechigaro chehurumende pamusoro pavo. Hazvinei kuti vanozivisa kuti nyika ndeyamaJuda. Kuvimbika kuhurumende. , inoita kuti uto, rive nesimba uye mutero kupfuura chero ani zvake.VaJudha vanofanira kudzidza kushandira pamwe)

  11. Kwete padanho repfungwa asi padanho rehunhu, Elyashiv Reichner anotsanangura Rabbi Amital semuOrthodox yemazuva ano mubhuku raakanyora nezvake. Iyewo, akadyiswa naPedal

    To my surprise wanga wakatsamwira Silman. Ani nani anosaina nemurume mumwechete gwaro mangwanani kuti achengetedze ramangwana rake, idiki polythruite inongotevera maziso ake uye neshure kwepakati yake iyo yaanove xxxx shure kwavo. Iko hakuna tsika uye hapana pfungwa dzekupandukira izvo zvakakura paari.
    Murume mumwe chete akakunda. Tinovimba kuti gadziriro yeruramisiro kana kuti zvikonzero zvokurapa zvichatungamirira kukupunzika kwake. Uye zviri nani kana izvozvo zvikaitika musarudzo dzinotevera

    1. Sechikamu chekudzidza kwezvinyorwa, ini ndinokurudzira kuti uongorore chikuva cheSmutritz uye iyo yekupedzisira-Orthodox: pakati pezvimwe zvinhu, ivo vari kufarira kutemwa nematombo vatyora Sabata nemhombwe, kudzikisa vasingatendi mugomba uye kwete kuvasimudza. , kuuraya vana vaAmareki, uye vamwe vakawanda.
      Iwe unofanirwawo kutarisa papuratifomu yechiKristu maererano neiyo dama rechipiri rinoshumirwa, saka ndiani akataura nezvekuponda nekutambudzwa muzita rechiKristu?
      Vanhu vakangwara vanotaura zvekuvata havanzwisisi zvavari kutaura. Mafambiro uye mapoka haaongororwe muzvikamu zvavo asi mukuita kwavo. Zvose ChiJudha, ChiKristu uye Ram.

      1. Yakanamirwa ipuratifomu yeChitendero Zionist Party. Ndakakwanisa kuitsvaga kubva mufiriji ndikashaya kana tsvakiridzo yezvaunoti kwavari. Zvimwe zvinhu zvakatsvedza kubva mukuona kwangu - ndingafarire chirevo chakadzama kune kamwechete referensi.

        https://zionutdatit.org.il/%D7%9E%D7%A6%D7%A2-%D7%94%D7%9E%D7%A4%D7%9C%D7%92%D7%94/

        Kuzivisa Kwakafanira: Handina chinetso nezvinhu izvi, pashure pokugadzwa kweSanihedrini uye kugara kwevatongi sokutanga muB. Uyu ndiwo murairo waMwari uye fadza Abda Dekodsha Brich ari. (Zviri nani kuedza…).

        1. Ndinofunga wakanzwisisa chinangwa changu. Chikuva chavo chakavakirwa paTorah neHalacha, uye kune dzidziso dzakasimba kwazvo. Kana waizovatonga maererano nematenesi aya waisaenda kure. Muenzaniso weVakristu neDama rechipiri unojekesa izvi (hapana chikuva chezvematongerwo enyika chebato rezvematongerwo enyika).
          Kana ari Abda Dekuba, Vachenjeri vaivewo varanda vake asi havana kunyatsoita mazwi sezvaaive. Ndini ndakataura kuti pane musiyano pakati pekugadzirwa kwenheyo uye theoretical substrate uye tsika, uye nharo yangu ndeyokuti mapoka anofanira kuongororwa kuburikidza nekuita uye kwete kuburikidza ne substrate.

          1. MuDare Repamusorosoro, munopa kutenda kwakawanda kukunzwisisa kwangu. (Ndiwo manzwisisiro andakaita, kana zvisiri ndapota gadzirisa). Mupuratifomu mavo handina kuwana kana mucherechedzo wazvo. Ichokwadi kuti mupi wezano wezvemitemo we "Yemina" akaenderera mberi achiti chikuva hachisungirire bato muKnesset, asi ini ndichiri kufunga kuti havazoteki nematombo chero munhu pamberi pekugadzwa kweSanihedrini uye kudzoreredzwa kwemutemo we mweya, saka panguva ino munhu wese anogona kuzorora…

            Izvo hazviitike kwandiri kuti ndizvienzanise neSages, asi ivo havana basa nehurukuro. Vakararama muutongi hwokumwe, kana kuti vaSadhuse (kunze kwenhambo pfupi) uye zvimwe vakanga vakaganhurirwa mukukwanisa kwavo kutanga mutemo weTorah. Zvisinei, dzimwe nguva vaiita zvinhu kwete mumashoko avo pachavo asi kunyange nehukasha hwakanyanyisa (seuya aitasva bhiza munguva dzechiGiriki, uye Shimon ben Shetach akaturika vakadzi makumi masere pazuva rimwe kana kupfuura). Ini handina muenzaniso wakajeka wehurumende maererano neTorah (yakakura uye iri nani kupfuura ini ichaonekwa ichiswedera pabasa rekunyora). Zvandataura ndezvekuti pamusimboti handina dambudziko nekusvibiswa kwevadariki veSabata nemhombwe, saka Sanihedrini huru ichazviona zvakakodzera mushure mekunge Mwari vapindura vatongi vedu kekutanga munaGd. Ini ndinofungidzira kuti zvese zvechitendero Zionism uye yekupedzisira-Orthodox vanonzwisisa kuti kunyangwe kana chishamiso chikaitika uye vakagashira huwandu hwakakwana muKnesset, zvinhu hazvishande nhasi. Sekuziva kwangu vamwe vavo, vakapusa.

            Muchidimbu, hazvina kukodzera kuisa mumuromo weanopikisa zvematongerwo enyika zvaasina kumbotaura, nekuda kwekuti unoonga kuti anofunga kudaro. (Uye kana akati, ndichakutendai nokuda kwekutaura).

            1. Wadiwa Modhekai. Hauna kupusa sezvaunozviita. Handina kuti vaizopima kana vapinda pachigaro. Ndakataura zvakapesana chaizvo: kuti kunyangwe papuratifomu havazokwira kunyangwe vauya kuzotonga.
              Asi mashura enzira dzekufamba neupofu.

              1. Zvichida maitiro anondipofumadza, asi nekuda kwaMwari, Rabhi wedu anodiwa, zvinhu zvawaiti kwavari zvinoonekwa papi papuratifomu yeTzaddik? (Zvavachaita nepuratifomu yavo kana vauya kuzotonga ndeimwe pfungwa).

                1. Haunzwisisi here kana kuti hauverenge zvandinonyora?
                  Inoonekwa muTorah neHalacha, izvo zviri zvechokwadi substrate yavo. Ini nokudaro ndakaratidza kukanganisa kuripo mukuongororwa kwemubhedha panzvimbo yetsika.

  12. A. Iwo ekupedzisira-Orthodox neSmutritz vanoenda kurudyi nekuti kupatsanurwa pakati pekurudyi nekuruboshwe kuri chaizvo - mumatunhu edu - pakati pechiJuda chekare cheConservatism uye nharaunda nyowani.
    B. "Vakaruka" vanosarudza kupfekedza korona varabhi vavo vanochengetedza nokuti vane manzwiro ekuonga Torah (kwete kuti vanogara vachiziva kuti ndiani). Usanetseka - zvichapera muchizvarwa.
    chetatu. Mamwe ese akanyorwa se "Latvian" nekuti avo vasina manzwiro ekuti havadi kuisa mari mutsika dzechitendero chechiJudha chakanangana nechiJudha, ingave ichokwadi kana kwete - ino haisi iyo nzvimbo.

  13. Sei kupatsanurwa kuri chete Conservatism uye Zionism? Ichokwadi kuti vose ve-ultra-Orthodox uye vechitendero chenyika vanochengetedza, asi Hillel paZuva reIndependence haisiriyo yega yedzidziso dzaRabbi Kook idzo vanarabhi vawataura vanotevera mumakwara ake. Kunyange kana izvi zviri izvo zvinotaridzika nenzira yakanyanyisa muRabbi Tao, pakupedzisira inzira inobata nzvimbo dzose dzehupenyu, yakasiyana zvikuru ne-ultra-Orthodox.

  14. Kunyangwe ndikabvumirana nezvakawanda zvezvaunotaura, izvo zvinokatyamadza (uye zvinokatyamadza, nekuti zviri pachena kuti hauna hanya nechiitiko ichi, kutaura zvishoma) - ndiwo maitiro auno "kugara pafenzi":
    Iko kurongeka chaikoiko kwakakosha uye kwakakomborerwa.
    Ipapo, anokodzera kutaurirwa neruzhinji, kurova, nekuda kwekusaronga zvinoenderana nekunzwisisa uye tsananguro iyi (iyo inomira sechinhu chakajairika cheruzivo rwunozvigadzira) - pasina kupa zano kana kunongedzera kune maitiro uye munhu kana boka vachatakura mireza.

    Ndine chokwadi chekuti hamuna kukanganwa chokwadi chekuti mabhindauko mazhinji uye shanduko yezvematongerwo enyika neyenyika yakaitika kwete nekuda kwemafungiro nemafungiro, asi mushure mekunge mutungamiriri amuka (uyo kanopfuura kamwe, kwete netsaona, aive mumwe wevanofunga) .

    Saka zvinokatyamadza kunzwa kuti kune rumwe rutivi unonyunyuta sei pamusoro pekushaikwa kwekuronga pasi pehunhu hunowanzozivikanwa hwawakatsanangura, gaka riri mukushaikwa kwehutungamiriri hwepfungwa-gothic (iyo yakaisimbisa semubatsiri asina kutsanangurwa dzimwe nzira dzakatsanangurwa). Izvo zvinomuita kuti anzwe mhando B, lite, nezvimwewo) - uye kune rumwe rutivi, anogara pafenzi uye iwe hautauri (kana kukurudzira) iwe pachako kutora chinzvimbo chinoshanda uye kwete kungoita gothic. Iko kugamuchirwa kunobva pakuziva Torich nebasa rako. Kana ari munhu anotama kubva pakuita, zvakanaka, asi zvinoratidzika kwandiri kuti kudiwa kuri mubvunzo hakuiti kukundikana kwekuzvipira ne impromptu Civil Guard muLod panguva yemhirizhonga - muenzaniso wakanaka wega unoratidzawo chido. kupeta maoko edu pazvinenge zvakakodzera.

    Zvinoita kwandiri, saka, kuti kutanga nzira uye hutungamiriri (mumiriri, kunyangwe asiri weparamende panguva ino) yaive nhanho inodiwa. Uye kubva muchikamu nemhinduro dzako kune vanokubvunza zvinonzwika kuti hausi kuona chisungo chakadaro, uye wakamirira mumwe Mesiasi kuti atore pfungwa dzako odzishandisa.

    Kwete kuti ini handizive kukosha kwevanofunga uye ideological infrastructure. Asi iwe pamwe unonzwisisa kuti kana nezuro chete iwe wakawana tsananguro uye pamwe nayo chishuwo chekuita iyo nzira (uye kwete chete "kushaikwa kwenzira" sezvataurwa) - zvishoma zvinokatyamadza kutarisira kuti zuva rinotevera Man Dhao achamuka uye fadza ruzhinji rwakamupoteredza.

    Ini handioni kuti maitiro ako akasiyana sei neaya eruzhinji rwaunonyunyuta nezvawo (kunyangwe ukazvibatanidza muzita reruremekedzo) nekusareva kuti nzira yake inzira uye kwete mupendero wepamutemo weasina nzira.
    Pane kudaro. Veruzhinji vakaita chikamu chavo nekuvhotera Bennett uye kwete Smutritz semuenzaniso. (Kana kugara kumba etc.). Avo vakapeta pamberi pekudzvinyirirwa vaingova avo "sluts" pabhodhi remutambo, avo vaimanikidzwa. Kwete veruzhinji vakatumira.

    1. [Sezvineiwo chimwe chinhu chakabuda kwenguva refu, ndakaona meseji yandakarangarira chiitiko. Pane imwe nguva ndichiri mudiki ndakatumira ruoko rwangu mukubika makeke emhuri uye ndaisiya seri kwendiro dzine tsvina. Mai vangu vakazviona kaXNUMX kana kaviri ndokubva vanyora kambo kekuti "anogadzirira asingageze kunge asina kugadzirira." Chokwadi ndakamunyeya zvine simba nekuti gadziriro yacho ndaiita uye nei uye sei ndaizoitawo basa rekutsvaira, uye kuti anorega kudya garlic ngaadzokerewo achirega kudya ambala. Pakutanga ndakafunga kuti aireva kuti keke iri rakanga risingakoshi, uye zvakanga zvakanaka kuti ave nekicheni yakachena isina keke kubva mukicheni ine tsvina nekeke imomo. Uye Nafka akagadza kuti kana vakasarudza kugadzira keke rakadai seSabbat saka zvirokwazvo ani naani ainetseka kugadzira pano akabhadharwa naye uye chiito chake pamberi pake uye haatombozvipira kune dambudziko rekuchenesa. Saka ndakamirira mukana wekunzi ndigadzirire ndichibva ndaita chipatapata kugadzirira nekusiya tsvina. Ndakashamiswa sei kunzwa rwiyo rwandaiziva runoti “Wakagadzirira uye hauna kuchenesa sokunge kuti hauna kugadzirira” ruchibva mumuromo womupristi mukuru. Ndakabva ndangovhomora zvigumwe zvangu ndokudzokera ku pepper zvese zviri pamusoro ndichizvibvunzawo kuti zvaitwa sei sekunge ndisina kugadzirira uye zvinorevei izvi sekunge munhu anoudzwa akadana mbuya asi mu mangwanani haana kumuka kuti anamate akaita seasina kufonera mbuya. Kusvikira zuva ranhasi ndinoramba ndichipikisa chinangwa chetsumo iyi. Aya ndiwo maonero ebasa rose uye sezvo pasina basa rakazara hapana mapoinzi pairi. Kana kuti pamwe zano mukusaziva kuwana hutsanana uye kurerutsa kupatsanurwa kwemabasa. Kana kuti uyo anoziva kuyamwisa achaita shoma. Kana kuti zvinofadza munhu kunatsa tsvina yake kupfuura tsvina yeshamwari yake. Kana kubheka ibasa rakanaka uye riri nyore uye harizi remamwe mabasa evaranda. Uye magumo acho anonzi chishamiso kubva kwauri usade zvawagara nhaka cherechedza hauna basa mune zvakavanzwa (tenga). ]

      1. Tsanangudzo pa 'Mai Vako Dzidziso (LTG)

        Mune SD XNUMX muTammuz P.B.

        TG - Mhoro,

        Gweta rehurumende rinoona sekuti munhu abika keke rinova rimwe remabasa aamai (sezvo kubheka riri rimwe remabasa manomwe anoitirwa murume nomukadzi) - anofunga kuti pakuita izvi akabatsira amai vake ndokuponesa. dambudziko rake. Uye kune izvi amai vako vakapindura nenzira yakarurama, kuti kunetseka kwekuchenesa ndiro nekicheni kunodarika dambudziko rekugadzira keke, kuitira kuti haana kurega muiti wekeke dambudziko kubva kuna amai vake.

        Mukupesana, kunetseka kwaamai kuchenesa murume anobika kunenge kukuru zvikuru, sezvo mukadzi achibika nokubika nenzira ine nhevedzano, pasina mabhura ose nekicheni zvinova ‘chinjo yeSodhoma neGomora’ nenyongano. Basa chairo rokugadzira keke rinopawo mukadzi ‘mufaro wokusika’ unounza kugutsikana kukuru mupfungwa. Izvo zvisiri izvo zvinokanganisa netsvina uye 'clutter'.

        Uye zvichida ndicho chikonzero kugeza imba nendiro hazvibatanidzwe ne 'mabasa manomwe anoitirwa mukadzi nomurume wake', pane kudaro, vachenjeri vakati 'mukadzi haave mucheki wedhishi, nokuti zvinonzi:' Vanhu vanobuda kunogeza '🙂

        Uye saka zvakanaka kuti murume atakure mutoro wekugeza uye kuedza lettuce kana kuzvigadzirira tii yekupisa. Uye kana achiri nechido chekubika uye kubika - achadzidza kuzviita nenzira yakachena uye yakarongeka.

        Nechikomborero che 'Kutsigira uye Kitchen kune Vakarurama', K. Kalman Hanna Zeldovsky

  15. Kana ndikafunga kuverenga chinyorwa chaRabbi Michi Yarom India nekurebesa kukuru, uye zvechokwadi chakakodzera.
    Zvinoitika kuti kutambudzwa kwese, kusvibiswa, kushungurudzwa uye pakupedzisira avo vakaputsa kubva pakuita uye zvakakonzera kuparara kwake (2 bato rake chikamu cheboka rechitendero uye 61 minus 2 = 59 zvapera zvakajeka) idi rechitendero uye chikamu chenzanga yechitendero.

    Kureva kuti: vechitendero vakapidigura mutungamiriri wechitendero chete nekuti ainamata (uye aitoratidza mukana wekuve wechitendero pasina kuzviisa pasi pehurongwa hunogamuchirwa)

    Zvino mubvunzo:
    I K. aitaura nguva dzose kuti iye (vechitendero) anotambudzwa nokuda kwechitendero chake.
    Ko mutumwawo, kusvikira kutambanuko yokuti ivo vakacherwa (zvakare, vorudzidziso) zvikurukuru nemhaka yokuva kwake kworudzidziso here? (Kupfuura zvinotarisirwa pakuchengeta mwana)
    Uye Gweta Guru rakacherwa kusvika pamwero wava (vechitendero) mumaoko avo kunyanya nekuda kwechitendero? (Etc. kupfuura izvo zvinotarisirwa kubva kune zvakajairika bubbly)
    Pamwe chete nemukuru weHofisi Yegweta reHurumende, Shai Nitzan, pamwe chete nevatongi vezvitendero paDare Repamusorosoro, uye pamwewo mukuru wezvechitendero kana ari muhofisi, uye chero chinzvimbo chepamusoro muhurumende.
    Kana iwe uri wechitendero uye uchiita basa nemazvo uchatambudzwa zvakanyanya nevechitendero?

  16. Seudat D. David Malka Moshiach

    Munguva yakapfuura, ndakanzwisisa kuti Gweta Weinroth akakumbirwa neshamwari yake panguva iyoyo, Supreme Court Justice Prof. Barak, kuti akumbire kuDare Repamusorosoro uye akaramba.
    Uye pamwe chikonzero chaive chekuti aizotambura zvakanyanya mukubaya kwake kubva mumitongo,
    Uye aifarira kugara zvakanaka pane kutambura.

    Muchokwadi, Bennett ainyanya kutambura kubva mukunyadziswa kwake, sezvaitarisirwa nemushakabvu Weinroth.

    1. Mushakabvu Adv. Dr. Weinroth akanga asingatyi danga rake asi hana yake uye kuzvidavirira kwaaizoita kana zuva rake rasvika pamberi paMwari. Akataura izvi nemazwi akajeka kwazvo.

      Ndakasvika pakuziva dzimwe hama dzeWeinroth (kusanganisira mushakabvu Jakobho) sevanhu vakatendeseka uye vakarurama (mumwe wavo aimiririra amai vangu Shachat nokuda kwemuhoro wokufananidzira kurwisana nehurumende iyo yakavatorera penjeni yavo inosiririsa nenzira yakashata uye inonyadzisa). Kuenzanisa ruremekedzo rwavo neruremekedzo rwemitezo ye“kurudyi” kunovaitira kusaruramisira kukuru.

  17. Musiyano pakati pechitendero Zionism uye Ultra-Orthodoxism

    Mhoro, mutori wenhau, funga kwechinguva, ndeupi musiyano pakati pe-ultra-Orthodox uye yekupedzisira-Orthodox? Kusvikira pakufunga kwangu, haungawani mutsauko wakadaro kunyangwe mumaikorosikopu erekitironi (kunze kweruvara rwedome uye chikomborero chimwe chakadaro). Mhosva yacho ine musiyano mukuru kwazvo mumubvunzo wemafungiro kune jecha. Iwe haungambowana vakomana ve-ultra-Orthodox vanoita matriculation, mukupesana kunyangwe pakati pe'ultra-Orthodox' - iwe unogona kuverengera kune rimwe ruoko masangano asingaswedere matriculation pane imwe nhanho kana imwe. Nekuda kweizvozvo, pakati peve-ultra-Orthodox pane mhomho yevadzidzi vakura, zvisinei, kunyangwe mumayeshiva akadai sa'Merkaz' kana 'Har Hamor' unowana vadzidzi vashoma vakura. Kunyangwe avo vanoramba vari mudzidzi webhaibheri kwemakore mashoma kusvika aenda kunoshanda munyika kana mubasa reTorah uye avo vasina kukodzera vanoenda kunoshanda. Musiyano, hongu, unobva mukukosha kweZionist - iyo inotora tsika yejecha nechinangwa chekuvaka nyika semitzvah. Sezvineiwo zvinoreva Zionist izvo zvinoona zvisina kunaka kugara mukumbundikira uye kuita muTorah, uchiona zvinhu zvichidzika kubva kudenga, uye zvichipa kukosha kune chido chekuita uye kufurira nyika. Iri rinoratidzika kwandiri semvura inoyerera. Kuve pamutemo kubuda uye mutengo unobhadharwa neZionism yechitendero pakupindira kwayo mukuvaka nyika uye hupenyu hwenyika. Vanhu vanosiya nyika yeTorah kune rumwe rutivi vanokuwana kwakaoma zvikuru kuchengeta uye kuva nemazvo mukuchengeta mitzvos, kune rumwe rutivi vanonzwa kuti mibato yavo munyika yenyika inewo chiyero chemitzvah chinofukidza uye chinoruramisa mutengo wechitendero. . I-ultra-Orthodox, hongu, haibvumirani kana kubvuma kuita uku. Hazvishamisi kuti Orthodoxy yemazuva ano inogona kubudirira muUnited States sezvo pasina iyo munhu wechitendero haagoni kururamisa basa pakutanga (kwete rekurarama) mujecha. MuIsrael, kune rumwe rutivi, Zionism neZionism yechitendero ndizvo zvinopa kururamisa uku, uye naizvozvo hapana chikonzero chekusvika kumatunhu eOrthodoxy yemazuva ano (iyo inofanira kubvumwa kuti inofungidzirwa kuti iri kure kure nechiJudha chepakutanga. )

    1. Aya ndiwo maitiro akajairika uye haasi chaiwo asina kujeka. Vanowedzera ultra-Orthodox vari kuita matriculation uye zvishoma uye zvishoma ultra-Orthodox vari kuzviita. Uyu hausi mutsauko chaiwo. Sand accounting ipassword isina chinhu, sezvakaita mamwe akawanda mapassword maanogona kusiyaniswa. Mubvunzo wezvinoitika mukuita zvakakosha uye hapana mutsauko. Kune mapoka e-ultra-Orthodox umo nhamba yevadzidzi idiki, saka madhasi haasi mutsauko wakakura.

          1. Hahahahahahahahaha. “Ko kupondwa kwemaJuda nekuti ivo maJuda hakutsauri here pakati peNazi Germany nemaPalestine (vanoda vaJudha nekuti vakagara munyika yavanoti ndeyavo)? Kwete. Inowanikwa muvanhu vese vari vaviri (kwaivewo nemaNazi maGerman akauraya maJuda chete nekuti vakagamuchira rairo, uye kwete nekuti vaive maJuda) ”. Izvi zvakada kuenzana nehupenzi hwawakanyora pano.

      1. Chirevo chekuti musiyano uripo pakati pematriculation (uye kudhirowa data yebasa) pakati peva-ultra-Orthodox uye ekupedzisira maZionists echitendero cheOrthodox hachisi chinhu chisina mubvunzo chinondishamisa. Iyo data ine chekuita neiyo yekupedzisira-Orthodox yakajeka, uye inomuka mune chero nharo yeInternet ine chekuita nehupfumi uye iyo yekupedzisira-Orthodox. Ini handisati ndaona zvirevo zvakafanana zvichisimuka kuenda kuMechinat Ali kana kunyange Mount Mount.
        Kuedza kutaura kuti sezvo muganho pakati peruzhinji wakasviba saka hapana mutsauko wakafanana ungave kupokana kuti nekuti muganhu pakati peOrthodox neruzhinji rwechinyakare hauna kujeka saka hapana mutsauko unokosha pakati pavo (uye iyo column iri pano iri. yakavakirwa chaizvo pamagakava pamusoro pekugamuchira halakhah seyo yega sosi yehunhu).

        Uye sezvo zviri mumaonero angu zvine chekuita, ini ndichazvidzikisa zvishoma uye ndogadzirisa kuti Rabbi Yitzchak Joseph haatauri kurumbidza paZuva reIndependence kunyangwe izvozvi.

        1. Mukati meMount Moor haisi tsika yekudzidzisa Chirungu kuvana uye mhedzisiro zvinoenderana; Kuderera kwematriculation rates uye kuchengetedzwa kwevana mu-ultra-Orthodox modhi yechizvarwa chinotevera. Iyo chete nzira yekupukunyuka iri muuto, asi izvi ndezvechokwadi kune akajairwa ultra-Orthodox.

  18. Zvakadiniko neBeit Midrash muZionism yorudzidziso isiri vazukuru vevadzidzi veHarzia (pakati neMount Mor), vakadai saYeshiva yeGush uye Yeshiva yeMa'ale Adumim?

    Zvinoita sekuti vanokupa zvaunoda, uye shure kwezvose, mayeshivot maviri aya akatora kubva pakati pavo vadzidzi vevachenjeri uye yeshivot Bat (wakanga uri R.M. mune chimwe chazvo… muYeruham, inova rudzi rwaBat Yeshiva vebloc)

    Zvinoita sekuti pane imwe rabbical-yeshiva imwe yauri kutsvaga uye yawakataura muchinyorwa kuti haiko.

  19. Iwe unongotsanangura hwaro hweruzhinji rwechitendero chenyika zvakasiyana uye chero zvipi zvazvo vese vanarabhi vawataura ndeye Ultra-Orthodox maererano nenzira yako.
    Mhinduro kubva kune rumwe rutivi ichava nyore: Chitendero cheZionism hachina kutsanangurwa maererano nemazuva ano (zvichida) asi maererano neZionism. Nenzira iyi, iyo inoratidzika kwandiri kuva inogamuchirwa zvakanyanya, vanarabhi vari pamusoro apa ndevenyika uye vakakwirira zvikuru.
    Uye shoko pamusoro pezita rekuzvidza rinodikamwa nhasi "Haredal" - unogona kuenda kurudyi nekuruboshwe nezvikonzero, asi zita remadunhurirwa iri rakatanga kugadzirwa nevaya vakati zvinyoro usatora kurerutsa sezvakaonekwa uye vakaona pamberi pechiso chavo girazi. wandakapinza basa kuti halakhah. Chitarisiko ichi chaive chisinganakidze nekuti akavaisa pachinzvimbo chekuti vaive vakanganisa. Kuita sei? Tanga zita remadunhurirwa rinozvidza. Hazvirevi kuti ini ndiri Hafifnik (uye ini zvechokwadi handikupi mhosva nokuda kweizvozvo, asi mupfungwa yepurofiti inowanzovapo), ndiye mustard! Zvino zvinogoneka kudzokera pakuva jena ane dome uye nehana yakachena.

    1. Handizivi kuti unofunga kuti waverenga mashoko angu kana kuti wakaverenga ukasanzwisisa. Hameno kuti ndeipi dudziro isinganyanyi kubata.
      Handina kutsanangura ruzhinji rwechitendero chenyika zvakasiyana. Ndinomutsanangura sewe. Ndakangokakavadzana kuti chikamu che-ultra-Orthodox (nokuti mubvunzo weZionism hauna maturo, zvichida mazuva ano), uye mvura inofanira kunge yakapoteredza mazuva ano uye kwete pedyo neZionism. Ndiko kuti, Orthodoxy yemazuva ano inopesana ne-ultra-Orthodoxism. Kutenderedza mutsara uyu, iyo Idim yandakataura yese ndeye Ultra-Orthodox.
      Nokudaro, zita remadunhurirwa remasitadhi, pasinei nokuti rakatangira sei, rakarurama uye rakarurama. Ivo vari Ultra-Orthodox (kureva anti-yazvino) uye yenyika. Zvese izvi zvakanyorwa nekutsanangurwa mukoramu pachayo hongu. Icho chokwadi chekuti iwe hausi kutara zvisizvo uye kurongedza hachiunze nharo inotsigira chero chinhu.

      1. Zvakanaka, kechipiri: havabvumirani nemafungiro ako kuti mutsara wakakosha wekuparadzanisa uri pedyo nemazuva ano, uye vanotonyanya kusabvumirana nemashoko okuti mubvunzo weZionism hauna basa.
        Pane kukakavara pamusoro pemaitiro ehurumende nemasangano ayo, tingave tiri mukudzikinurwa, nezvimwewo zvinomutsa mibvunzo yakakosha sebasa rechiuto nezvimwe.
        Kodzero yako yekuchekeresa zvakasiyana uye muchikamu chako maRabhi ari pamusoro ari echokwadi ma-Orthodox, asi zvinoratidzika kwandiri kuti ruzhinji rweruzhinji harwutsanangure saizvozvo nekuti harubvumirani newe mukutsanangura kwekutanga kwemvura.

        Kana iri yemasitadhi - nguva yokutanga yandakaona zita remadunhurirwa iri rakanga riri pedyo nevaya vakanga vasingabvumirani kunzwa vakadzi vachiimba vachirarama, chinhu icho kunyange varabhi vakuru vakasununguka vairambidza.

  20. Ongororo iri pamusoro ingadai yakave yakarurama 100 muzana, dai Levant aidaidzwa kuti Shivi Reichner kana kuti Shmuel Shetach. Zvekuita Kuenderera mberi kwemutungamiri wehurumende akarega basa kunoratidza kuti anonyanya kurovha ane hanyn'a neprose yake pane kuti ashandise dzidziso yake yakarongeka kugarikano yevavhoti. Haana kumbove ane mishnah yakarongeka, asi ego - hongu.

    Bennett akafanana nemunhu anoshanda maererano neAmerican motivation mabhuku. Denga ndiro muganhu, unogona kunyoresa muGeneral Staff patrol, kuroora runako rwenyika, uve mamirioni epamusoro-soro uye wozofunga nezve nhanho inotevera. Kukwira Everest? Kutora mufananidzo wehofisi yebhokisi? Kuti ave mutungamiriri wehurumende? Bennett anosarudza sarudzo yechitatu uye kwechinguva anotamba nemafungiro ebato reIsrael (nokuda kwezvose zvakanaka, zvinopesana nezvakaipa zvose, hezvino izvo zvakanaka uye zvinofadza, Shabbat Ahim zvose). Anobva aita imwe kufunga uye anoita musika wekutengesa kutora pane skeleton yeNRP.

    Zvese izvi hazvisi zvekukurudzira mweya mutsva wepfungwa mukududzirwa kweZionism yechitendero, asi kuzvisimudzira pachayo, uye nemubhadharo. Ichi ndicho chikonzero chekuiswa kwaEri Ohana, hukama neLapid uye zigzags pamberi, panguva uye mushure mesarudzo yekupedzisira. Zviri pachena kuti pane nzvimbo yeimwe utopian bato mumweya weMount Etzion Yeshiva uye kuruboshwe, asi Bennett ane kazhinji mhepo uye kurira.

    1. Zvinoshamisa kuti izvi ndizvo zvawauya nazvo nezve Bennett. Kana yatova American Pike yakavakirwa paBibi kutangazve. Akatoroora mudhara uye gare gare munhu anorwara nepfungwa. Uye zvakare akatengesa vakadzi vake vese, ndinofunga. Uye akaita mari yake nei? Kubva kuPike uye nezvimwe Pike uye mumwe rabhi akavanzika pane zvakazarurwa.
      Zvichitaurwa zviri nyore, Bennett akashanda nesimba hupenyu hwake hwese uye akaita zvese zvaanoziva kuita zvinogoneka. Uye chinhu chakanakisa chakabuda maari ndechekuti akakwanisa kuburitsa mutyairi wejuggling kubva mumboni yeziso raBibi zvishoma. Wekutanga kuve nehushingi nehunyanzvi. Nashoni.
      Hapana chikonzero chekufungidzira kukanganisa mukukurudzira, uye zvisina basa.

      1. Kutanga, "Asi Bibi" haisi mhinduro kune zvakaitwa naBennett. Bibi ane zvakawanda zvaanokanganisa, ndingafara kumuona achisiya basa rezvematongerwo enyika, kana nekuda kwezera rake rakanyanyisa. Chechipiri, zviito zvemunhu (zvemunhu wese) zvakanyanya kubuda kwekwake, dzidzo uye kunyange chitarisiko chekunze.

        Bibi, uyo mune zvakawanda zvinobudisa nhau akaberekwa ane teaspoon yendarama, kana kuti, mari mumuromo make, akanga asingafaniri kuratidza chinhu chipi nechipi kumunhu upi noupi. Basa rake, rinosanganisira kukwira nekudzika uye kutengesa kwevakadzi nevanovhota, rinotaridzika chaizvo. Kune rimwe divi, Bennett akanetseka kuti azviratidze iye neavo vakamupoteredza kuti Khurchik mupfupi aigona kunyoresa patrol, kuti mwanakomana wevatorwa vanobva munharaunda yeReform, anogona kuve mudiwa wevagari nevakuru vevatorwa. iyo NRP, zvichingodaro.

        Kana mutungamiri achifambiswa neNapoleon Syndrome, zvine njodzi pachayo.

        1. Mafungiro ekuzvidzikisira uye kutsveyamisa kune vanhu vakatanga kubva pakutanga uye vakazvivaka nemaoko avo.
          Bhibhi anotenderwa nekuti akasimudzwa kubva pavanhu. Hafu G-d. Asi mumwe wevanhu? Sei ndiani ane hushingi hwekubudirira nemari yedu? Iwe haugone.
          Hazvina kukodzera kutaurwa chero imwe nguva, dambudziko nderekuti hausiwe wega uri kuita chishamiso ichi kupokana nhasi.

  21. Pese paunoshandura dzidziso yako yekutenda kuita zvematongerwo enyika, inongoramba, nemisiyano inosungirwa, iyo yekupedzisira-Orthodox 'Torah maonero'. Vanhu vakangwara, vane kurongeka uye kwakakosha subtext (kunyangwe yako iri hunyanzvi uye yepakutanga) vanobata dzidziso dzavo pamusoro pezvaitika zvezvematongerwo enyika nekuda kwekusaziva uye kazhinji kusanzwisisa kwakadzama. Ini ndinoda izvi mukurumbidza, nekuti ivo uye iwe uri kuita zvinhu zvakanyanya kukosha kupfuura kumonyoroka uye kutendeuka kwezvematongerwo enyika uye kusemburwa kwese kunoitika ipapo, asi kuti pakupedzisira utaure pfungwa pasina kuzivana hazvina kukomba.

    Ane rombo rakanaka Naftali Bennett, semuenzaniso, paakaita madhiri anonhuwa naYair Lapid achipika akatsikitsira pasi mune zvese zvaidiwa kwaari pasi pemakrofoni nyowani nyowani, haana kunyatso kukurudzirwa nerondedzero dzese dzakanaka pano, asi zvakanyanya neasina kuvharirwa megalomania. , inova imba yababa yakanaka kune dzimwe dudziro dzese.

    Ruregerero, kuregerera chaiko nekuti ini ndiri mudiki pamberi pegoti renyu, kana muchinyora zvematongerwo enyika zvinongonyadzisa kune vari mubhizinesi. Chokwadi kudzima, asi zvaive zvakakosha kuti ndiburitse zvakadaro.

    1. Zvinoreva kuti uri "mubhizinesi", unogona here kutsanangura zvinorehwa?
      Kuvapo kwako munhau kunoreva here kuti unosevha nzvimbo dzenhau dzinogamuchirwa uye kumedza mashoko anoparadzirwa kubva kudivi rako semanyorerwo awo kana kuti unoratidzirwa kumashoko akavanzika uye anokosha ayo anongozivikanwa navashomanene chete vako?

    2. Zvinoshamisa kwandiri kuti munhu ari kuverenga mazwi angu anotya kuti ndichadzima iyi post. Nei ndichifanira kudzima? Uye kuti handitenderi pano kutsoropodzwa kwemashoko angu? Ndinoshora kunyomba uku uye kusina musoro.
      Sezvineiwo, handina kunyora chero kupi zvako kuti iyi yaive yekurudziro yaBennett (kunyangwe ndichifunga kudaro, kunyangwe nerima 'madhiri' aunotsanangura pano. Asi handisi kubata naBennett murume asi nemaitiro aanoratidza). Ndakati akabudirira nekuti akakunda manzwiro iwayo uye vazhinji vevavhoti vake vaitarisira kuti aite nenzira idzodzo. Zvinangwa zvaAdam Bennett hazvindifadzi, uye handina kubata nazvo. Sezvakataurwa, ini ndinoshandisa maitiro ezvematongerwo enyika seratidziro yemafungiro nemagariro.
      Kana iri rudzi rwekunyadziswa kwaunonzwa pakuverenga mamwe mazwi angu mune zvematongerwo enyika, saka ndakadzikama zvachose. Ndinofungidzira kune dzimwe nzvimbo zvakare hausi kunzwisisa zvauri kuverenga. Zvichida mumwe munhu ane ruzivo rwakanyanya mune zvematongerwo enyika ane nzwisiso isina kujeka uye anoshaya kunzwisisa kwekuverenga. Ichi chikamu chetsvina yawataura ipapo.
      Nemharidzo dzerumbidzo dzakadaro, hapana chikonzero chemharidzo dzinozvidza.

  22. Michi handifungi kuti kune vemazuva ano Orthodox avo mukuzivisa vanobvuma kuti mamwe maitiro avo anobva kune imwe seti yemitemo isiri Torah. Inobva pamunhu Sabra chete. Zvinoitika kuti isu tiri varanda ve * pfungwa dzedu * Ku * yedu * pfungwa.

    Kunyange avo vanoti dzimwe dzetsika dzemazuva ano hadzipokani neTorah. Vanoruramisa kuti vaiva nehwaro. Paiva nevechikadzi, kana kuti kana uchitozvipembedza, kunyange kana tsika dzechisikigo dzichifanira kurangarirwa.

    Kwete kuti ini pachangu ndinofunga kuti ibasa rekune dzimwe nyika kana kuti rinopesana nekuda kwaMwari kubatirira kune mamwe maitiro evanhu. Zvakare mumamiriro ezvinhu apo ivo vasingapesani neTorah. Uye ndiani pakati pedu asingaiti izvozvo? Manzwiro echisikigo kutanga uye mberi. pfungwa yokusungirwa.” Kunyange munhuwo zvake anomiririra vanhukadzi anoshamiswa nokubatwa chibharo, somuenzaniso.

    Asi mubvunzo ndewehuremu hwazvinoita kana munhu kwenguva yakareba achiedza kuita 100% yemazuva ano uye 100 muzana yeTorah achishandira zita.Uye ndinoziva kuti haisiriyo gwara rako.Munhu iyeye anozvisimbisa kuti hapana kupokana kana kukakavara.Kusanzwisisana.Muzhinji.Pachokwadi chinzvimbo chake

    Asi pfungwa yangu huru ndeyokuti handifungi kuti dzidziso yemazuva ano iripo kunyange kunze kwenyika yakawanda zvikuru.Uye dai isina kunyorwa mairi, vangadai vasina kuibata.” VanaRabhi veChiedza. Uye hazvisi neural kuti tinosiiwa nevazukuru vemweya kana vebiological

    1. Zvirokwazvo ane uye ane. Mubvunzo wekuti vangani kune mumwe mubvunzo. Uyezve, kunyange avo vasingazvibvumi ndezvokuti havazivi nezvechisarudzo chekubata maitiro maviri ekukosha panguva imwe chete, asi chaizvoizvo iyi ndiyo mamiriro avo chaiwo. Nekuda kwekuparidza kwakanyanya vanhu vazhinji avo mukuona kwangu vakabata chinzvimbo ichi havazvizivi kunyangwe mukati mavo. Ndinofunga kuti pane zvakawanda zvavo.
      Nenzira, kubata maviri seti yezvakakosha hakuna kufanana nekugovana kunze kwekunge imwe yadzo isina hukama naGd. Asi kana vari vaviri naye hapana chinonetsa. Ndakatsanangura izvi kakawanda, uye zvakare mune ino koramu pachayo. Kana ndichitaura nezve kubata hunhu kunze kweTorah hazvireve kukosha system kunze kweGd. Izvi zvinhu zviviri zvakasiyana zvachose.

  23. Zvakanyanya kunaka kusiyanisa pakati pechitendero chekuchengetedza uye chitendero chinoshanda
    Kune vazhinji vasingafarire conservatism uye kune rumwe rutivi vanobva kure nemazuva ano kana ichienda kure

    Muzvokwadi yehupenyu pano muIsrael, hapana nzvimbo yepati (kusimbisa sepati uye kwete yehupenyu hwepachivande) yemazuva ano semafungiro, nokuti zvakare kana iri ideological ipapo ichaenda kune imwe nzvimbo yakanyanyisa nemazuva ano. uye kuva nemishnah yakarongeka inonzi 'chitendero'.

    Kunyanya, pane nzvimbo yehufungidziro hushoma uye hune hungwaru uye hunoshanda humiriri pamberi penyika maererano neRega ndivake uye ndive akachenjera.
    Patafura pane mizhinji uye mizhinji yemibvunzo isina kugadziriswa iyo yemazuva ano haina chekupindura kana kuti inopindura mhinduro dzisina musoro uye inopa kosher muzita rechitendero kune ese marudzi ezviitiko muchidimbu midzi dambudziko reConservatism uye ideological modernity inobva kunzvimbo imwe chete.

    Kune rumwe rutivi, rudzidziso runoshanda runoziva nzira yokusiyanisa pakati pechinodikanwa nechinowanikwa
    Zvamazvirokwazvo, rakanga riri basa revakuru venharaunda muchizvarwa choga choga kuzvibata ivo vamene netsika nedzidziso.

    Kuedza kupa muenzaniso wekusiyanisa pakati pekunamata kunoshanda uye chitendero chemazuva ano
    Ngatitii tafura yese yekabhineti izano rekudzidzisa 'tsika dzemhuri' zvinoenderana nekuona kwepasirese kunofambira mberi.
    Saka vechitendero chemazuva ano vanoedza kuzvipa kosher nekuda kwekugamuchira zvakasiyana uye zvisinganzwisisike uye nezvimwe zvisina maturo.
    Vechitendero vanoomerera pakunamata vacharwa hondo inorwadza nayo
    Uye iyo inoshanda yechitendero inoregeredza iyo inopomerwa uye yepfungwa nyaya uye ichaedza kuderedza kukuvadzwa maererano nechiyero chechirongwa uye ruzivo rwayo.
    (Ivo ultra-Orthodox neimwe nzira vese vanochengetedza uye vanoita zvechitendero sezviri mumutemo wekutora vanhu vanopikisa pasi pemuti mutsva uye nerumwe rutivi vanotumira vamiriri vavo kumakomiti kuyedza kuderedza kukuvadzwa)

    1. Muenzaniso wawapa unoratidza kuti mutsauko wako hauna chinhu, kana kuti uri kurwisa murume weshanga. Orthodox yemazuva ano haingotore chero kukosha kwemazuva ano. Anongozvibvumira kuita kudaro, kana ukoshi huchiita sekwakanaka uye kwakakodzera kwaari. Uyo anongombundikira zvese zvakamukomberedza anongoita dofo.
      Tsanangudzo yeyako yekupedzisira-Orthodox inofanirawo kukurukurwa, uye hapana nzvimbo yayo pano. Ichokwadi kuti ivo vane pragmatic, asi iyi haisi maonero akasiyana asi nzira yekuzvibata. Ndiri kutaura pano pamusoro pemafungiro kwete nezvemaitiro.

  24. Rugare,

    Ndinovimba kuti hazvina kunonoka kupindura (paive nefamily kufarira kwakandibata).

    Kutanga ndinofanira kunongedza kune koramu yandakambonyora nezve iyi pfungwa yako,

    https://www.kipa.co.il/%D7%97%D7%93%D7%A9%D7%95%D7%AA/%D7%93%D7%A2%D7%95%D7%AA/%D7%94%D7%93%D7%A8%D7%9A-%D7%9C%D7%94%D7%99%D7%A4%D7%98%D7%A8-%D7%9E%D7%94%D7%A8-%D7%94%D7%9E%D7%95%D7%A8/

    Saka, makore masere apfuura, aka kaive kekutanga kusangana nenharo idzi uye zvakandishatirisa. Asi nhasi ini ndinonyatsofunga kuti wakarurama uye mutsara wekukanganisa ndizvo chaizvo zvaunotsanangura. Padanho rinoshanda nyaya idzi dzakanyanya kukosha uye zvine chekuita nehupenyu.

    Asi padanho regothic-ideological ndinofunga kuti mudzi uchiri muchikamu chekirasi.

    Muchiitiko chekupedzisira-Orthodox, hapana chakakosha chakachinja kubva pakudzokera kuIsrael. Nzira imwechete yehupenyu hwekutapwa.

    Mukuona kwaRabbi Kook, kudzokera kuIsraeri kudzoka kumazuva eBhaibheri, ishuviro yekubatanidza halakhah neaggadah uye nokudaro kuchinja nyika yose yeHalakhah kubva kumagumo kusvika kumagumo (Rabbi Shagar akati iyi ndiyo Rabbi Kook inonyanya kukoshesa. innovation). Ishuviro yekuona mune zvese zvenhoroondo-huzivi-tsika maitiro, chikamu cheyakakwana uye yakazara nhoroondo nzira yekuvaka vanhu veIsraeri, sekutsanangurwa kwaRabbi Kook mukufamba kwemazano.

    Ichokwadi kuti mufungo unoshanda waRabbi Kook kucherechedzwa kwenyika yenyika uye naizvozvo vanhu veMizrahi vakanamatira kwairi uye nokudaro vakapesvedzerwa navasiri vechitendero, naizvozvo Rabhi Tao akaita kutendeuka ndokuedza kumisazve chinhu chiri chose. Asi Rabbi Tao achiri akatendeseka zvachose kumaonero aRabbi Kook.

    Maererano nemaonero aya tine basa renhoroondo rekuita mukuvaka humambo hwevaprista. Usatarise paD. Amot yeHalacha. Izvi zvinoreva kuti T.H. iri kuvakwa kufambisira mberi rudzi mune zvechitendero uye kana izvozvo zvaitika zvinokwanisika kudzokera kuTemberi, kuporofita, kunyora halakhah uye ngano, zvichingodaro. Ichi ndicho chiono chaRabbi Kook.

    Chinokosha chekuvandudzwa kwaRabbi Kook chiri munyika yeKabbalah, iyo Rabbi Kook yakavandudzwa inofananidzwa nezvinyorwa zveAryan maererano neizvo zvinoreva kurongeka kwedzinza iri mukuona kwekusika kwevanhu chikamu chemaitiro aMwari uye naizvozvo Rabbi Kook akabata. nehuzivi uye dzidzo kubva kuKabbalistic mazano. Mune izvi, Rabbi Kook akasiyana neGa'a uye Ramchal, umo nyika ye-ultra-Orthodox iri kutevera mumakwara avo, avo vakaona mufananidzo muhutungamiri hwaMwari munyika uye kwete mukusikwa kwevanhu.

    Ichokwadi kuti iye zvino ari Ultra-Orthodox, kunyange yakavharwa kupfuura Ultra-Orthodox, asi iyi inguva yenguva. Maitiro ake ese, emasitadhi, aive uye anoramba ari maitiro aRabbi Kook.

    Avo vakaturikwa pamaonero echitendero chenyika kuti vape kosher kune tsika dzekuMadokero saka iwe wakarurama kwazvo, kuti masardard haana kusiyana neiyo Ultra-Orthodox uye nekudaro inoda ruzhinji rwechitendero chenyika kuti vabatane uye vakure hutungamiriri hune chivimbo mukati mawo uye neayo. nzira, asi ndiani anonzwisisa kuti chinangwa chese chekumisikidza nyika Nharo yedu neyekupedzisira-Orthodox yakamirira kuti ibve kudenga, uye kosher yejecha renyika ndicho chinhu chinoshanda asi kwete moyo wekupokana, saka akanyanya. kufadzwa nemamiriro ezvinhu uye vakangomirira kuti tisvike padanho iri vanonamata vachaisa mukati kuti nyika inovakwa Imwe munzira yake.

    1. Dzidziso dzaRabbi Kook dzakasiyana zvechokwadi, uye kufarira kwavo ndekweZionism, uye izvi zvinogonawo kuva nezvazvinoreva kune maonero echitendero (imwe yemazuva ano). Izvi hazvina basa nhasi, saka iindasitiri yeultra-Orthodox. Vangave vakamirira zvakakodzera kuti Mesiya aone mumwe muenzaniso, saka pangava nemusiyano mune ramangwana remapoka maviri aya. Munyaya yedu inoshanda hapana musiyano pakati pavo. Ini ndinofungidzira iwe uchawanawo ekupedzisira-Orthodox anokuudza kuti kunetseka kwavo kunoshanda uye utopia yavo inosanganisirawo mamwe sainzi nehunhu. Chero bedzi isina kubata kunoshanda kwatiri vanogona kuve vakavhurika uye vakasununguka, asi havasati vakwanisa Dera. Ichi chinyorwa chemazuva ano cheultra-Orthodox.
      Kupfuura izvozvo, kuvhiyiwa kwako kwakafanana nekwangu uye ndinobvumirana nazvo zvachose (nemhedziso yakasiyana hongu).

      1. Zvirokwazvo, handina chokwadi kuti iyi ndiyo halakhah yaMesiasi. Temberi chikamu chakakosha chechiratidzo chepasirese icho Rabbi Zacks akataura nezvazvo uye inotaurwa nezvayo naRabbi Shreki, uye shanduko yemhando yekudzidza zvakare chikamu chakakosha chayo. Nguva yemberi, Mesiya, yatova pedyo zvakakwana

  25. Chinyorwa chaMichi muenzaniso chaiwo wokusavimbika kwoungwaru.
    Michi anotaura pamusoro pekuti kunyanya ma-ultra-Orthodox nemasitadhi aipesana naBennett.

    Michi anokokwa kuti averenge nezve kuratidzira kukuru "mukuda kupona kwehurumende" mumazuva asati aitwa sarudzo yekupedzisira yaBennett.
    Kune ruzivo rwevaverengi - vanhu vanenge 2,000 XNUMX (mazana akawanda) vakauya kukuratidzira muhurumende.

    Vese vasiri Haredi kana mustard vanonamata kupi?
    Sei vasina kuenda kumigwagwa mumakumi / mazana ezviuru?

    Vhura munyori wenyaya kuti azviongorore asati aburitsa zvisina maturo zvakadaro.

    1. Rabhi wedu Shlita ari right. Uyo anozvidza muponesi wedu muBennett Yeracha - isardadi zvishoma mumoyo make, kunyange kana kuonekwa kwake kwakasiyana. Chiratidzo chekutaura nezvaNir Orbach naIdit Silman, avo vakatobata kushushikana mukati memukati mavo.

      Uye zvakapesana, vanhu vane dome rakakura, machira kunze uye ndebvu refu, vanotsigira Bennett havana kutapukirwa nemasitadhi, vachiongorora 'chizvarwa chaMesia, Dayahu Bish Malbar naTev Malgao' 🙂

      Kuremekedza, Gilad Chaya Gavriyahu-Grushinsky

      1. Pakati pe'vanokoshesa vanarabhi' uye kusimbisa kwete

        Mune SD XNUMX muTammuz P.B.

        Kunyangwe avo vasingagaye cod zvakanyanya, uye kunyangwe avo vanozvitsanangura se 'venyika' - pane mamiriro ane hukama hwakanaka hweTorah nevachenjeri vayo, vanokoshesa Rabbanan naRachim Rabbanan.

        Akanga ari murume wechitendero akasiya musha wechiJudha nokuda kwo‘kudzora kwavanarabhi’, uye akanga ari shamwari yake ‘yenyika’ uyo, kunyange zvazvo akamanikidzwa kusiya basa nomumwe wake mukuru, akarumbidza zano rokuchenjera ravarabhi naro. waaida kubvunza.

        Zvinoita sekuti kuenda pamudyandigere kwaBennett - kunodzosera 'kodzero' kune veruzhinji vanotendeukira nerudo kurudyi, kutsika uye kuvaRabhi. Matan Kahana nevamwe vake - vachazviwana ivo saElazar Stern Nakinli Turpez, nhengo dze "Trustees of Torah neBasa" avo hondo ye "kunyanyisa kwechitendero" inotangira mapapiro avo ekurudyi - vachawana nzvimbo yavo mu "Yesh Atid" nezvimwe zvakadaro. , nepo vadi veTorah vachizozviwana zvakare mu "kurudyi" Kuti uwedzere kubatana neruzhinji rweTorah.

        Nemwoyo wose, Galgagi

  26. Shatzal, Matan Kahana anoda Torah kwete pasi pevanoda Torah yauri kutaura nezvayo. Haana kurwisa kunyanyisa mune zvechitendero. Anorwisa huwori hwechitendero, uye hapana chaachaita zvinopesana neHalakhah. Munhu wechitendero, akatendeseka, anongwarira sevamwe vakawanda, uye vavariro dzake dziri nokuda kwedenga.
    Ndakaverengawo zvinhu zvawakanyora munguva yakapfuura zvichipesana neshanduko yekosher. Ndokumbira utarise kuti vanoita sarudzo muRabhi nhasi maererano nenyaya dzekosher havasi vanarabhi, asi vakuru vakuru. Zvisinei neizvi, sarudzo dzavo ndedzekupedzisira maererano nezvinhu zvakakosha mukukoshera kwayo uye maitiro. Sarudzo dzisiri halakhic uye nyaya-ye-chokwadi, uye dzinokonzera kukuvadza kwakati. Zvese zviri zviviri zvekosher uye yako yakavanzika homwe.
    Kunyange kana pane kukundikana kwekugadzirisa kusati kwagadziriswa, kunobva kune imwe nzvimbo yakanaka inoda kugadzirisa matambudziko akaoma aripo nhasi.
    Munzvimbo zhinji pasi rose hakuna 'Mukuru weRabhi', asi zvakadaro maJuda anofarira kudya kosher, vanodya zvakabikwa zvakanakisa. Hapana sangano ravarabhi ndiyo vimbiso yekupedzisira yemhando yechikafu chekosher.

    1. Saka nzvimbo yake muYesh Atid

      Zvechokwadi Matan Kahana anoda Torah, nokuti ndicho chikonzero akatambudza 'kuiponesa' kubva kuvarabhi, uye naizvozvo achava nenzvimbo yekuremekedza muGaza mubato chete iro mutungamiri wake akanyora bhuku remimhanzi pazvikamu zveTorah, iyo ' Pane ramangwana' 🙂

      Nekudaro, ndakataura nezva'Mukir Rabbanan', nezveavo vanofarira kuteerera kune vaRabhi uye vanonakidzwa nezano ravo uye kugona kwavo kunyangwe vasingabvumirani navo zvachose, uye kusiyana neavo vaiona vanarabhi se'mutoro uye nekudaro vakabviswa. iyo 'Jewish House'. Uye zvakasiyana neavo vaifunga kuraira kuvaRabhi veIsrael maitiro uye mitemo kosher uye kutendeuka.

      Pamusoro pekugadzirisa kwehutsotsi hwekashrut iyo Kahana yakaedza kurayira, maererano neayo mutongi wekupedzisira munyaya dzekashrut achava mukuru akagadzwa neGurukota reZvitendero kuti anzi 'Kashrut Commissioner muMukuru Rabbinate' kutsausa vatengi, uye kuzarura kudzidziswa kumasangano ane zvishuwo zvebhizinesi. - Ndakawedzera muchikamu 427 pakushambadzira kwechikafu chekosher, nezvimwe.

      Kutevera nhaurirano ipapo, ndakapa zano kuna Chief Rabbi weIsrael, Rabbi David Lau, chirevo chakagamuchirwa: kuvandudza mwero wekashrut yemakanzuru ezvitendero nekumisa matare edunhu kashrut ayo anotungamira uye kutungamira madhipatimendi eko kashrut uye nekudaro kuwedzera nhanho yehunyanzvi yekashrut, uye kuwedzera kuvimba neruzhinji. Rabbi Lau akaendesa chikumbiro changu kuGurukota rezveChitendero, uye sezvaitarisirwa, 'Kahana Station haipindure' 🙂

      Chasara kutarisira kuti musarudzo yechishanu Ba'alat ichahwina 'Minister weChitendero' panzvimbo pe'Minister of Religious Duties' 🙂

      Kuremekedza, Gilad Chaya Gavriyahu-Grushinsky

  27. "Asi ingori nyika yandinoda kugara mairi uye ndine kodzero yekudaro."
    Ndiri kurasikirwa nepoindi mukudzidzisa kwako, pamwe wakanyora nezvazvo kumwe kunhu? Pane here, mukuona kwako, hapana halakhic chisungo chekugara munyika?

    1. A. Kwete munyika asi muNyika yeIsrael. Uye kunyange ikoko haizi hazvo mitzvah asi kosher mitzvah (nokuti pano chete ndipo panokwanisika kuchengeta mitzvos inoenderana nenyika).
      B. Ndinofunga kuti ndakanga ndakarurama uye ndakanyora kuti kunyange ndisina kukosha kwechitendero ndine kodzero yekugara munyika yandinoda. Izvi hazvireve kuti hapana kukosha asi kuti hazvina kufanira kumisikidza tsigiro yedu yehurumende neZionism.

    1. A. Zvinoenderana nekukakavadzana pakati peRambam naRambam.
      B. Mubvunzo wacho handina kuunzwisisa. Zionism isangano rinovavarira kuumba nyika yechiJudha yemaJuda muNyika yeIsrael. Usandibvunza kuti tsananguro yechiJudha ndeipi mune ino mamiriro. hapana.

  28. Handinzwisise kuti ndeipi budiriro yaBennett yauri kutaura nezvayo. Murume uyu haana kupfuudza chikamu chekuvharisa, akabva angopfuura nechishamiso chete nekuda kwekorona uye kushambadzira-demagogic kugona kwake kuisimudzira. Iyo yakajairwa dhinomineta yevatsigiri vake yandakasvika kuziva haisi yeOrthodoxy yemazuva ano asi kusadzika kwehungwaru uye kufarira masirogani uye clichés kubva kune zvese zviri pedyo ..

  29. Iwe unoparadzanisa zvakanyanya pakati pe "Zionism" uye "mazuva ano". Iko kugamuchirwa kweZionism, kunyange nevatungamiri vezvokunamata veZionism yechitendero vakadai saRabbi Kook, yakabva kune zvemazuva ano uye kuiswa kwemukati kwekukosha kwechirudzi kunze kweTorah, uye kwakabatana nekugamuchirwa kwemamwe maitiro emazuva ano. Chinangwa cheZionism, kusanganisira chechitendero, ndechekuvandudza vanhu veIsrael (kuregeredza "kutapwa" = maonero asiri emazuva ano eVanhu veIsrael). Ichokwadi kuti nekufamba kwemakore, uye nekutsveneswa kwehurumende nezviratidzo zvayo, kwave kune nyonganiso, asi chitendero cheZionism chinongova shanduro yechitendero chemazuva ano.
    Munyori haasi muZionist, uye haasi wemazuva ano.

    1. Hatina kumbonzwa munyika yanhasi nezvekudzokera kunyika yekare mushure mezviuru zvemakore (LHB)

      BSD XNUMX muTammuz P.B.

      Melody - Rugare ngaruve kwauri,

      Pfungwa yokuti rudzi rwakadzokera kunyika yarwo yekare mushure mezviuru zvemakore ekutapwa - haipo munyika yanhasi. Kwakave nekumutswa kwevanhu vaive muuranda kuti vawane rusununguko rwezvematongerwo enyika, asi kuti vadzokere kunyika iri kure mushure mezviuru zvemakore - iyi ipfungwa isina yakaenzana, uye tsime rayo chete iTorah inovimbisa 'Uye Jehovha achadzoka uye achatsvenesa. kutapwa kwako uye kudzoka uye kukuunganidza kubva kumarudzi ose. Tariro yaipindirana nevaporofita, yakaverengwa muminamato yakagadzirwa nevarume veKahasath mukuru umo chido cheZion chakatora nzvimbo yepakati, uye vakatora nzvimbo yepakati mumashoko eVachenjeri nevachenjeri vekare.

      Zvamazvirokwazvo, kutamira kuIsraeri zvikurukuru kwakanga kuri pfuma yavanhu vakakurira mutsika. Vatami veariyah vekutanga vaive vazhinji vevaJudha vechitendero, uyezve vatami vechipiri aliyah, vamwe vavo vakabvisa joko reTorah nemitzvot - vazhinji vaibva kuEastern Europe uko vakakurira pachitendero chipenyu uye chine simba. tsika. Vakakurira pa'Vani babai mapadan' nemudzidzisi Haider, pakururamiswa kwababa pakati pehusiku uye mapeni akadonhedzwa naamai mubhokisi raRabbi Meir Baal Hans vasati vatungidza makenduru. Saka pfungwa yokudzokera kuIsraeri yakanga yatova mundangariro dzavo.

      Izvi zvinoreva: pfungwa yekudzokera kune imwe nyika yekare uye kure kure haisi yemazuva ano. Kubva kumazuva ano vakatora midziyo yekuurayisa.

      Zvakanakisa, Amiauz Yaron Schnitzer.

      1. Uye vamwe vakauya kuZionism nekuda kwekuora mwoyo nemazuva ano

        Uye kune vazhinji, vakaita saMoses Hess, Pinsker, Smolenskin naHerzl, vakauya kuZionism kubva mukuora mwoyo kwavo nemazuva ano. Vaifunga kuti mhinduro yedambudziko rekuvengwa kwemaJuda nekutambudzwa kwavo yaizogadziriswa kana mweya weChiedza wakakunda Europe. Nyika yakavhenekerwa ichatanga kugamuchira maJuda apo vanorega kuva vakasiyana, kuwana dzidzo yeEurope nemararamiro, uye ipapo vaEurope vakavhenekerwa vachavagamuchira nemaoko maviri.

        Kukushamiswa kwavo, Europe 'yakavhenekerwa' yakaramba ichivenga maJuda. Kusiyana neizvi, kubatanidzwa kwavo muhupenyu hwetsika, hupfumi uye sainzi - kwakaonekwa mukutambudzwa kweVemamwe Marudzi se'kuedza kwemaJuda kutora nyika', uye patakaedza zvakanyanya kuve veEurope uye nemazuva ano - zvakanyanya anti. -Semitism yakakura.

        Uye saka vaJudha vakadzidza vakasvika pakuziva kuti tinofanira kumisa nyika yechiJudha umo taizonyanya ‘kuvhenekerwa’ uye kuva ‘chiedza kuvaHedheni’ mukuvhenekerwa kwedu, uye tichifunga kuti nyika yokuMadokero yakanga isati yagadzirira kugamuchira. ivo semunhu mumwe nemumwe - vaizovagamuchira serudzi rwakazvimiririra.Pfungwa iri kuramba ichiwedzera kurasika. Kunyange sorudzi havasati vachizotida, zvisinei nokuti tingave takavhenekerwa sei uye tine tsika.

        Zvisinei, avo vakatamira kuIsraeri mumapoka vakanga vari chaizvoizvo vaJudha vokuMabvazuva kweEurope nenyika dzokuMabvazuva, uko kubatana kwavo neNyika yaIsraeri kwaizocheneswa pagamuchidzanwa. Vakauya vakawanda kunyika yemadzitateguru avo uye vakabudirira munyika yayo nokuzvipira uye norudo.

        Regards, Chaiye akatumira maruva

    2. Ndotanga ndichiti handina basa nazvo kuti munyori ndiani. Zvichemo zvinofanirwa kutariswa kwete vamhan'ari.
      Ndinopatsanura pfungwa idzi pachena nekuti dzakazvimiririra. Ichokwadi kuti panogona kuve nemagariro epfungwa mhedzisiro yeChitubu cheMarudzi pakuziva kukosha kweTorah yekumisikidza nyika, asi kufunga kunoshandiswa mukutaura ndiko kufunga kwechitendero. Tese tine izvi nezvimwe zvinofurira, asi chakakosha zvikonzero zvedu uye kwete kufurira kwakazvisika. VaZioni vechitendero havatsananguri kuti kune kukosha kwemazuva ano kwehuchangamire uye naizvozvo munhu anofanira kunge ari Zionist, uye izvi hazvisi izvo zvavanotaura kune avo vasiri Zionist. Ndicho chikonzero chiri chiZionism chechitendero uye kwete dzidziso dzemazuva ano.

      1. Asi Zionism haisi kungotamira kuIsrael kana chishuvo chehuchangamire, asi chirongwa chese che "rumutsiriro" nevanhu veIsraeri, kumashure uko kumire kufunga kwemazuva ano par kunaka, zvakare uye kunyanya naRabbi Kook, uyo ari mufungi wemazuva ano. nzira dzose. Kunyange nanhasi muzvikamu zve-ultra-Orthodox mitsara yakaita se "Torat Eretz Yisrael" inowanzova mazita emakodhi emhando dzemazuva ano dzeTorah kudzidza nekuverenga.

        Mumwe wechitendero-Zionist ndiye anogovera chirongwa chemazuva ano cheZionism, uye chaizvoizvo ari wechitendero-Israel nenzira imwechete iyo yemazuva ano-Orthodox ndeyechitendero-America (kana mumaonero akazara, yechitendero-Western). Mumaziso angu, kuoma kwechisikigo chete kwekubata migumo miviri (yechitendero neyemazuva ano) yakagadzira mutsauko pakati pemafungiro.

        Chirevo chako "Tese tine maitiro akadaro uye akadai, asi chakakosha zvikonzero zvedu uye kwete maitiro akazvisika" sezviri pachena anopesana neimwe yepfungwa huru yechinyorwa, umo munonyomba avo vanopa zvikonzero zvechitendero zvenhema uye vanomanikidzwa. muzvinzvimbo izvo chaizvo zvinomira kumashure kwavo ndezvemazuva ano.

        1. Iyi psychoanalytic analysis uye haina basa mumaziso angu kunyange ichokwadi. Kunyanya iwe unoti ivo vese vemazuva ano maOrthodox uye kwete vechitendero-vanoshora. OK. Ndiri kutaura nezvezvigaro kwete vanhu. Kupfuura izvozvo, ini ndatotsanangura maonero angu pamusoro pezvikonzero uye mhedzisiro yepfungwa. Hadzinakidze uye hadzina hukama nehurukuro. Ndiri kutarisana nemakakatanwa ayo vanhu vanoisa pamberi uye kwete ne psychoanalytic ongororo yezviri shure kwayo.

        2. 'Torah yaIsraeri' inopesana (rwiyo)

          BSD XNUMX muTammuz PB

          Chokwadi kune maitiro anoenderana neshanduko uye maonero ekuchengetedza, maererano nezvatinobvuma maonero echizvino-zvino kana echizvino-zvino se 'Torah kubva kuSinai', uye Torah inofanira 'kugadziridzwa' kune yazvino maitiro.

          Iyi haisi Torah AI yaRabbi Kook. Anoona kuti 'ism' yese inovandudzwa ine 'pfungwa yechokwadi' chaiyo, asi inosanganiswa neakaipa slag. Torah, kana ichidzidzwa zvakadzama uye nehupamhi - inotibvumira 'kuparadzanisa' zvakanaka kubva kune zvakaipa, uye naizvozvo kuwana zvakanaka kubva kune imwe neimwe nhovo inogona kudzorerwa uye kurasa tsvina.

          Uye vanhu ve'Torah neDerech Eretz' vakaratidza kuti zvinogoneka kuve musayendisiti wedanho rekutanga pasina kusiya 'comma' kubva muTorah nekuremekedza Mwari. Uye saka chitendero cheZionism chinoedza kuratidza kuti zvinokwanisika kuita zvinhu zvikuru mukuvaka kwehurumende nekusimudzirwa kwayo, uchive wakatendeka kune mirairo yeTorah.

          Torat Ai iTorah yakazara inotenderedza nzvimbo dzese dzeTorah - Talmud neHalacha, Hasidic kufunga, kuburitsa uye kuvanza - saka inokwanisa kubata nemafungu ese ehupenyu hutsva uye kuvapa yakakwana halachic uye yehungwaru mhinduro.

          Regards, Chaiye akatumira maruva

              1. Ndakaratidza kuti Zionism inyaya yakakosha, kana shanduro yeIsrael, yemazuva ano. Padanho renzvimbo uye kwete pamwero wepfungwa yepfungwa (?!). Izvi zvinoenderana zvakananga nekupokana kwako muchinyorwa. Uye hazvisi pachena kwandiri kuti ndeupi rudzi rwe psychoanalysis (?!?!) yawakawana mumashoko angu.

                Pamusoro pezvo, uye sechinyorwa cheparutivi, ndakapokana kuti muchinyorwa chako iwe unongotaura zvakajeka kwete chete kune yakataurwa chinzvimbo asiwo kune vavariro (kwete iyo psychoanalytical imwe - hapana kubatana - asi iyo yepfungwa). Asi iyi ingori tsinhiro nekuti mazwi angu ainyatsotaura nezvechinzvimbo chakataurwa.

                1. Tinongotenderera isu. Kana nhasi kune munhu ane nharo pamusoro pe-ultra-Orthodox ndeyokuti haaenderani nemitemo yemazuva ano (nyika, hutongi uye democracy, nezvimwewo), saka iye zvechokwadi muOrthodox yemazuva ano (uye ndakati vazhinji vezvitendero- MaZionist ndeazvino. Nharo yangu haisi yechitendero-Zionists asi nezvepfungwa yechitendero-Zionism). Asi kana achitaura muzita remitzvah yeshuv pasina vimbiso yemumwe nomumwe, nezvimwewo, saka haasi iyezvino. ndizvo. Zvino zvisarudzire wega kuti ndeupi pavanhu ava uye kuti ndeupi. handisi kunzwisisa zviri kutaurwa pano.
                  Ndichawedzera kuti sezvandinorangarira handirevi vavariro asi kuzvikonzero. Dzimwe nguva ndinotaura kuti iwe unoona vavariro kuburikidza nekufunga (kunyanya kana nharo dzisingabatanidzi mvura). Handishore vanhu uye handisi kuvafarira nekuda kwezvinangwa zvavo.
                  Sezvataurwa, zvinoratidzika kwandiri kuti tiri kuzvidzokorora.

  30. Handizivi kuti Orthodox yemazuva ano yauri kutaura nezvayo ndiyani?
    Varabhi vakanyanya kukosha veYU ndiHardelim (maererano netsanangudzo yako). Vazhinji vemazuva ano (vanobatanidza munharaunda) vane ultra-orthodox (= inochengetedza) kana layites.
    Semunhu aimbove chutnik, ndinoziva vanarabhi vashoma vakadai uye handizivi Yeshiva 'yemazuva ano' kuEurope.
    (Uye vakasununguka vakadai seYCT vakapfuurira zvikuru kupfuura muno muIsraeri. Kunyange zvazvo vakagadzawo pachivande vazhinji muIsraeri, nezvimwewo.)

  31. Mhoro, Rabbi Michi, maererano nezvamunotaura kuti kune ruzhinji rwevanhu muIsrael rwune rusununguko mune zvechitendero, ichi ichokwadi, asi ndinofunga kuti veruzhinji havafarire pfungwa yese yechitendero yakasununguka yaunomiririra. Iye akasununguka kwete nekuti anofunga kuti iyi ndiyo nzira yakakodzera yekuzvibata kubva kune halachic maonero uye anoedza kuimisa mumhando dzese dzekuverenga halachic, asi ane rusununguko nekuti ndiwo makuriro aakakura uye ndomabatiro aakaita. Chitendero chine zvakawanda, hachifadzi kwaari uye chiri chikamu chepakati chehupenyu hwake uye haanetsiswi nemibvunzo ipi neipi yehalachic kuitira kuti veruzhinji kuti Rabhi Vataure kwaari uyo ari zvese zvakasununguka uye akasununguka. chitendero chechokwadi chakashomeka uye Bennett anozomumiririra (fungidziro yangu ndeyekuti iyi veruzhinji inomiririra 6 mandates ini handifunge kupfuura izvozvo)

Siya mhinduro