New on the site: Michi-bot. An intelligent assistant based on the writings of Rabbi Michael Avraham.

Especially compared to Benin Ab

שו”תCategory: Talmudic studyEspecially compared to Benin Ab
asked 11 months ago

Is there a difference between a simple matter and a fundamental building, because any KV can seemingly work as a fundamental building, and just as one decomposes a fundamental building into a stage… one also decomposes a simple matter.

Leave a Reply

0 Answers
מיכי Staff answered 11 months ago

I didn’t understand. So what if you interpret it as similar, why does that mean the argument is similar?

רש replied 11 months ago

My point is whether the argument is necessary, let alone the place where it is used, or is it really sufficient in the ab construction. After all, let alone the ab construction says that if law x belongs in a, in b, which is an easier situation (according to the law in question), it is clear that it also belongs there. In the ab construction, we see that we do not need to find a serious side to say that a law belongs in another place, but rather it is enough to say that if a has law x, and b is equal to it, then that law will belong to it.

מיכי Staff replied 11 months ago

It is clear that it is a similar verb. But when there is a קוה, it is stronger because there is a hierarchy (I wrote in the past that a קוה is a type of parent building, unlike those who believed that it was a deduction, like Adolf Schwartz). See the issue of Chulin Keto Eb – Ketez Eb אב regarding differences in the פרכות קול דהו.

Leave a Reply

Back to top button