חדש באתר: NotebookLM עם כל תכני הרב מיכאל אברהם

Q&A: The Rabbi’s Views on Maimonides

Back to list  |  🌐 עברית  |  ℹ About
Originally published:
This is an English translation (via GPT-5.4). Read the original Hebrew version.

The Rabbi’s Views on Maimonides

Question

Hello Rabbi,
 
Many times it seems that your views are not on the same wavelength as those of Maimonides.
 
From looking at Micah Goodman’s book, The Secrets of the Guide for the Perplexed, which lays out Maimonides’ theological worldview clearly, it seems that the outlooks are very similar on prophecy, the Messiah, God, and so on.
 
Is the Rabbi familiar with the book?

Answer

Not really. In any case, I’m not especially bothered by the question of whether my views match those of any particular person, however important he may be.

Discussion on Answer

Israel (2018-07-23)

Goodman’s book really does not lay out Maimonides’ theological worldview; rather, it twists and distorts his views in a disgraceful way, and one should not rely on even half a word written there.

Michi (2018-07-23)

I’m not impressed by his interpretations either (to the extent that I know them). But I don’t think one should rely on books and interpretations. You can read and see what is convincing and what is not.

Israel (2018-08-19)

Suppose someone were to publish a book called “The Thought of Rabbi Michael Abraham” and in it he wrote things you never said, never wrote, and that never even crossed your mind.
And not only that, but he would attribute to you utter nonsense and empty absurdities that no reasonable person could accept.
And not only that, but the very views that you sharply argue against in your books he would describe as your own doctrine.
I imagine he would earn a particularly sharp rebuke from you.
And if that happened after a long life, I assume you would be glad that someone would do that in your place.
And you wouldn’t say, “I don’t think one should rely on books and interpretations. You can read and see what is convincing and what is not,” because you know that very many people will not go check in your books whether what was written in your name is true or not. Because that is the way of most people, to believe things like that. And therefore it is definitely very important to say about such books that one should not rely at all on what is written in them, so that the reader knows what is in front of him.

Michi (2018-08-19)

Either I didn’t understand, or you didn’t. Maimonides is right there before us, and therefore it doesn’t matter what Goodman writes about him, and there is no reason to form an opinion about Goodman the person. One should examine his arguments. That’s all.

Leave a Reply

Back to top button