Q&A: Tradition Regarding Locusts
Tradition Regarding Locusts
Question
What is the Rabbi’s opinion on this issue? Is tradition enough? Can I rely on the tradition of my friend? Why shouldn’t they teach the tradition to all the Jewish people so everyone can eat locusts and be satisfied? After all, the tradition started somehow and then stopped. So let them restore it.
Answer
I do not understand the status that tradition is given in these matters. Tradition has status on the level of clarification. If there is a reliable tradition, then that is an indication that the interpretation or identification in question is correct (that is, that this is probably what was originally intended). But from the period of the medieval authorities (Rishonim), an approach began that sees tradition as something constitutive (without a tradition it is forbidden to eat, and the tradition permits it). Regarding kosher animals this is very central, but it also comes up with respect to tekhelet (Rabbi Joseph Dov Soloveitchik), and all of this, in my view, is completely baseless. If this tradition is considered reliable by Moroccan Jews, then Ashkenazi Jews can also rely on it, and vice versa. And if it is not reliable, then Moroccans may not rely on it either.
Discussion on Answer
Maybe.
Thank you. Blessed be God that I had the right intuition!
Rabbi, is this worth a column? It also connects, in my opinion, to the meaning of the term “authority.” There too, there is confusion between clarification and normativity.