Q&A: On style, not substance – Nofekh Sapir Yahalom column (Column #2)
On style, not substance – Nofekh Sapir Yahalom column (Column #2)
Question
With Heaven’s help,
Honorable Rabbi,
I apologize for taking up the Rabbi’s time with such trivialities, but I would be glad to know why a respectable site like the Rabbi’s uses the Arial font.
I’ll go so far as to say that it is in the category of “a Torah scholar with a stain on his garment” — that is, seemingly an external matter, but one that could symbolize something problematic.
Thank you, and sorry for the silly side of this question.
Answer
You’re forgiven.
Discussion on Answer
Could someone explain what this is about?
Haim,
What didn’t you understand? Someone complained that the site uses the Arial font (the font used on almost every website), which in his opinion is apparently not nice-looking or respectable enough.
To increase the astonishment, he apparently thought that at the root of this wonderful criticism there were some lofty secrets.
I thought the questioner meant the criticisms on Wikipedia of the Arial font (that it is “generic and lacking distinction”), and that its origin involved sin, in copyright theft:
https://he.wikipedia.org/wiki/%D7%90%D7%A8%D7%99%D7%90%D7%9C_(%D7%92%D7%95%D7%A4%D7%9F)
The wording of the question — “could symbolize something problematic” — made me think there was something deeper to the question.
Perhaps the questioner himself would be so kind as to explain what he meant?
While you’re busy with the copyright problems of “Arial,” which have already been settled in a compromise agreement, you fail to notice the fact that “Ariel” is a city in the occupied territories, and its name expresses the illegal settlements that contravene the Geneva Convention. Oy vey, gevalt!
In shock, S. Z. Levinger, Kokhav HaShahar, M.P. Eastern Binyamin
Well then.
Shatzel,
You should distinguish between ariel and arial.
To Ishay — greetings,
I hereby answer you in the same coin you answered me (more than a year ago) when I responded seriously to something you had said humorously: sometimes one has to understand that things are said in humor (especially when the one shocked by “Ariel” is a resident of the settlement of Kokhav HaShahar in Eastern Binyamin 🙂
And as for your comment itself: am I some kind of pedant who works by strict rules, that I should make an issue out of switching an a to an e? Especially since we maintain that “the vocalization follows the reading tradition,” and to the ear the English a sounds like a segol 🙂
Regards, S. Z. Levinger
Shatzal,
It wasn’t I who failed to understand, so the situation remains as it was a year ago…
Because back then you were joking too…? (:
The discussion between Ishay and me can be found in the comments on Column 38, “The Law of Small Numbers.” On Ishay’s comment from the 23rd of Heshvan 5777 at 19:00, I responded at 19:32, “The main thing is the homework,” and Ishay replied to me again the next day at 10:26 (after Rabbi Michael Abraham’s discussion with Netanel). My words of appreciation there for the site that obligates its readers to “do their homework” remain valid “to this very day.”
Regards, S. Z. Levinger
Apparently Ishay meant that this time too he was joking, and Yisrael understood him and joked as well.
Our discussion has risen to the level of poetry, since it requires interpretations and explanations regarding the intentions and feelings of the writer(s). Indeed, after learning in the last four columns what poetry is, we are now doing a “workshop” to apply those ideas 🙂
I’ll return a bit to prose. Mr. “Nofekh Sapir and Diamond” discussed whether the arial font is suitable for this site.
It seems to me that it is, since the simplicity of the letter forms is an advantage for reading them on a computer screen, as was explained on Wikipedia (to which Haim referred us).
What should be asked is this: on Wikipedia there an alternative font called “Alef” was mentioned, which is also specially adapted for reading on a computer screen, and whose letters seem to me more attractive. The question is whether they are as comfortable to read as arial. I suggest to Oren, the site administrator, that he also check the “Alef” font and decide which font is the most attractive and readable.
Regards, S. Z. Levinger
I thank Anonymous for the interpretation (the correct one, of course). If I ever need a spokesperson, I’ll know whom to turn to.
This goes into the competition for the most bizarre.