חדש באתר: NotebookLM עם כל תכני הרב מיכאל אברהם

Q&A: Parts of the Prayer That Are Not Obligatory

Back to list  |  🌐 עברית  |  ℹ About
Originally published:
This is an English translation (via GPT-5.4). Read the original Hebrew version.

Parts of the Prayer That Are Not Obligatory

Question

Hello Rabbi Michi.
Are the following sections required in prayer, or are they optional?:

  1. Verses of Praise.
  2. The blessings of the Shema (of course, Shema Yisrael itself and the paragraphs must be recited).
  3. Tachanun.
  4. The Psalm of the Day.
  5. The Incense Offering passage.
  6. Aleinu leshabe’ach.

 

Answer

  1. One can omit most of it beyond the two blessings (Barukh She’amar and Yishtabach. It is preferable to add at least one more chapter in the middle, such as Ashrei). A proof of this is that someone who arrives late to synagogue may skip, and according to the Geonim (and this also seems to be the view in the Mishnah Berurah) there is no need to make it up afterward.
  2. The blessings of the Shema are obligatory.
  3. Rivash, responsum 412, wrote that Tachanun is only a custom. Rabbi Ovadia (Yabia Omer, vol. 3, no. 11, sec. 8) permitted someone hurrying to work to omit it. And as is well known, the Jewish people are pretty lax about this.
  4. Merely a custom (Jerusalem Talmud, Ta’anit 4:5). It sounds there as though they wondered whether it may even be said at all without libations, and the conclusion is that it may be said and is certainly not obligatory. But it is noted there that such a custom exists.
  5. It seems to me that, plainly speaking, this is obligatory (“so we will render the offerings of our lips”). But people are generally lax about it, and I do not know the source for that.
  6. Plainly speaking, it seems that this is not obligatory but rather a custom. Only in the Amidah of the High Holy Days is it part of the formal institution of the prayer itself.

But one should know that customs too must be observed (“do not forsake”; vow), and therefore one needs reasons if one wants to be lax. Plainly speaking, annulment of vows is also required (unless the custom was based on a mistake. Here I do not think that is the case. Even if you thought this was a halakhic obligation and it turns out you were mistaken, the broader public thinks so, and I do not think there is a mistake here that uproots the vow retroactively without annulment).

Discussion on Answer

A.H. (2018-03-09)

If one does not say a chapter in between, aren’t the blessings of Verses of Praise considered blessings said in vain?

Michi (2018-03-11)

That is why I wrote that it is proper to add a chapter in the middle. But it is not mandatory; see the halakhic authorities.

Noam (2025-01-01)

1. Are the morning blessings obligatory?
2. Is it permissible to change some of the blessings to a more positive wording: “Blessed is He who made me a man / Blessed is He who made me a woman / Blessed is He who made me Jewish / Blessed is He who made me free”?

Michi (2025-01-01)

1. Yes.
2. In principle, it is forbidden to change the wording of a blessing, especially its essential formula.

Leave a Reply

Back to top button