Q&A: Maimonides' Science
Maimonides' Science
Question
Hello Rabbi,
I would be glad to know why Maimonides studied science, and whether there is any halakhic command to study the sciences. And if not, why did Maimonides study it—wouldn't that count as neglect of Torah study? And you too, Rabbi, I would be glad to know what your approach is to the relationship between Torah and science: does it stem from the desire to learn, or from obligation (if there is an obligation)?
Answer
First, it is permitted to engage also in optional matters. That is how all the halakhic authorities inferred from the contradiction between the Talmudic passages in Berakhot and Menachot. Second, with respect to Maimonides there is certainly no difficulty, since in his view science and philosophy (the Account of Creation and the Account of the Chariot) are a great matter, whereas the discussions of Abaye and Rava are a minor matter. Third, even without going as far as Maimonides did, it is clear that these are worthwhile fields, and it is important to study them even without there being a commandment to do so (see the responsa of Rabbi Moses Isserles, section 9). In my view, this kind of engagement is Torah on the level of the person (even if not on the level of the object studied). You can search here on the site for a fuller explanation.