Q&A: Critical Thinking
Critical Thinking
Question
Hello, Rabbi, and happy Sukkot!
Would you have any tips on how I can acquire analytical skill, philosophical skill, and critical thinking?
I’m a very curious person and thirsty for knowledge. But even if it’s not pleasant to admit it—I feel somewhat shallow-minded. A lot of things have shaken me in the past, and I was even afraid of that. For example, in the past I was afraid, because of doubts in faith / belief that I had, of losing my faith / belief, and I assume that even today I’m afraid of things in that vein, even if not necessarily losing faith / belief.
I know you’re less inclined to recommend books. But in any case, if you have advice or things along those lines, I’d be glad.
Thanks in advance!
Answer
There is an internal contradiction in what you’re saying. If these things shake you, then that will be your conclusion. The fear that critical thinking will unsettle you means that you do not want critical thinking. Critical thinking is not a game, but a way of relating to life, and its essence is that if you reach a different conclusion, you go with it and not with what is accepted. That is, of course, if you have truly become convinced and examined things carefully, and not lightly.
As for the matter itself, I suggest that you study logic. There are also courses and classes in critical thinking. Beyond that, I have no advice other than to think about what you read.
Rabbi, I think there’s a difference between critical thinking and what to do in practice.
I think he can take it upon himself to keep Jewish law and maintain his current situation for X years, and in the meantime think freely in a way that won’t interfere with him.