Idealism kaRabi Moshe Rat

Izimpendulo > Isigaba: Ifilosofi > Idealism kaRabi Moshe Rat
Kobe Ubuzwe ezinyangeni ezi-7 ezedlule

I-BSD
Sawubona Rabi,
Bengifuna ukubuza ukuthi ucabangani ngendlela yokucabanga esekelwa nguMoshe Rat,
Umbono wezwe ongokoqobo awethulayo, uphikisa kabanzi ngokuthi konke okungokoqobo kungokwengqondo, umkhiqizo wokwazi komuntu, ophuma ngokwawo ekwazini okungaphezu kwamandla kaNkulunkulu.
Ngamanye amazwi, okungokoqobo kuwuhlobo lwephupho olukhona ekuqapheleni komuntu siqu, iqiniso kuphela iphupho elihlanganyelwa yibo bonke abantu, hhayi elakho.
1. Lokhu kusekelwe, phakathi kwezinye izinto, ezifundweni ezivela ku-quantum (cishe okuhlobene nomthelela wokubhekwa ezilinganisweni, njll.).
2. Futhi njengezazi zefiziksi ezimemezela ukuthi imizamo yokuthola ubukhona bangempela bento yonke yehlulekile, futhi uma kunjalo okuwukuphela kweqiniso elikhona ukwazi. Ngokwengqondo.
Futhi, ezimeni lapho umsebenzi wobuchopho wehla futhi ukhutshazwa - abantu baba nolwazi olunzulu kakhulu lwengqondo kunesimo esivamile.
Isibonelo ezimweni lapho ucishe ufe noma uphuze izidakamizwa ezithile. Futhi ngaleyo ndlela isondela esimweni sokuqaphela okukhulu kwasekuqaleni. ~ / Ubunye obubodwa. Futhi nokuningi.
4. Ngaphezu kwalokho, ngenxa yokuthi kunezizathu eziningi zale ndlela, futhi ilula futhi uphikisa ukuthi kufanele ithenjwe.
5. Futhi umbono wezwe ongokoqobo awunangqondo. Ngakho esikhundleni sokunamathela embonweni wezwe wangenkathi ephakathi, umuntu angaguqukela ekuthuthukisweni kwemibono emihle.
(Ngicabanga ukuthi unezinye izingxabano eziningi kodwa azibekwanga kuzo zonke).
 
Ngokusekelwe kulezi zindlela, sekukhona labo abakha zonke izinhlobo zamamodeli ukuchaza iqiniso.
Ake sithi ingqondo, ngokwendlela ye-Castrop, imane nje "indlela ukwazi kwethu okubukeka ngayo kobukele ngaphandle." Ingqondo nokwazi akuzona izinto ezimbili ezihlukene, kodwa ingqondo iwukumelela okubonakalayo nokuphathekayo kokuqaphela.
 
 

Shiya amazwana

Izimpendulo ze-1
mikyab Abasebenzi Kuphendulwe ezinyangeni ezi-7 ezedlule

Sanibonani.
URabbi Moshe Rat ungumfundi wangaphambili futhi ngimazisa ngempela. Angihlanganyeli ngemibono yakhe eminingi futhi ikakhulukazi ukuthambekela kwakhe embonweni nasekucabangeni okuhle. Izimpikiswano ozibhale lapha egameni lakhe (angazi imininingwane. Angizange ngifunde) zibonakala zingenasisekelo ngokuphelele kimi, kuhlanganise nesisekelo sazo sesayensi.
Isimangalo sokuthi iqiniso liyiphupho elikhona ekuqapheleni komuntu siqu kubonakala sengathi liyaphikisana ngempela. Ukwazi kwami ​​siqu Ubani? Eyami? Ngiqonde ukuthi ngikhona? Mina ngedwa okhona? Kungani ucabanga ukuthi yimi kuphela engikhona futhi bonke abanye abekho? Futhi lonke iqiniso alikwenzi noma? Futhi uNkulunkulu ukhona? Wazi kanjani?
Futhi mayelana nesisekelo "sesayensi", angizange ngiqonde ukuthi ukuxhumana kwe-quantum bekuyini. Umthelela wokulinganisa eqinisweni ngumbuzo onzima, kodwa imibono ihlukene phakathi kuwo, futhi kusobala namuhla ukuthi "ukulinganisa" akudingi ukuqonda komuntu (ngisho nokulinganisa ngekhompyutha kuphazamisa umsebenzi wamagagasi), ngokuphambene nalokho okwamukelekayo. ezincwadini ezidumile. Futhi kumnandi.

Kobe Uphendule ezinyangeni ezingu-7 ezedlule

Angisekho kuzo zonke izimangalo zakhe, kusukela kulokho engidlule kukho kafushane mayelana nazo.Unezimangalo ezengeziwe ezimbalwa kusizindalwazi sakhe sokulandisa.
Yebo ucabanga ukuthi abanye abantu bakhona. Kodwa njengoba nje ephusheni noma ubani angaphupha kanje emhlabeni wethu i-consciousness iphupha ndawonye endaweni eyaziwayo. Kimina kubonakala sengathi isibonelo somdlalo wekhompiyutha singabonisa amazwi akhe ngendlela enhle. Ngiphinde ngicabange ukuthi kuyindlela yokucabanga yeqiniso futhi kuyindlela ehambisanayo.

Kodwa noma kunjalo,
Okunzima kimi ngale ndaba, ucabanga ukuthi kufanele ukhulume kanjani ngale ndaba? Noma ezindabeni ezinjalo?
Angalethwa kanjani ngempela amaphathi lapha noma laphaya? Futhi cabangela iziphetho futhi wenze isinqumo.
Phela kucacela wonke umuntu ukuthi ngokusho kukaKant abukho ubufakazi bokuthi umkhathi wangempela ukhona kanye nento uqobo (iNuumana). Kodwa sihlala sihlangana nesenzeko kuphela (ngaphandle kokuba khona kwethu uqobo)… Kodwa-ke kungani kunezinto eziphindwe kabili futhi singacabangi ukuthi isenzakalo kuphela esisebenzayo? (Njengensingo ye-Oakham uma ingelapha nhlobo)
Ngibonile ukuthi umbuzo wakho uvela endaweni eshelelayo mayelana nokungabaza okujwayelekile kukhuphukile, futhi mhlawumbe nekhabethe;).
Kodwa, akucaci ukuthi kufanele kuze lapha ngoba akuyona indlela yokungabaza, kodwa incazelo ye-metaphysical yeqiniso.

Mhlawumbe ngizobuza okuphambene, kungani urabi ethatha ububili nokuthi abanye abantu bakhona nokuthi uG d ukhona?
Ngicabanga ukuthi “kubukeka” kanjalo kuye. Futhi asikho isizathu sokukungabaza futhi ngokuvamile ukuqonda kwakhe nemizwa cha? Kodwa umqondo wento enikeza incazelo egcwele yalezi zinto awunakungabaza ngempela ngoba ubonakala ufana nenye inketho * yokuhumusha * / ehlukile. Noma akubonakali yini kuwe ukuthi lokhu kuyisimangalo esilungile (ngoba ekugcineni siphikisana nemibono yokuthi kukhona itafula phambi kwethu)?

Ngiphinde ngacabanga ukuthi kungenzeka ukuthi kwakungamaBohr owabalula kukholamu 383 okunzima kakhulu ukusebenzisa le ncazelo, ngoba kuwulimi olungenabizo (ngaphandle kwabanye abantu) kodwa olunezenzi kanye nokuguquguquka kwazo. Kodwa ngakolunye uhlangothi, kubonakala sengathi ngisho nasemdlalweni wekhompiyutha siphatha izinto njengezikhona. Futhi uma kunjalo futhi ukuvumelana kubonakala sengathi kuyahambisana futhi kuhlangene.

Umlamuli wokugcina Uphendule ezinyangeni ezingu-7 ezedlule

Ngakho esikhundleni sokububula amazwi, wayenyathela phezu kophahla oluphakeme lwensimbi aziwise phansi afe bese evuka ephusheni. Noma wayezonakekela ukukhansela amandla adonsela phansi ephusheni lakhe futhi asivulele izimoto zamaphupho ezintanta emoyeni.

mikyab Abasebenzi Uphendule ezinyangeni ezingu-7 ezedlule

Aniwaqondi lawa magama, futhi angazi ukuthi kufanele kuxoxwe kanjani (noma nibone iphuzu ekwenzeni kanjalo).

Kobe Uphendule ezinyangeni ezingu-7 ezedlule

Uxolo ngokubambezeleka bengimatasatasa bengifuna ukuphawula.
Angizange ngiqonde inani lamaphuzu kulo mugqa.
1. Okokuqala mayelana nokuntuleka kokuqonda amagama.
Ingabe urabi angawuqonda umqondo wokuthi ngoba esikwaziyo kuphela "umbono" wethu hhayi into ngokwayo. Ngakho-ke kungashiwo ukuthi empeleni yonke into ekhona ngaphandle kwabanye abantu, isekuboneni "kwethu" kuphela. Futhi asikho isidingo sokwengeza ku-hypothesis ubukhona bento ngayinye. ~ Njengephupho. Kuphela lapha ukuthi kuyiphupho elihlanganyelwe.

Uma kunjalo.
2. Ngakho-ke manje sinezinketho ezimbili zokuchaza iqiniso.
A. Ngibona itafula futhi kukhona "into enjalo" ngaphandle kimi.
B. Ngibona itafula, kodwa empeleni kusengqondweni yami kuphela hhayi ngaphandle. Uthathwa lapho yisici esixhumanisa lokhu ake sithi u-Gd. Nomxhumanisi ukuze abantu abaningi bazoyibona futhi. Uhlobo lomdlalo wempi wokusebenzisana kukhompuyutha.

Uma kunjalo, ingakhethwa kanjani incazelo "elungile"?
Ngemuva kwakho konke, kuzoba ngokwemibandela ethile ethi ku-A. izwe elinjalo likhona. Futhi ku-B. ukuthi asikaze sihlangane nalo mhlaba ngesesodwa kodwa besilokhu sihlangabezana nawo ngokubona.
Kubonakala kunengqondo ukukhetha incazelo elula uma ichaza idatha efanayo futhi uma kunjalo kufanelekile ukukhetha u-B. Kodwa akungicaceli ukuthi lokhu kulungile kuleli cala. Futhi ikakhulukazi methodological. Kodwa lapha abantu abaningi bacabanga njengo-A.
Futhi uma kunjalo, ngiyabuza ukuthi kufaneleka futhi kunengqondo kangakanani ukuxoxa ngalolu daba.
Ngokuphambene, uma urabi engakwazi ukuxoxa ngakho, pho kungani ecabanga ukuthi uRabi Moshe unephutha futhi uqinisile ??

3. Kungani ungaboni lutho kule ngxoxo? Ingabe kungenxa yokungakwazi ukuxoxa ngakho (futhi uma kunjalo, khona-ke umuntu angakhuluma kanjani “ngephutha” lale ndlela). Noma ngenxa yokuthi ayikho i-NFKM (kodwa ngisho nalokho akulungile, kuningi ezingeni elikhona kanye nefilosofi, njengoba abasekeli bale ndlela bethi)

4. Ngokomzimba, kungenzeka ukuletha zonke izinhlobo zobufakazi njengoba impahla eyinhloko empeleni kuyizinkambu, nokuthi ziziphatha ngendlela eyinqaba (njengokushesha kunejubane lokukhanya, nesivinini esingapheli, ukulondolozwa kwezindleko ezibonisa imithetho engaphandle kwemvelo, njll.). Futhi azikho njengezinto zangempela kodwa kuphela "njengamandla" noma inkambu. Futhi nokho banayo imiphumela eqinisweni. Ngicabanga ukuthi kukhona abathola uNkulunkulu kulokhu. Okuhlanganisa amasimu noma imithetho yemvelo ngayinye.
Lapha kuphela ukuthatha isinyathelo esisodwa ngaphezulu njengengxenye ukwazi okwabiwe.

mikyab Abasebenzi Uphendule ezinyangeni ezingu-7 ezedlule

Xolela ukubambezeleka, kodwa kunzima ukuxoxa, ikakhulukazi njengoba uphindaphinda izinto engizichazile. Ngizophendula kafushane.
1. Ngachaza ukuthi angiwaqondi amagama. Uma kungekho lutho nami anginalo. Pho ubukhona bami busemcabangweni kabani? Eyami? Futhi uma uthi ngikhona futhi kuphela bonke abanye abekho, pho uzuzeni? Uma usuvele ucabange ukuthi kukhona okukhona asikho isizathu sokungeza ukuthi ezinye izinto zikhona. Phela, lena intuition yethu.
2. Incazelo efanele yilokho okubonakala kunembile kimi.
3. Ngempela, akunakuxoxwa. Lokhu akusho ukuthi alikho iqiniso lapha. Lokhu kucabanga akulona iqiniso ngokubona kwami, futhi ngeke kuxoxwe ngakho. Kanjalo nomthetho we-causality ngombono wami futhi kusenzima ukuxoxa ngawo noma ukufakazela labo abangawamukeli.
4. Akukho okuhlanganisa ne-physics. I-Physics ayisho ukuthi izinto azikho, kodwa ukuthi azikho lokho esizibona ziyikho (futhi azinembile).
Lezi zingxabano azithakazelisi kakhulu futhi angiboni iphuzu kule ngxoxo.

Insangu Uphendule ezinyangeni ezingu-7 ezedlule

Kulungile ngiyabonga.
1. Lokhu akulona iqiniso ngokuphelele ngoba yebo bayavuma ukuthi abanye abantu bakhona, futhi iphutha kuphela ekuchazeni kwethu inhloso yokuba khona kwezinto zangaphandle ezingezona ukwazi.
2. Ngiyaqonda, leli gama kuphela elakhelwe phezu kwezimangalo ezengeziwe futhi uma kunjalo thuthukisa ukuqaliswa kokuqala. Njengenhlobo yobufakazi befilosofi kanye nokudalula ku-Gd.
3. Xoxani uma niqonde ikhono lokufinyelela esiphethweni futhi nihlole ukuthi bukhona yini ubuqotho nokuhambisana ekungazini? Kodwa uma kunjalo, ucabangani ngesimangalo sakho ukuthi ngempela ubona isithakazelo kunkulumo-nkulumo. Futhi ezingxoxweni ezijwayelekile...

4. Kulungile, lesi sihloko esithakazelisayo esivela kakhulu ezincwadini ezithandwayo futhi lapha kule sayithi sibuye sivele ngezikhathi ezithile, siphinde sisetshenziswe abantu benkolo kwenye indlela, kanye nabafisi kwenye indawo, kodwa I-Narali idinga ukunwetshwa embuzweni ngokwayo.

mikyab Abasebenzi Uphendule ezinyangeni ezingu-7 ezedlule

1. Ngokusekelwe kulokho othi kukhona abanye abantu? Futhi ukuthi mayelana nabo unolwazi oluqondile, ngokuphambene nokuba khona kwenhloso yamathebula?
3. Ngichazile ezindaweni eziningi ukuthi izinkulumo-nkulumo zimayelana nani. Lezi yizimangalo ukuthi ayikho indlela yokuhlola, ngoba noma ubani oziqinisayo uzokwenqaba noma iyiphi ingxabano ngendlela efanayo (mhlawumbe lokhu kuwumbono wami nje). Ngakho-ke angiboni nzuzo kule ngxoxo.

Kobe Uphendule ezinyangeni ezingu-7 ezedlule

1. Ngicabanga ukuthi kungaphikiswana kakhulu ngokususelwa kulwazi. Kodwa uma kunjalo, yithi itafula elikhona ngempela linjalo.
Ngakho thola. Kukhona okubonayo okungcono?

2-3. Ngiyabonga. manje ngiyayithola.
4. Njengoba ngike ngasho mayelana nobudlelwano phakathi kwesayensi yesimanje nesayensi nefilosofi kanye nemfundiso yenkolo, ngingathanda ukubuza, kuphela ngincamela ukwedlula iconsi esihlokweni kuqala. Ngoba ivame kakhulu ezincwadini nasezincwadini ezidumile. Nakuba izitatimende zakho lapha zimangaza impela (isayensi yesimanje ingase ibonise nokuthi izinto esizibonayo zinjalo ngempela). Uma ngingakhiphanga ngokuphelele inhloso yakho emzuliswaneni 🙂
Ngokweqiniso ngicabanga ukuthi lesi yisihloko esikhulu esanele sekholomu ikakhulukazi ukuthi ungudokotela kuyo.

Shiya amazwana