חדש באתר: מיכי-בוט. עוזר חכם על כתבי הרב מיכאל אברהם.

A question about the mathematical abilities of humans

שו"תA question about the mathematical abilities of humans
שאל לפני 7 שנים

In the book "Two Carts and a Balloon," the rabbi brings up the parable of two tuned clocks in the context of man's adaptation to the world, and concludes that it is more reasonable to claim that there is a coordinating factor (=Gd) between the two clocks, contrary to the conventional view that the mechanism of clock A (=the world) is what drives the mechanism of clock B (=man). In particular, the rabbi refers to man's mathematical ability and claims that there is no reason for such an ability to exist, and it cannot provide a survival advantage.
But is it so? First, we do not have well-developed mathematical and physical intuitions. It is easy for us to think about the most basic concepts, such as distance, shapes, speed, acceleration, which we encounter in everyday life. In connection with these concepts, it is certainly understandable that there is a survival advantage. An animal that knows how to navigate in space, and knows how to decipher when various threats are approaching it, will survive better in the world, and this will continue to develop through the process of natural selection.
The mathematical achievements that are further from intuition have developed thanks to two factors: exceptional geniuses, in whose brains one can see a kind of mutation that includes the refinement of the above-mentioned basic abilities, and a collective effort – contributions from many people (geniuses and just smart people) accumulated over hundreds of years, step by step. Each step contains a little bit of basic intuition, but all together it is already very far from basic intuitions.
Beyond that, we only perceive (or succeed) in areas where there is truly human potential to decipher the world. There may be billions more vashas, ​​or laws of nature, that we are unable to perceive, and never will.
Some argue that quantum mechanics is exactly on this seam. It is on the edge of our intuitions, and indeed there is almost no correspondence between the "clocks". Nor does it need to be, because it is already far from the basic concepts that provide a survival advantage.
It follows, then, that evolution certainly explains mathematical ability, and the simpler and more plausible solution to adjusting the "clocks" lies in it, so why is there a need for a correlation factor?


לגלות עוד מהאתר הרב מיכאל אברהם

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

השאר תגובה

0 Answers
מיכי צוות ענה לפני 7 שנים
All you said are possible suggestions that, in my opinion, are no different from evolution itself. In short, you explained evolution on one foot. Therefore, I have nothing to say about them except what I said about evolution itself. For example, that evolution itself became known to us as a result of our scientific abilities. Therefore, it is difficult to see it as justification for our trust in these abilities. Furthermore, that evolution itself is a result of the laws of nature (without which it would not exist), and this itself proves the existence of the coordinating/planning factor (what I later called "the evidence from the laws").

לגלות עוד מהאתר הרב מיכאל אברהם

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

השאר תגובה

Back to top button