Is the Talmud influenced by external mythologies?
Rabbi Avraham, greetings.
I would like to ask about the rabbi's attitude towards the extent to which Judaism is influenced by external sources. Many times, mythological creatures are mentioned in the legends of the Sages that almost completely correspond to creatures and descriptions from the mythologies of various peoples and a certain spirit that swept the entire world during the Talmud period and was influenced by the beliefs of many peoples and groups. See, for example, the mermaids in Tractate Bekorot, the great Ram, Rabba Bar Bar Hanna who thought he had reached an island and eventually discovered that he was a whale, the hybrid animals mentioned in the various prophecies, and other animals and situations that "mixed" something with the imagination. Often, this is not a general description or an expression of an idea, but rather a determination of an actual fact. Should we think that Judaism is influenced by external sources and was not given in its entirety to Moses from Sinai? Or is it said that it is, except that the Tanais, the Amoraic scholars, the Rishis of the Hidda, and other sages who dealt with the above subjects are only mistaken in some of their statements, and then there is no sense in analyzing their words word for word, but only as historical interpretation without a hint of holiness.
This leads to a bigger question. When we see a spring and next to it we see a stream, let's assume that the stream flows from the spring. Looking at the period and the various customs and examining the Judaism of Narra, it is clear that the Jewish stream came from the era and seemingly has no connection to our present day. Starting with imaginary animals and ending with various "primitive" customs. The relatively inferior status of women, court deaths, and so on. In their time, women were the property of their husbands and if they died by the sword, these principles are no longer valid. Why bother explaining the divine idea behind the sanctification of women when it is clearly seen that this law stems from the spirit of the era? Go ahead and say that the stream stems from a spring located hundreds of kilometers away, even though they are similar in appearance to the water of the nearby spring?
I am a religious person and a layman, and I have searched for an answer in many faith books, both first and last, and have not found an answer to the "spring question" that satisfies my mind and strengthens my faith. I would appreciate the Rabbi's response.
With immense gratitude.
Joseph Kanter.
לגלות עוד מהאתר הרב מיכאל אברהם
Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.
לגלות עוד מהאתר הרב מיכאל אברהם
Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.
השאר תגובה
Please login or Register to submit your answer