Q&A: Customs
Originally published:
This is an English translation (via GPT-5.4). Read the original Hebrew version.
Customs
Question
Hello Rabbi, in your opinion, what is the halakhic weight of custom?
Answer
2.493 pounds.
Discussion on Answer
The question asked here is not serious. One can discuss whether a custom overrides Jewish law and other such issues. But to throw a general, undefined question out into the void is not serious.
Not long ago I wrote a column about questions of this kind.
Column 560
I don’t understand the cynicism, forgive me Rabbi, this is a serious discussion among later authorities about to what extent a custom can override Jewish law. See Maharik, responsum 9, and others; and many disagreed with him.