Q&A: Instructions of the Rabbis
Instructions of the Rabbis
Question
No one expects you to know what goes on behind the scenes in Haredi society,
but if you decided to write about Haredi society and name names, it would have been worthwhile to check the details first.
The real story, which is known to anyone even somewhat familiar with the matter, is perhaps even sadder than the picture you painted, but it is important to be precise:
From the very beginning, Rabbi Edelstein and Rabbi Lando instructed people to obey the authorities, but they feared that a frontal confrontation with Rabbi Kanievsky would cause the Kanievsky family to turn Rabbi Kanievsky’s view into a banner and launch a holy war against the authorities.
The first letter, which said that the yeshiva had not stopped, etc., was a kind of compromise, while in practice in the Ponevezh Yeshiva, for example, students were instructed to study in their rooms, and two days later they were told to close the yeshiva. Again, this was not done dramatically, so as not to enter into a war with Kanievsky.
The letter from the Ministry of Health to Rabbi Edelstein was also a “commissioned” letter, intended to neutralize the Kanievsky family indirectly, since even after Rabbi Kanievsky instructed people not to pray with a minyan, they claimed that the instruction was directed only at Bnei Brak.
It is sad and shocking that while a global pandemic is raging, petty political considerations are being weighed, but in retrospect it was proven that in this way they ultimately managed to harness Rabbi Kanievsky to the wagon.
Answer
Even if you are right, it does not change the picture.
It is not clear why the Rabbi excludes himself from the category of rabbis on this issue.
The common denominator of all the rabbis involved in this matter is that they do not understand the first thing about biology, medicine, viruses, or epidemics. Ignorance reigns, and whoever is more ignorant in these areas reaches a higher rank in the hierarchy of sages. They have all also specialized in the sharpest hairsplitting sophistry in monetary law, but when it comes to the plain meaning of laws of life and death, they are like a blind man groping in the dark; they do not have the slightest clue what, how, or why.
Stupidity is running wild. And the greater the man, the greater his stupidity.
So these great sages do what they have always done in emergency situations: they use the ultimate weapon—mass prayer—during an epidemic… the stupidity of ignorance. And nobody says a word.
And therefore, when a body like the Ministry of Health arrives and makes noise, all those ignoramuses who send their flock to die accept its instructions without demanding, without investigating, and without asking who said so, why they said so, and whether it is even correct.
And people will continue to die, and all those rabbis are already elderly and already in the risk group.
And as we already see in New York, many are dying.
So go on multiplying prayer, and go on arguing about whether or not they violated the Ministry of Health’s instructions.