חדש באתר: NotebookLM עם כל תכני הרב מיכאל אברהם. דומה למיכי בוט.

Q&A: Judaism: Monotheism or Polytheism?

Back to list  |  🌐 עברית  |  ℹ About
Originally published:
This is an English translation (via GPT-5.4). Read the original Hebrew version.

Judaism: Monotheism or Polytheism?

Question

Hello and blessings,
Is belief in angels in Judaism reflective of a monotheistic religion or a polytheistic one? It is not the very act of addressing angels that troubles me, but rather attributing desires and powers to them that are independent of the Creator of the world sounds jarring to me. Of course, it is clear to me that there is a big difference between the biblical angels and the kabbalistic ones; my question is about the kabbalistic ones, such as “Metatron and company.”
Best regards, Benjamin

Answer

I don’t see any difference between those angels and the others.
In any case, how is this different from human beings, who also have will and the ability to act independently of the Creator? Does that mean that someone who believes in free will is a polytheist?

Discussion on Answer

Benjamin Gurlin (2020-08-23)

Rabbi Michi, I asked explicitly about powers that are independent of the Creator of the world, as distinct from human beings, who operate within a given framework of laws (whether the Creator intervenes or not). People turn to angels so that they will act outside that framework of laws. How does that fit together? Seemingly, angels acting independently are subject to a dispute between the Babylonian Talmud and the Jerusalem Talmud?

Michi (2020-08-23)

I don’t understand what the difference is. Human beings also act outside the laws. Free choice goes beyond the laws of physics. In my opinion there is no difference at all. But even if that were true only of angels, I still don’t see any problem with it. They received powers from the Holy One, blessed be He, to act as they do, and that’s all.

Benjamin Gurlin (2020-08-23)

Human beings act outside the laws but are still subject to them; angels have autonomy within their spheres of activity. To the extent that angels received powers from the Holy One, blessed be He, then Judaism is at most based on monolatry, which is one aspect of polytheism, but it is certainly not a monotheistic religion. In monotheism there is no delegation of powers; the one God alone acts (or does not act).
If necessary, I’d be happy to quote direct prayers to angels, such as Metatron, from early literature. Metatron is certainly understood as an independent entity, even if an emanated one.

Michi (2020-08-23)

I don’t understand these hair-splitting arguments. There is no difference at all.
Prayers to angels are an old topic, and there’s no point going over it again.

השאר תגובה

Back to top button