Q&A: Freedom
Freedom
Question
Hello Rabbi,
From what I understood from your words [and as you quote Viktor Frankl],
the concept of freedom means a person's coping within his limitations [that is, the more limitations a person has, the more his freedom is expressed in his room to maneuver, in that he does not surrender to his limitations].
What does room to maneuver within limitation mean—casting off the yoke of enslavement? [That is, for example, if I am obligated by Jewish law, is my freedom expressed in not observing Jewish law? In my opposing it? In not accepting it upon myself?]
Thank you
Answer
There are many forms of freedom: different interpretations of Jewish law, rebellion against Jewish law, conscientious objection, and the like. And of course also observing it despite urges, constraints, and difficulties. That too is freedom.
Discussion on Answer
Absolutely. As long as it's his decision and he shapes his path within the constraints. No point expanding here. It's been explained to death in the series of columns on freedom and liberty.
1. "And of course also observing it despite urges, constraints, and difficulties. That too is freedom."
What does that mean? Is a slave who carries out his master's will [he has no choice] considered a free person??