Q&A: Question
Originally published:
This is an English translation (via GPT-5.4). Read the original Hebrew version.
Question
Question
A follow-up question [I couldn’t manage to write in the comments—is there some problem?]
Regarding an apikores who shows contempt for Torah scholars, what does the Rabbi think his status is today? Does the Rabbi hold that his status is like that of a secular person, and therefore he is coerced / not acting of his own free will, in accordance with the Rabbi’s well-known view? Or since he believes in the Written Torah and the Oral Torah, would he then be liable to the death penalty?
Answer
I don’t understand the question. If he is coerced / not acting of his own free will, then he is coerced / not acting of his own free will. There is no difference between that and coercion in matters of belief.