Q&A: ๐ปPharaoh in Pajamas in the Middle of the Night ๐ป
๐ปPharaoh in Pajamas in the Middle of the Night ๐ป
Question
R’ Alter Yachness, the singer-songwriter of โPharaoh in Pajamas in the Middle of the Nightโ ๐ป, and also โA Lot of Clouds in the Skyโ ๐ธ, and also โFire Fire, Hot Hot,โ and more, had challah separated and many children sang for his recovery.
In the end he passed away on Saturday night, and now there are those singing for the elevation of his soul.
My question:
Is singing for his recovery like saying Psalms for his recovery?
Why didnโt God save him and listen to the prayers-songs?
Is singing for the elevation of his soul like studying Mishnah for the elevation of his soul?
Do we have reliable knowledge of what this gives the dead?
Iโd be happy if the Rabbi has answers even to only some of the questions.
Answer
Happily, I have answers to all the questions. Nobody knows anything about what helps or does not help the dead. Not Psalms, not Kaddish, not songs, and not standing on one leg while separating challah with your tail.