Q&A: Your Response, Please
Your Response, Please
Question
Hi Michi, have a good week.
Haim Sompolinsky says that it is possible to cause a person to choose by means of a certain electric current applied to a certain place in the brain.
https://youtu.be/jIleVs8VRhE?si=L16SXJDBSrC1QD6Q
At minute 1:20.
Your response, please. Thank you very much.
Answer
My response is applause. Do you have a specific question?
Discussion on Answer
Why does this contradict the notion of free will? There is also a mirage, where a person is sure that he really sees something, and that is not true. It is an illusion. So does it follow from this that our entire sense of sight is an illusion? And the same goes for all the visual deceptions that we all know—there are many such cases. It is also possible, by artificial means such as electrical stimulation, to cause a person to imagine that he sees his grandmother standing in front of him. So from now on, every time he sees his grandmother, is that an illusion? The fact that an illusion can be created is a known fact, but that does not mean that everything is an illusion.
How can this study be reconciled with the idea of free choice, if at all?