Q&A: The Statutes of the Nations
The Statutes of the Nations
Question
Hello, honorable Rabbi.
Regarding the prohibitions against following the statutes of the nations and against resembling idol worshippers:
The particulars included in these prohibitions are based on how the nations behaved thousands of years ago. I assume that today either they no longer do these things, or it is very uncommon. Why are things that were meant to distance us from the nations of old, who are no longer around, still binding today?
Thank you very much.
Answer
A distinction should be made between the general principle, which should be applied according to what exists in your own time, and specific Jewish laws that were established in the past (such as red clothing, etc.), where there is room for discussion. With rabbinic enactments, the accepted rule is that even if the reason no longer applies, the enactment does not lapse unless it is formally repealed by a court of equivalent authority and number (although see my article here on the site about repealing enactments). In Torah-level law, there is more room to be lenient, since the specific rules probably constitute only an application of the Torah-level law and not an enactment in themselves, and therefore it is reasonable to interpret them according to the context.