Q&A: Talmud, Second Attempt
Originally published:
This is an English translation (via GPT-5.4). Read the original Hebrew version.
Talmud, Second Attempt
Question
Listen, usually when someone sends you a link to a video or article and asks what you think, you ask them to formulate an actual question. So first I wrote a summary of an article I read, including all the annoying claims in it; then I left a link to that same article, and I wrote two questions that came up for me while reading it. What exactly was wrong with that?
Answer
You open with sweeping statements that have no basis at all. After that you bring a few examples, and those too are baseless. And in the end you cap it off with a general question about why one should listen to the voice of the Sages. That is not how you ask a question.
If you want to ask, formulate a question and not a set of declarations.