Q&A: A Commandment Fulfilled Through a Transgression, and a Positive Commandment Overriding a Prohibition
A Commandment Fulfilled Through a Transgression, and a Positive Commandment Overriding a Prohibition
Question
Hello Rabbi,
When do we say that it is a commandment fulfilled through a transgression, and when do we say that a positive commandment overrides a prohibition?
Thank you very much
Answer
There are several different explanations of this among the medieval authorities (Rishonim). What I mainly remember is Rabbenu David on Pesachim, who brings several approaches on this. For example: a positive commandment overrides a prohibition only when the commandment is being fulfilled at the time of the transgression. The disqualification of a commandment fulfilled through a transgression applies only when the commandment comes to appease. A commandment fulfilled through a transgression applies only in cases of theft. And there are other such distinctions as well.