Q&A: The Attitude Toward the Medieval Authorities
The Attitude Toward the Medieval Authorities
Question
Hello Rabbi. I recently read several of the Rabbi’s articles, and it seemed from them that the Rabbi disagrees quite a few times with the medieval authorities (Rishonim), and even with Amoraim and even Tannaim, in understanding the intent of the Torah—though not in practical Jewish law. How does this fit with the explanation in Two Carts and a Balloon about the decline of the generations, where the Rabbi brings the studio analogy, and it sounds there like it would be very difficult for us to disagree with the medieval authorities in understanding the Torah. I’d be glad to know the Rabbi’s view on this topic, and if there is an article that expands a bit on the subject, I’d be happy to know. Thank you very much.
Answer
Hello.
Indeed, my view has changed somewhat (in degree). I do not disagree with them lightly, but if I am convinced, then yes. More extensive discussion will appear in the trilogy that will be published, God willing, I hope quite soon.
Discussion on Answer
Not at the moment.
And what about the book on Maimonides’ roots (Midah Tovah 5768)?
That one really is coming out within a few weeks, in my estimation. It’s now at the end of the graphic editing stage.
Actually, theology has reached morbid obesity, and is now undergoing bariatric surgery with Dr. Michi.
We are all praying and hoping that the surgery succeeds, and that very soon a young, slim theology will emerge from the operating room, amen, may it be God’s will.
At this point it’s already under anesthesia (for several thousand years now). The truth is that I myself also tend to fall asleep when I see it.
As the writers of Eretz Nehederet put it: “He who sleeps on high.”
What is the book “Maimonides’ Roots (Midah Tovah 5768)”?
Could you give a few details about it?
The articles in their original version appear here on the site. They were updated and edited, and many things were added to them, and they will soon be published as a two-volume book. See here at the beginning of the “Talmudic Analysis” category:
How much longer until the trilogy is supposed to come out? Is there any estimate?