חדש באתר: NotebookLM עם כל תכני הרב מיכאל אברהם

Q&A: Gratitude

Back to list  |  🌐 עברית  |  ℹ About
Originally published:
This is an English translation (via GPT-5.4). Read the original Hebrew version.

Gratitude

Question

Hello, honorable Rabbi, why are gentiles not commanded to recite blessings over food or over wonders of nature such as lightning and thunder, etc.?

Answer

I don’t know. Why are they not commanded regarding association? There we’re already dealing with actual facts.
Perhaps for them there is no value in standing before the Holy One, blessed be He, but rather in preserving the human image/dignity (the seven Noahide commandments).

Discussion on Answer

Boaz (2019-05-02)

Is there no room to say that just as regarding Israel we do not find commandments about character traits because of how obvious they are (as is well known in the name of Rabbi Chaim Vital), so too the descendants of Noah were not commanded about giving thanks because of how obvious it is?

Michi (2019-05-02)

So why is it different for Israel? Though admittedly this is rabbinic.

Shalom Cohen (2019-05-02)

What does “association” mean?

Shalom Cohen (2019-05-02)

Also, the way I understand it, giving thanks for God’s goodness is part of preserving the human image/dignity; gratitude is something moral.

Michi (2019-05-02)

Association is the belief that besides the Holy One, blessed be He, there are other gods together with Him. Gratitude obligates all inhabitants of the world, and obviously gentiles as well. So they are obligated to show gratitude to the Holy One, blessed be He. But gratitude can be expressed in various ways, or even just be felt inwardly. The form of a blessing in our wording is not necessary, and that is imposed only on Israel.
By the way, I once argued that there is a Torah-level obligation of blessing to thank and show gratitude to the Holy One, blessed be He. The rabbinic obligation is only to do so in the specific manner established by the Sages. In that formulation, gentiles are obligated in the Torah-level obligation but not in the rabbinic one.

Leave a Reply

Back to top button