Question

Hello. Regarding the last lecture, about constitutive and directive definitions. I think that even if, for the sake of argument, the debate over how to define a Jew is a constitutive debate, it is still impossible to ignore how that concept has been defined over the years. Just as you cannot call a chair a horse and then dismiss the problem of all the people who are afraid to ride a horse. So Ariel Sharon can call his Jew “Jew 2.0,” and not use the term Jew.