Q&A: Weakness of Will
Weakness of Will
Question
Hello and blessings.
According to my understanding, the above problem begins with the fact that I feel a sense of failure precisely after the act that I regret, since the definition of failure is that I tried to do X and did not succeed in doing X. And then the dilemma pops up: either it was under compulsion, or I chose it—but in any case I did not fail.
But if from the outset we give up defining the feeling as failure, the problem does not begin. I am not denying the feeling/emotion that comes after the act; I am only trying perhaps to say that this is not a feeling of failure in the simple sense as defined above, but rather some other feeling of sadness/disappointment/regret, etc.
I would be happy to hear the Rabbi’s opinion on this direction as a solution to the problem.
Answer
What you are really saying is that there is no such thing as weakness of will. Someone who does not accept the phenomenon of weakness of will is of course not troubled by the problem. That is not a solution to the problem but a denial of its existence.