חדש באתר: NotebookLM עם כל תכני הרב מיכאל אברהם

Q&A: Leavening and Putrefaction

Back to list  |  🌐 עברית  |  ℹ About
Originally published:
This is an English translation (via GPT-5.4). Read the original Hebrew version.

Leavening and Putrefaction

Question

I saw in Atzur here that people think you once dealt a bit with the Sages’ understanding of “se’or and chametz” — what is the difference between leavening and putrefaction, and why fruit juice does not cause leavening, etc.
Full disclosure: I’m not a chemist, even though both my grandfathers were chemists (and one was even a professor); knowledge is not inherited…
So I’d be glad to know whether you have, or whether you know of, material written in an accessible way that tries to analyze, in light of our scientific tools, the way the Sages understood this prohibition. Did they prohibit puffed-up dough? Because of the bubbles? (There are also bubbles in matzot.) Because of the alcohol? Because of the leaven in people’s hearts that comes only to someone who eats dough kneaded with water and not with orange juice (most of which is H2O)? etc.

Answer

I have no idea. I haven’t dealt with it. I assume I brought there things I had heard or read. As far as I know, Rabbi Aharon Katz and Rabbi Shabtai Rappaport have dealt with this extensively, and it’s worth looking for their material, or for them, online.

Discussion on Answer

Reference to a summary article (2021-03-16)

With God’s help, 3 Nisan 5781

A summary and analysis of the various explanations that have been proposed for the distinction between leavening and putrefaction can be found in the article by R. Menachem (Mendy) Bronfman, “What Exactly Makes Chametz ‘Chametz’? The Surprising Solution Offered by Scientific Knowledge,” on his blog “Alei Sefer.”

Wishing you a kosher and joyful Passover,
Yaron Fisch”l Ordner

Leave a Reply

Back to top button