Q&A: Mixed Service in the Army
Mixed Service in the Army
Question
Hello Rabbi,
I am a student in a pre-army preparatory program before enlisting in the army. I have a combat profile, and I will probably be a combat soldier. I also want to defend the country, but I am very afraid of dying. I thought about going for a “light” combat role—air defense and the like. Maybe artillery, which isn’t exactly light, but could suit me. The problem is that the service there is mixed. I don’t really see myself in infantry battalions or special forces. I wasn’t given intelligence, and I do want to contribute. I have thoughts about not going into combat, but the chances aren’t high because my profile is high and the IDF needs fighters.
Do you think it is permissible to enlist in a mixed combat unit?
Thank you very much
Answer
I don’t know exactly what goes on there, so it’s hard for me to answer. I assume it is probably not recommended.
Discussion on Answer
Shmuel Chaim Peleg,
Where did you serve? It is virtually impossible to keep Jewish law in mixed combat service. There is no comparison to working in a civilian office, nor even to serving at the Kirya or in personnel administration.
Why do you assume it is probably not recommended?
Throughout the IDF there is separation between the boys’ and girls’ living quarters.
So what is the difference between being on a mixed base and living in a mixed world?